Historic tavern vibes with classic American eats & affordable cocktails.
Step back in time at this iconic NYC tavern, established in 1864, offering a genuine taste of history with its classic American dishes and a lively bar scene. It's a beloved spot for both its affordable cocktails and its role as a charming neighborhood gathering place. While the food is often described as solid tavern fare, the real draw is the unique, historic ambiance that transports you to another era.
The cuisine is primarily classic American and bar food. While some dishes, particularly burgers, are frequently recommended, others are described as 'mid' or average. The overall consensus is that the food is decent and fits the tavern atmosphere, with a notable mention of good steak.
"The burgers are frequently recommended as a standout dish, and steak is also mentioned positively."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, appreciating the historic atmosphere, affordable drinks, and classic American fare. Some find the food to be average, but it's often considered good value for the price.
Important Note
Some customers find the food to be average or 'mid'.
"This user recommended the burger at Petes Tavern."
Positive"This establishment offers significantly better food than Rolfs, although the menu is primarily bar food. It is also noted for its extensive Christmas decorations."
Positive"Pete's tavern is recommended as a casual, neighborhood restaurant with bar seating, which is ideal for solo diners."
Positive"This restaurant/tavern is recommended as a dining option."
Neutral"This restaurant/tavern is recommended as a dining option in the Gramercy Park area."
Neutral"Recommends Pete’s Tavern for burgers."
Positive"Suggests Pete’s Tavern as a burger spot that surprisingly hadn't been mentioned."
Positive"The food is considered extremely mid but very American."
Neutral"The food is considered mid."
Negative"Recommended for its setting, neighborhood, affordable cocktails, and classic American dishes."
Positive"Recommends Pete's Tavern."
Positive"A commenter suggests visiting bars that offer a sense of NYC history, listing Pete's Tavern as an example."
Neutral"Recommended as a good spot for both beers and cocktails, although it lacks a view."
Neutral
