TLDR
Hand-rolled, Montreal-style bagels that freeze perfectly. A bougie, popular staple for unique cream cheese spreads and inventive sandwiches.
Reddit Sentiment for BLACK SEED BAGELS(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Black Seed Bagels is listed as one of the food vendors in Chelsea Market, known for its bagels. It's presented as a key stop for those seeking a classic New York food experience.
Details
Known for its distinct Montreal-style bagels that freeze well [7], this establishment is a popular destination in Rockefeller Plaza [11]. While many customers laud the shop as a top choice for their morning bagel [10], opinions on specific specialty items like the pizza bagel remain polarized [1].
Food Overview
Specializing in Montreal-style bagels [7], the menu features inventive spreads and sandwiches, including well-liked ramp cream cheese [9]. While many find the bagels flavorful, the chili crisp cream cheese has been described as flavorful but lacking the advertised spice [5], [6], and the pizza bagel has received specific criticism for its sauce and cheese quality [1].
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is generally positive, with customers particularly appreciating unique seasonal offerings like ramp cream cheese [9] and occasional acts of unexpected staff kindness [3]. Some minor friction exists regarding app payment integration [2] and inconsistency with specialty items like the pizza bagel [1].
Caveats
The pizza bagel has been noted as a disappointing menu item due to its flavor profile [1]. Additionally, users have reported that the chili crisp cream cheese does not meet the expected spice level [5], [6], and some patrons have encountered difficulties with the restaurant's payment app [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BLACK SEED BAGELS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help With Food Recommendations First Time Trip
"The commenter dislikes these bagels but notes they are located in Rock Center and are popular."
NegativeFrom post: Where Are The Best Bagels To Pair With A Spread
"This user mentions Black Seed as a preferred bagel place."
PositiveFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"This user suggested that a 'bougier' option like Black Seed might be willing to rent out their space for an event."
NeutralFrom post: Seasonal Ramp Dishes
"The commenter likes the ramp cream cheese offered at Black Seed Bagels."
PositiveFrom post: Places With Cream Cheese Spicier Than JalapeñO
"This user tried the chili crisp cream cheese at Black Seed Bagels and found it flavorful but not particularly spicy."
NegativeFrom post: Places With Cream Cheese Spicier Than JalapeñO
"A user recalled seeing a sign at Black Seed Bagels advertising chili crisp cream cheese."
NeutralFrom post: Pastriesbagels To Bring Home
"Black Seed Bagels is suggested as a place for bagels that freeze well, noted for their Montreal style."
PositiveFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user suggested Black Seed Bagel might be Montreal-style and found them to be pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: Kindest Thing That Was Happened To You In A Nyc
"A commenter received a $10 gift card from an employee at Blackseed Bagel for no apparent reason, an unexpected gesture that they have yet to use."
PositiveFrom post: Inkind Payment Question
"The user inquired about payment options at Black Seed Bagel, noting that the app did not automatically sync with the bill and only presented the option to use their $25 cashback. They were unsure if the system would combine wallets or if their cash was not linking properly."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Bagels Black Seed Essabagel Bagel Pub Bagel
"The author found the pizza bagel unpleasant, noting a poor sauce taste and an excessive amount of cheese that lacked flavor. This experience was not great."
Negative