TLDR
Elevated by a unique, flavorful sourdough crust and consistently high-quality slices. A perfect, underrated stop for an authentic and accessible NYC pizza experience.
Instagram Posts References
The post features the user enjoying casual pizza slices from Upside Pizza, with one slice notably topped with a garlic knot, suggesting a unique and satisfying New York pizza experience.
Details
Renowned for its distinctive sourdough crust, this pizzeria is widely considered an underrated gem in New York City [1], [2]. It has earned a reputation for excellence, even securing a place on city-wide lists for the top slices available [3]. Customers frequently praise its consistent quality, often preferring it over more hyped competitors that require long wait times [4].
Food Overview
The menu features Italian-American pizza staples characterized by a standout sourdough crust that many customers find enhances the flavor [1], [2]. Highly recommended items include the pepperoni and mushroom slices [4], the lemon mushroom slice [5], and the Sicilian pepperoni slice [6], while garlic knots are also a local favorite [7]. The restaurant has been noted as an accessible option for groups, with full pies available at a reasonable price point [8].
Diners consistently recommend the pepperoni and mushroom slices, the unique lemon mushroom slice, and the Sicilian pepperoni slice [4], [5], [6]. Garlic knots are also highly regarded by patrons [7].
Feedback for the pizzeria is overwhelmingly positive, with many diners considering it an essential and underrated destination [1], [2]. While the vast majority of experiences are glowing, a rare critique has noted that the pizza can occasionally lean towards being too salty [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01pepperoni pizza2 mentions
Caveats
While generally well-received, some diners have found the pizza to be slightly too salty [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UPSIDE PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Plan My Once In A Lifetime Nyc Pizza Crawl Doctor
"Listed as the commenter's current favorite for slices."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Cheap Quick Eats Under 10 Near Penn
"Recommends the Sicilian pepperoni slice."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Still Get Great Knots Slice Joints
"The commenter enjoys the garlic knots here."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Found the pizza to be a bit too salty."
NegativeFrom post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Highly recommended alongside another local spot."
Positive