Updated
Phone: (646) 943-5135
Address: 45 WEST 35 STREET 10001
Wild, over-the-top milkshakes perfect for kids & teens; burgers & fried pickles also popular. Some mixed reviews on overall food quality, but a definite visual spectacle.
This American eatery is known for its over-the-top, Instagram-worthy milkshakes that are a hit with kids and teens. While some diners recall immense hype from years past, recent feedback suggests a mixed experience with the food. Some praise the fried pickles and duck, while others found dishes underwhelming, with overcooked proteins and bland appetizers.
The American cuisine here is largely defined by its extravagant and visually striking milkshakes, often adorned with candy and cake, making them a highlight for many. Burgers and fried pickles also receive positive mentions. However, there are criticisms of the overall food quality, with some experiences describing overcooked proteins and bland appetizers, suggesting a potential inconsistency in execution.
"Highly recommended are the visually spectacular and over-the-top milkshakes, often adorned with candy and cake. The fried pickles and duck have also received positive mentions."
Customer sentiment is divided, with a strong positive reaction to the visually stunning and fun milkshakes, especially for younger diners. However, some patrons have found the food quality to be disappointing, with specific criticisms of execution and flavor.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest the restaurant might be coasting on past hype, and there are conflicting opinions on the taste and quality of the food, particularly the milkshakes.
"Describes the 'Brooklyn Blackout' milkshake at Black Tap as looking great and over-the-top but tasting horrible and repulsive, leading to an upset stomach. Contrasts this with a positive experience at Brooklyn Farmacy."
Negative"States that the milkshakes at Black Tap are insanely over-the-top with toppings and also taste amazing."
Positive"Simply lists Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer."
Neutral"Confirms Black Tap still exists and that their daughter was thrilled by the milkshake."
Positive"Categorizes Black Tap as serving 'Weird, over-the-top Instagram stuff' in terms of milkshakes."
Neutral"Asks if Black Tap still exists, referencing their 'decked out' milkshakes."
Neutral"Black Tap Burgers is mentioned as a sit-down restaurant option in Lower Manhattan, Tribeca, East Village, or LES areas that is suitable for takeout."
Neutral"For a 10th birthday, this restaurant offered "crazyshake" milkshakes that were large and came with a slice of cake on top."
Positive"Black Tap Burger on 35th street is recommended for burgers, with the added suggestion of getting a visually impressive milkshake afterwards, which is expected to delight a child."
Positive"BlackTap is known for its "ginormous" milkshakes, which are topped with candy and cake layers and are suitable for sharing."
Positive"This user had a positive experience dining outside at Craft during the pandemic, finding the food solid, but feels they need to return for a more complete assessment."
Neutral"Craft was included in a comprehensive list of restaurants that did not make it onto the 2025 NY Times list."
Neutral"This user recalls Craft being amazing two decades ago but suggests it may now be coasting on an old reputation, implying a decline in quality."
Neutral"This user had a very disappointing birthday dinner at Craft, finding every dish underwhelming or mediocre, with overcooked proteins and bland appetizers, compounded by an unhelpful and un-vibe-reading waiter."
Negative"Craft was mentioned as a restaurant that fell off the NY Times list."
Neutral
