Last Updated: 3 months ago
Phone: (917) 502-7279
Address: 205 WEST 57 STREET 10019
Hearty American diner w/ huge portions & tempting desserts. Lively yet conversation-friendly atmosphere.
This classic American diner offers a generous dining experience with remarkably large portion sizes, making it a popular choice for families and those seeking hearty meals. While the main courses are substantial, patrons often rave about the appealing desserts, though many find themselves too full to indulge. The atmosphere is noted for being lively yet conducive to conversation, making it suitable for casual dates.
The diner serves classic American fare with a significant emphasis on large portion sizes. While the main dishes are plentiful, the desserts are visually appealing and highly recommended, though often unattempted due to the sheer size of the main courses.
"While specific dishes aren't consistently highlighted, the desserts are noted as visually appealing and tempting, though often unattempted due to the substantial main course portions."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, praising the good food, reasonable prices, and generous portion sizes. The lively yet conversational atmosphere is also a plus.
Important Note
The portion sizes are very large, which may lead to diners being unable to try the highly recommended desserts.
"The original poster reported that they ended up going to Carnegie Diner and had a lovely time, expressing a desire to try other recommended places later."
Positive"Carnegie Diner was positively reviewed for having good food and prices, with an atmosphere that was lively enough but still quiet enough for conversation. The commenter also humorously noted it was a good place for a date."
Positive"A commenter affirmed that Carnegie Diner is '100%' good and reasonably priced."
Positive"The food at Carnegie Diner is described as pretty good with huge servings. The desserts also looked amazing, but the commenter had never had the chance to try them due to the large main course portions."
Positive"The original poster suggested Carnegie Diner as a potential dinner option for its theater menu and kid-friendly choices."
Neutral"Carnegie Diner is mentioned as a suggestion."
Positive"The chicken fried steak at Three Decker Diner is highlighted as being exceptional, with a user noting they never see it elsewhere."
Positive"Carnegie Diner across the intersection is decent and close."
Positive
