Underrated NYC pizza joint w/ great sourdough crust! A go-to for many, esp. near Times Sq. Try the sausage & pickled pepper slice.
This pizzeria is a highly-regarded spot for New York-style pizza, consistently drawing positive reviews. Many appreciate its convenient locations, with several mentioning it as a go-to option, especially when other popular pizza joints have long lines. Reviewers often highlight the unique sourdough crust and specific slices like the sausage and pickled pepper, or the mushroom slice, as standouts. While generally praised for its crispiness and toppings, some note that certain pizzas can be a bit greasy.
This establishment is celebrated for its New York-style pizza, with a notable emphasis on its unique sourdough crust. Popular recommendations include the sausage and pickled pepper slice and the mushroom slice. While generally well-received for crispiness and generous toppings, some feedback suggests certain pizzas can be on the greasier side.
"The sausage and pickled pepper slice and the mushroom slice are frequently recommended, and the sourdough crust is noted as a unique and positive feature."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards this pizzeria, frequently recommending it as a top pizza choice. While most praise the quality and taste, a few minor critiques mention greasiness on some pizzas.
Important Note
Some pizzas might be on the greasier side.
"The Spring Street location of Upside Pizza is highly rated, with the commenter preferring a slice from there over waiting for L'industrie."
Positive"Upside Pizza is described as an underrated slice in the city, suggesting its quality is overlooked because it's too accessible and doesn't require long waits."
Positive"The commenter finds Upside Pizza's sourdough crust to be special and enhances the flavor, noting its convenience and freshness."
Positive"Upside Pizza is recommended as a NYC pizza option for visitors from the UK."
Positive"Upside Pizza has a unique sourdough crust."
Positive"The best pizza in the area is Upside."
Positive"For pizza, Upside Pizza at 39th and 8th is recommended."
Positive"Upside Pizza was listed among several other restaurants as a good place to eat near Times Square."
Positive"This commenter agrees with the previous statement that Upside Pizza is great."
Positive"Upside Pizza is recommended for its slice, which the commenter considers underrated."
Positive"Responding to a comment about Upside Pizza, the author affirmed that it was 'incredible'."
Positive"This native New Yorker noted that Upside Pizza looks great, indicating it's a place they recognize or are interested in."
Positive"This commenter thanked the original poster for introducing them to Upside Pizza, indicating it was a positive recommendation."
Positive"The author listed Upside Pizza with pepperoni and mushroom slices as favorites from their NYC trip."
Positive"Upside Pizza was mentioned as a place visited but not pictured in the original post."
Neutral"The commenter suggested Upside as an affordable pizza option, with regular pies costing around $28 and designed to feed more than five people."
Neutral"This user mentioned Upside Tomato Pie (likely referring to Upside Pizza) as having vegan pizza options."
Positive"The user expresses dissatisfaction with Upside Pizza."
Negative"Upside, a new pizza place nearby, was recommended for its great pizza. However, the user noted that their topping options are restrictive. This is in response to a request for pizza recommendations near Koreatown."
Neutral"The original poster found a slice from Upside Pizza to be a bit too heavy and greasy, but still enjoyable."
Neutral
