Historic NYC tavern w/ classic American eats & festive holiday vibes. Go-to for drinks & casual bites.
Step into a piece of New York history at this iconic tavern, established in 1864 and renowned for its classic American fare and festive atmosphere. It's a beloved spot for pre-dinner drinks, cocktails, and a casual neighborhood dining experience, making it a year-round favorite and a particularly magical destination during the holidays.
The food is generally considered classic American and tavern-style, with burgers frequently recommended. While some describe the food as 'mid,' others find it to be a solid, unpretentious choice for a neighborhood spot.
"Burgers are frequently highlighted as a must-try, with multiple recommendations specifically for this dish."
Customers praise the restaurant's historic ambiance, affordable cocktails, and classic American dishes, making it a year-round favorite, especially during the holidays.
Important Note
While generally well-regarded, some customers find the food to be only 'mid' or average.
"Pete's Tavern was suggested as a consistently good option during the holiday week."
Positive"This user recommended Pete's Tavern."
Positive"This user recommended Pete's Tavern."
Positive"This user suggested Pete's Tavern for cozy booths, potentially for dinner."
Positive"This user recommends Pete's for its Christmas decorations."
Positive"The user is considering switching out Pete's Tavern for a different post-dinner option in the West Village due to its festive and Christmas-specific vibe."
Neutral"This user noted that they and their girlfriend frequently visit Pete's Tavern and that reservations are currently unavailable."
Neutral"This user suggested Pete's Tavern in response to a search for a holiday-themed bar with good wings in Manhattan."
Neutral"This user suggested Pete's Tavern as a Christmas-themed bar/restaurant."
Positive"At Pete's Tavern, the staff mistakenly believed the commenter was a relative of the owner, providing a prime table and exceptional attention. Although the confusion was cleared up, they still comped the meal, which was a humorous and appreciated experience."
Positive"Suggested visiting Pete's Tavern in Union Square for a drink as part of a Christmas-themed outing."
Positive"This user recommended the burger at Petes Tavern."
Positive"This establishment offers significantly better food than Rolfs, although the menu is primarily bar food. It is also noted for its extensive Christmas decorations."
Positive"Pete's tavern is recommended as a casual, neighborhood restaurant with bar seating, which is ideal for solo diners."
Positive"This restaurant/tavern is recommended as a dining option."
Neutral"This restaurant/tavern is recommended as a dining option in the Gramercy Park area."
Neutral"Recommends Pete’s Tavern for burgers."
Positive"Suggests Pete’s Tavern as a burger spot that surprisingly hadn't been mentioned."
Positive"The food is considered extremely mid but very American."
Neutral"The food is considered mid."
Negative
