TLDR
Must-try pizza joint feat. acclaimed white mushroom & sausage w/ pickled peppers pies. Can be a bit pungent w/ parmesan but worth it!
Details
This popular pizza spot offers a delicious array of pies and slices, consistently praised by patrons. From their standout white mushroom slice to the highly recommended Sausage and Pickled Peppers pie, there's a flavor for every pizza enthusiast. While many rave about the quality and taste, some mention a strong Parmesan smell that might be noticeable to sensitive individuals.
Food Overview
Customers consistently praise the pizza, with the white mushroom slice and the Sausage and Pickled Peppers pie being frequently recommended. One commenter noted that the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe slice is no longer available. A few patrons have mentioned a strong Parmesan smell, which might be a consideration for those sensitive to it.
Caveats
Some customers have noted that the restaurant can have a strong Parmesan smell, which might be off-putting to those sensitive to it.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UPSIDE PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This user mentioned the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe slice at Upside Pizza used to be available."
NeutralFrom post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This user mentioned Upside Pizza on 40th & Madison as an option."
NeutralFrom post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This commenter recommended Upside Pizza, located at 4th between 5th Ave and Madison, as a good choice. They noted it can be 'heavy' and have a strong smell if one is sensitive to Parmesan."
NeutralFrom post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This user enthusiastically recommended getting the Sausage and Pickled Peppers pie at Upside Pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This commenter recommended Upside Pizza on 40th near Madison as the best pizza within a reasonable walk of the user's hotel."
Positive