Last Updated: 13 days ago
Phone: (646) 943-5135
Address: 45 WEST 35 STREET 10001
Wildly over-the-top milkshakes & burgers that are a hit with kids. Some say it's a nostalgic spot, others find it disappointing.
This American eatery gained significant popularity for its over-the-top, visually stunning milkshakes, which are a major draw for families and younger crowds. While burgers are also a common recommendation, the restaurant's reputation appears to be somewhat divided. Some diners recall fond memories and love the creative desserts, while others have found the food underwhelming and suggest it may not live up to its past hype.
The American cuisine offered here is best known for its extravagant and visually impressive milkshakes, often described as 'ginormous' and topped with candy and cake layers, making them a hit with kids. Burgers are also frequently recommended. However, there are negative reviews mentioning overcooked proteins and bland appetizers, with one user describing their shakes as the worst.
"The milkshakes are frequently highlighted for their extravagant presentation and are recommended for those seeking a fun, visually appealing treat, especially for children. Burgers are also commonly suggested."
Customer feedback is mixed. While some patrons recall positive past experiences and recommend the restaurant for its visually appealing milkshakes and burgers, others have had very disappointing experiences, describing the food as mediocre or the shakes as the worst. There's a sentiment that the restaurant might be coasting on past hype.
Important Note
Some customers have reported very negative experiences with the food quality, including overcooked proteins and mediocre appetizers. One reviewer specifically called the shakes the worst they had ever had.
"Black Tap Burger on 35th street is recommended for burgers, with the added suggestion of getting a visually impressive milkshake afterwards, which is expected to delight a child."
Positive"BlackTap is known for its "ginormous" milkshakes, which are topped with candy and cake layers and are suitable for sharing."
Positive"This user had a positive experience dining outside at Craft during the pandemic, finding the food solid, but feels they need to return for a more complete assessment."
Neutral"Craft was included in a comprehensive list of restaurants that did not make it onto the 2025 NY Times list."
Neutral"This user recalls Craft being amazing two decades ago but suggests it may now be coasting on an old reputation, implying a decline in quality."
Neutral"This user had a very disappointing birthday dinner at Craft, finding every dish underwhelming or mediocre, with overcooked proteins and bland appetizers, compounded by an unhelpful and un-vibe-reading waiter."
Negative"Craft was mentioned as a restaurant that fell off the NY Times list."
Neutral"Suggests Black Tap for their cool milkshakes."
Positive"A commenter recommended Black Tap as a burger spot, particularly if the picky eater enjoys milkshakes."
Positive"The commenter recalls that Black Tap was a popular spot ("the spot") in 2016 when they were a sophomore in high school."
Neutral"Although they haven't been in years, the commenter fondly recalls being obsessed with the fried pickles from Black Tap."
Positive"Reflecting on a past experience, the commenter described Black Tap as "garbage" and claimed they served the worst shakes ever."
Negative"The commenter mentioned that they used to frequent Black Tap back when they were in high school."
Neutral"The commenter recalls the significant hype around Black Tap's opening years ago but hasn't thought about it recently."
Neutral"The commenter notes that tween locals still visit Black Tap."
Neutral"Black tap has wild over the top looking milkshakes super fun for kids!"
Positive
