TLDR
Sophisticated West Village seafood tavern featuring an elite raw bar, inventive European-inspired plates, and a sprawling, Old World-focused wine list.
Instagram Posts References
Capitaine NYC is a new seafood tavern located in the West Village, opened by the same team that was behind Libertine. The restaurant offers both brunch and dinner services, and is noted for its luxurious caviar sandwich served on toasted milk bread with French egg salad, a seafood platter featuring oysters, shrimp, and peach scallop crudo, and an incredible hamachi crudo with yuzu and pistachio. The reviewer also enjoyed a rich chocolate ice cream cake and a hot chocolate chip cookie topped with ice cream. The ambiance is described as having a seafood tavern feel, suitable for both brunch and dinner.
Capitaine offers oysters, martinis, and a caviar sandwich reminiscent of Grand Central Oyster Bar. It is suggested for a first date.
Capitaine NYC is a seafood restaurant located in the West Village, offering a diverse menu of oceanic delights. The post features several of their signature dishes, including dorade, a lobster roll with hollandaise sauce, sea scallop crudo, tuna toast, and hiramasa tonnato. The presentation of the food is noted as artistic, and the overall experience suggests a high-quality dining destination for seafood enthusiasts.
Vicki Denig reviews Capitaine, a New England-style seafood tavern in the West Village with a wine list centered on value-driven bubbles and crisp whites.
Sonal Shah reviews Capitaine, an approachable West Village seafood tavern that has transformed into a neighborhood staple perfect for martinis, oysters, and elevated pub fare.
Capitaine, a new West Village seafood spot from the duo behind Chateau Royale, offers a refreshing take on European seafood traditions and classic oyster bar fare. Explore their raw bar, innovative starters, and hearty entrees in a stylish mid-century inspired setting.
Details
Located in the West Village, this New England-style seafood tavern features an elegant mid-century ambiance with dark wood paneling and booth seating [1]. The menu highlights European seafood traditions, showcasing a fresh raw bar, inventive starters like sea urchin-topped deviled eggs, and sophisticated main courses [1]. While many diners praise the high-quality raw bar and wine list, others have expressed mixed feelings regarding the consistency of the cooked entrees [6].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in New England-style seafood, featuring a standout raw bar with oysters, enormous shrimp, and scallop crudo [1], [6], [11]. While the raw bar is widely celebrated, cooked dishes receive mixed reviews; recommended items include the caviar sandwich, whitefish brandade croquettes, and the whole dorade, whereas some diners find the lobster roll and wagyu burger inconsistent or overly rich [1], [5], [6], [11].
Highly recommended items include the decadent caviar sandwich on toasted milk bread, the perfectly cooked large shrimp cocktail, and the fresh sea scallop crudo [1], [6], [11].
Visitor feedback is polarized; while the raw bar and specific appetizers consistently receive high praise, some guests find the cooked entrees hit-or-miss and have criticized the concept for relying too heavily on social media hype [6], [8].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01lobster roll7 mentions
- 02caviar sandwich3 mentions
- 03wagyu burger2 mentions
- 04dorade2 mentions
- 05hiramasa tonnato2 mentions
Caveats
Some diners have noted that certain cooked dishes, such as the wagyu burger and lobster roll, can be polarizing or inconsistent in preparation [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CAPITAINE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Corner Stores Next Sibling Highlights French
"Reflects that the restaurant is a cynical refresh capitalizing on social media hype."
NegativeFrom post: The Corner Stores Next Sibling Highlights French
"Describes the restaurant as a miss, noting that the raw shellfish was the only highlight."
NegativeFrom post: The Corner Stores Next Sibling Highlights French
"Mentions the restaurant seems to be performing well in terms of popularity."
PositiveFrom post: Capitaine Quite Pleasant Evening In The West
"Clarifies that while the lobster roll was too rich, the bun itself was enjoyable."
NeutralFrom post: Capitaine Quite Pleasant Evening In The West
"Criticizes the cooked food preparation while acknowledging the raw bar quality."
Negative