TLDR
NYC's beloved pizza joint, known for its unique pies & reliable comfort food. A nostalgic favorite, still going strong across multiple locations.
Details
A New York City institution, this pizza spot is celebrated for its unique pies and long-standing presence in the culinary scene. It's considered a reliable and comforting local eat, with a history of overexpansion and subsequent renewal, ensuring its continued operation across multiple locations [1], [2]. The owners and their developed recipes remain a constant, offering a taste that many fondly remember from years past [3].
Food Overview
The restaurant is primarily known for its pizza, with specific mentions of unique pies and a characteristic crust [1]. The 'Buckminster slice' has been noted, and while some may have nostalgic perceptions, the consensus is that the food and recipes have remained consistent [2], [3]. It is generally considered a solid choice for pizza.
Caveats
While generally well-regarded, one commenter suggested that while Two Boots is solid, other pizza places might offer a potentially better experience [1]. There is also a discussion regarding the perceived consistency of recipes, with some attributing differences to nostalgia rather than changes in the food itself [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TWO BOOTS PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests the crust is characteristic of Two Boots."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Two Boots as a possibility."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc
"The commenter suggests a 'Buckminster slice' from Two Boots as a last meal option."
NeutralFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Disagrees with the notion that recipes can be taken, stating the owners developed them and the food is identical, attributing differing perceptions to nostalgia."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Believes a main chef left Two Boots in the past with recipes and plans to return due to nostalgia, even if the food isn't identical."
NegativeFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Asserts that the owners and food at Two Boots remain the same."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Refers to the original Two Boots crew from the late 1990s and expresses intent to revisit NYC locations."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Lists seven locations for Two Boots, including those on the Upper East Side, Upper West Side, and East Village."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"States that Two Boots has multiple locations and shares that the owner discussed the restaurant's history of overexpansion and subsequent renewal."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Inquires about the current location of Two Boots, reminiscing about its past presence near a theater on the Lower East Side."
NeutralFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Confirms that Two Boots is back and operating with multiple locations."
PositiveFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"The commenter fondly remembers a previous iteration of Two Boots as a Friday night hangout for food before partying."
PositiveFrom post: Opinion On My 2day Solo Eating Plan In Nyc 3
"While acknowledging Two Boots is solid, this commenter suggests trying other pizza places like 'industry's' for a potentially better experience."
NeutralFrom post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats
"Two Boots is recommended as a go-to spot."
PositiveFrom post: Opinion On My 2day Solo Eating Plan In Nyc 3
"This user recommends trying Two Boots pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Boucherie Reviews
"The commenter would rather eat at Two Boots than Boucherie."
PositiveFrom post: New Yorkers Whats Your Favorite Place For Thin
"This commenter mentioned Two Boots as not bad and criminally underrated, in addition to Lucia."
NeutralFrom post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In
"The commenter mentioned 'The Meg' from Two Boots."
Neutral