Retro diner vibes w/ classic American eats – think amazing pancakes, hearty hash, & sweet treats. Great for comforting meals & casual celebrations.
This Brooklyn diner offers a nostalgic trip with its 1940s-inspired decor and classic American fare. It's a place where families can gather for comforting meals, from breakfast staples like pancakes and corned beef hash to evening treats like mozzarella sticks. The diner also surprises with unique dessert options and a cozy atmosphere suitable for casual celebrations.
The diner excels in classic American comfort food, with standout pancakes and bacon frequently mentioned. While some dishes are hit or miss, the overall feedback highlights well-executed diner staples, and special dessert items like Petee's chess pie are also recommended. It's a place for familiar, satisfying meals.
"Customers particularly recommend the pancakes and bacon, with Petee's chess pie also being highlighted as a noteworthy dessert option."
Customers generally have a positive view of the diner, appreciating its nostalgic atmosphere and classic comfort food offerings, with specific praise for items like pancakes and bacon.
Important Note
Some reviewers note that while certain dishes like pancakes and bacon are excellent, other items on the menu can be hit or miss.
"The user collects matchbooks from various NYC restaurants and Montague Diner is one of them."
Neutral"A classic diner experience is suggested, with Montague Diner being a nearby option."
Positive"This diner is located on Montague Street and was suggested as a lunch option."
Neutral"This user recommended Montague Diner, describing it as a diner created by Hollywood individuals with a vision of an ideal diner. It also reportedly takes reservations."
Positive"A local diner's grilled chicken with mashed potatoes and broccoli is a go-to comfort meal for the commenter when feeling unwell."
Positive"A local diner is recommended for Borscht, pierogis, matzoh ball soup, and Hainese chicken and rice, suggesting these as healing foods."
Positive"Montague Diner is simply mentioned as a recommendation."
Neutral"Mentions that Montague Diner serves Petee’s chess pie, implying a recommendation for this dessert option available there."
Positive"Suggests Montague Diner as an option for a take-out burger, noting it is open until 10 PM."
Neutral"Montague Diner is slightly upscale and offers sundaes and chocolate cake, making it suitable for a celebratory breakfast."
Positive"Asks if a previously mentioned establishment might be Montague Diner."
Neutral"Finds The Montague Diner has surprisingly solid pancakes and A+ bacon with real maple syrup, despite the rest of the menu being hit or miss."
Positive
