TLDR
Exceptional sourdough-crust pizza delivering authentic NYC flavor. An underrated, accessible gem that outshines tourist-heavy area options.
Instagram Posts References
The post features the user enjoying casual pizza slices from Upside Pizza, with one slice notably topped with a garlic knot, suggesting a unique and satisfying New York pizza experience.
Details
Renowned for its distinctively flavorful sourdough crust, this pizzeria stands out as a top-tier destination for an authentic New York City slice [17], [22]. It has earned recognition as one of the city's top 25 slices by the New York Times, offering a high-quality alternative to the typical tourist traps [4], [26]. Diners consistently praise its accessibility and freshness, marking it as a local favorite that manages to avoid long, exhausting wait times [23].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Italian-American pizza, highlighted by a signature sourdough crust that many customers find enhances the overall flavor profile [17], [22]. Highly recommended items include pepperoni and mushroom slices, as well as unique offerings like lemon mushroom pizza or even slices topped with garlic knots [10], [25], [32]. While vegan options are available, some customers find the topping variety to be somewhat restrictive [6], [8].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended orders include the classic pepperoni and mushroom slices, or the unique lemon mushroom pizza [10], [25]."
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is highly positive, with many patrons describing the pizza as incredible and an underrated staple of the city [13], [19], [23]. While most find it to be a solid choice, a few visitors have noted that individual experiences can vary, with occasional reports of the slices feeling too heavy or salty [5], [30].
Caveats
Some diners have occasionally found the pizza to be overly heavy or salty, and others have remarked that the available topping options can feel somewhat limited [5], [6], [30].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UPSIDE PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Found the pizza to be a bit too salty."
NegativeFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Highly recommended alongside another local spot."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Considers the pizza at the restaurant to be solid."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Positive endorsement for the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Recommended as a better alternative to a cracker-crust pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Mentioned as a spot that made the NY Times list of top 25 slices in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Mushroom Pizza In Manhattan
"Upside on the west side (around 112th street) is mentioned as having a pretty good lemon mushroom slice."
PositiveFrom post: You Cant Leave Nyc Without Eating
"The Spring Street location of Upside Pizza is highly rated, with the commenter preferring a slice from there over waiting for L'industrie."
PositiveFrom post: You Cant Leave Nyc Without Eating
"Upside Pizza is described as an underrated slice in the city, suggesting its quality is overlooked because it's too accessible and doesn't require long waits."
PositiveFrom post: You Cant Leave Nyc Without Eating
"The commenter finds Upside Pizza's sourdough crust to be special and enhances the flavor, noting its convenience and freshness."
PositiveFrom post: You Cant Leave Nyc Without Eating
"Upside Pizza is recommended as a NYC pizza option for visitors from the UK."
PositiveFrom post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations
"Upside Pizza has a unique sourdough crust."
PositiveFrom post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations
"The best pizza in the area is Upside."
PositiveFrom post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations
"For pizza, Upside Pizza at 39th and 8th is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Times Square Recs Food Services Etc
"Upside Pizza was listed among several other restaurants as a good place to eat near Times Square."
PositiveFrom post: Gushing Positivity Post
"This commenter agrees with the previous statement that Upside Pizza is great."
PositiveFrom post: Gushing Positivity Post
"Upside Pizza is recommended for its slice, which the commenter considers underrated."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"Responding to a comment about Upside Pizza, the author affirmed that it was 'incredible'."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This native New Yorker noted that Upside Pizza looks great, indicating it's a place they recognize or are interested in."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This commenter thanked the original poster for introducing them to Upside Pizza, indicating it was a positive recommendation."
Positive