Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (203) 644-4339
Address: 1195 3 AVENUE 10021
Viral cookie spot w/ a new menu weekly. Sweet treats w/ mixed reviews - some love 'em, others find 'em too sugary. Worth a try for a free birthday cookie!
This popular cookie chain offers a rotating selection of gourmet cookies, with a new menu each week. While some find them to be overly sweet and lacking in depth of flavor, others are pleasantly surprised by their quality, especially when redeemed as a birthday freebie. The brand is known for its viral status and frequent mentions in discussions about the best cookies in the city.
The restaurant specializes in cookies, offering a different selection each week. Customer reviews are mixed; some praise them as a pleasant surprise and even a top choice for chocolate chip cookies, while others criticize them for being excessively sweet and having a one-dimensional flavor profile. One mention also highlighted their crumb cake as a good option.
"The Chocolate Chip Cookie has been listed as a top choice by one user. Additionally, their crumb cake has been mentioned as a delicious option."
Customer feedback is divided. While many acknowledge the cookies' popularity and some enjoy them as a sweet treat or birthday perk, a significant portion finds them overly sweet and lacking in nuanced flavor.
Important Note
Some customers find the cookies to be overly sweet and lacking in flavor depth. There are also opinions that the cookies are not worth the price or the wait.
"Crumbl is mentioned as a second-tier option for birthday perks, considered less desirable compared to Chip City."
Neutral"The commenter mentions that Crumbl Bakery also has a delicious crumb cake, in addition to recommending Wegmans."
Positive"The user expresses surprise at Crumbl's low ranking but mentions not having tried it."
Neutral"The user thinks Crumbl being ranked last at #32, even worse than Costco, makes sense."
Negative"Crumbl is never worth waiting in line for."
Negative"Cookies were a pleasant surprise despite their viral status."
Positive"User lists 'Crumble' (assumed Crumbl Cookies) as one of their top 5 choices for chocolate chip cookies."
Positive"Commenter ironically suggests Crumbl, likely acknowledging its general perception as lower quality compared to others mentioned."
Neutral"OP contrasts Culture Espresso cookies favorably against Crumbl, describing Crumbl as just sugar on top of sugar with weak taste."
Negative
