Next.js logo

THE MERMAID INN

Updated

Phone: (212) 799-2666

Address: 227 10 AVENUE 10011

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A go-to for oysters & seafood w/ a relaxed vibe [1]. Known for its amazing mac & cheese [2] & affordable lunch deals.

Reddit Sentiment for THE MERMAID INN(based on 5 Reddit opinions)

80% Positive20% Neutral

Tags

seafood 3american 2View All

Neighborhoods

Chelsea

Instagram Posts References

The Mermaid Inn's mac and cheese has been acclaimed as one of the best five in Manhattan. The post notes the dish's exceptional cheesiness as a key factor in its inclusion, making it a highly recommended option for comfort food enthusiasts in Chelsea.

Details

This seafood and Italian restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere and is a consistently satisfying option, particularly noted for its lunch deals and excellent oysters [1]. It has garnered acclaim for dishes like its exceptionally cheesy mac and cheese, considered one of the best in Manhattan [2]. The Mermaid Inn is a strong contender for special occasions, with multiple locations to serve its patrons.

Food Overview

Specializing in seafood and Italian cuisine, The Mermaid Inn is lauded for its fresh oysters and a standout mac and cheese dish praised for its cheesiness [1], [2]. The restaurant is also recognized for offering an affordable lunch deal, making it a consistently satisfying choice.

Highlights / Recommended

"The mac and cheese at The Mermaid Inn is a highly recommended dish, celebrated for its exceptional cheesiness and considered among the best in Manhattan [1]. Oysters are also a notable feature of the menu."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive view of The Mermaid Inn, appreciating its seafood and oyster offerings, as well as a notable mac and cheese dish [1], [2]. It's frequently recommended for both casual meals and special occasions.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE MERMAID INN

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1lz6z8g/lunch_for_foodies/
This comment recommends The Mermaid Inn as a great choice for oysters and seafood in a relaxed atmosphere, also mentioning a good lunch deal.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1ms30ep/seeking_birthday_restaurant_recommendations/
The Mermaid Inn is recommended as a suitable birthday restaurant option, with the commenter noting its multiple locations.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1ms30ep/seeking_birthday_restaurant_recommendations/
This user had The Mermaid Inn in mind for a past meal and remembered it positively, making it a strong contender for their birthday celebration.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1l0rafm/dinner_for_10_last_min_this_saturday_night_soho_w/
The Mermaid Inn on 9th Avenue is suggested as a potential option for a group dinner.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Seeking Birthday Restaurant Recommendations

"The user expressed that they had previously considered The Mermaid Inn for a meal and remembered it positively, making it a strong contender for their birthday celebration."

Positive
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Seeking Birthday Restaurant Recommendations

"The commenter recommended The Mermaid Inn, noting that it has multiple locations and appears to meet the user's criteria for a birthday restaurant."

Positive
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Lunch For Foodies

"The Mermaid Inn is a great choice for oysters and seafood, providing a relaxed atmosphere with solid cocktails. It's noted for often having an affordable lunch deal, making it a consistently satisfying option for a Friday meal."

Positive
Jul 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner For 10 Last Min This Saturday Night Soho W

"Mermaid Inn on 9th Avenue is suggested as a potential option for the dinner."

Neutral
Jun 1, 2025View Comment →