TLDR
Old-school NYC burger joint w/ insane burgers & great atmosphere. A classic, no-fuss burger experience.
Reddit Sentiment for PAUL'S DA BURGER JOINT(based on 19 Reddit opinions)
Details
This classic New York City burger joint is an institution known for its straightforward, no-fuss burgers [1]. While some recent reviews suggest a decline in quality and service, others maintain it's a go-to spot for a satisfying burger experience [2], [3]. It's a place that evokes nostalgia and a consistent craving for a traditional burger.
Food Overview
Primarily known for its burgers, this establishment is considered an old-school NYC institution. While some patrons describe the burgers as 'insane' and a consistent favorite, others have noted a decline in quality and even experienced illness [1], [2], [3]. Some find the burgers to be just 'okay' and prefer other local spots for a similar burger experience [4]. The pickles have also been humorously mentioned as a potential highlight [5].
Caveats
Recent reviews suggest a potential decline in food quality and service, with some users reporting negative experiences and others finding the burgers to be only average [1], [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PAUL'S DA BURGER JOINT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Is The Best Classic Burger Between These
"This commenter recommends Paul's da Burger Joint as a go-to for classic, no-fuss burgers."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Have Any Rec For To Go Lunch Places In The
"Paulie's Da Burger Joint is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Anyone Have Any Rec For To Go Lunch Places In The
"Paulie's Da Burger Joint is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Im Looking For The Cheesiest Cheeseburger In Nyc
"Described as an old-school NYC institution with insane burgers and a great atmosphere, implying it's a solid choice for a burger."
PositiveFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This user reported getting very sick the last time they ate at Paul's da Burger Joint."
NegativeFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This commenter suggests that Joe Jr or Veselka are better options for burgers than Paul's da Burger Joint."
NegativeFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This commenter is asking about the current quality of the burgers at Paul's da Burger Joint, specifically mentioning fresh jalapenos, as they haven't been in almost 20 years."
NeutralFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"In response to a positive comment about Paul's da Burger Joint, this user stated that 'we know... we know it's just okay'."
NeutralFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This user humorously suggests that Paul's da Burger Joint might be best known for its pickles."
NeutralFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This commenter enjoyed the atmosphere at Paul's da Burger Joint but found the burger itself to be only average. They prefer JG Melon or Corner Bistro for a similar style of burger."
NeutralFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This commenter expresses strong agreement with the original post, stating Paul's da Burger Joint is their favorite spot for a classic burger and steak fries. They used to visit weekly for about 10 years."
PositiveFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"Despite negative reviews, this user claims they recently had good service and great quality at Paul's da Burger Joint."
PositiveFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"A local resident mentions that Paul's da Burger Joint is just 'okay' despite living nearby."
NeutralFrom post: These Best Burger Lists Have A Glaring Error
"This commenter states that Paul's da Burger Joint is terrible now with worse service and is always empty. They believe a classic restaurant must remain good to retain its status."
NegativeFrom post: I Asked This Sub For The Best Pizza Rec And Got
"The user expressed amusement at the idea of Paul's Da Burger Joint being compared favorably to high-end burger places like 4 Charles Prime Rib."
NeutralFrom post: I Asked This Sub For The Best Pizza Rec And Got
"The user stated that the rankings had changed and Paul's Da Burger Joint was no longer ranked second."
NeutralFrom post: I Asked This Sub For The Best Pizza Rec And Got
"The user found Paul's Da Burger Joint being ranked second for burgers to be absurd."
NegativeFrom post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg
"Paul's is listed as a favorite, along with Minetta and Red Hook."
PositiveFrom post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg
"This user consistently returns to Paul's Da Burger Joint, indicating it remains a favorite."
Positive