Next.js logo

TWO BOOTS PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (646) 837-6015

Address: 1243 2 AVENUE 10065

TLDR

NOLA-inspired pizza w/ famous Hot Knots & unique slices. Underrated or overrated? You decide.

Reddit Sentiment for TWO BOOTS PIZZA(based on 51 Reddit opinions)

49% Positive22% Neutral29% Negative

Tags

italian-american 24american 5pizza 2pizza 20slice 12garlic knots 11View All

Neighborhoods

Upper East Side

Details

This pizza joint offers a unique take on pies with a New Orleans-inspired twist. While some lament its past struggles and the closure of various locations, many still find a reason to return. The Hot Knots are a popular choice, often lauded for their affordability and taste, though opinions on their value vary. Some specific slices, like the Buckminster and Cleopatra Jones, have garnered dedicated fans, while others find the overall experience to be just passable.

Food Overview

The restaurant is known for its New Orleans-inspired pizza and a signature item called 'Hot Knots,' which are often praised for their affordability and taste, though some debate their value. Certain pizza slices, like the Buckminster and Cleopatra Jones, have a dedicated following, while others find the pizza to be merely passable. There are also mentions of gluten-free options and disappointment with the cornmeal crust.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Hot Knots are frequently recommended as an affordable and tasty option, with specific praise for the homemade jalapeno sauce. The Buckminster slice and Cleopatra Jones slice are also highlighted by fans."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • hot knots(3)
  • knots(2)
  • buckminster pizza(2)
  • cleopatra jones(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is mixed, with some lamenting past issues and closures, while others remain loyal fans, particularly praising specific items like the Hot Knots.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About TWO BOOTS PIZZA

This post and subsequent comments discuss the value and quality of Two Boots' Hot Knots. While some find them an incredible deal and delicious, others argue they are overpriced and not worth it.
In this thread, users discuss reliable local eats. Two Boots is mentioned as a go-to spot and a former Friday night hangout, with discussion also touching on its history, renewal, and the consistency of its food.
A user inquires about gluten-free pizza options, and a commenter suggests Two Boots, expressing confidence that they offer GF choices.
As part of a discussion about last meals in NYC, a commenter suggests the 'Buckminster slice' from Two Boots.
In a discussion about the best Pizza Bianca, a commenter mentions 'The Meg' from Two Boots.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc

"The commenter suggests a 'Buckminster slice' from Two Boots as a last meal option."

Neutral
Apr 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Disagrees with the notion that recipes can be taken, stating the owners developed them and the food is identical, attributing differing perceptions to nostalgia."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Believes a main chef left Two Boots in the past with recipes and plans to return due to nostalgia, even if the food isn't identical."

Negative
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Asserts that the owners and food at Two Boots remain the same."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Refers to the original Two Boots crew from the late 1990s and expresses intent to revisit NYC locations."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Lists seven locations for Two Boots, including those on the Upper East Side, Upper West Side, and East Village."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"States that Two Boots has multiple locations and shares that the owner discussed the restaurant's history of overexpansion and subsequent renewal."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Inquires about the current location of Two Boots, reminiscing about its past presence near a theater on the Lower East Side."

Neutral
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Confirms that Two Boots is back and operating with multiple locations."

Positive
Apr 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"The commenter fondly remembers a previous iteration of Two Boots as a Friday night hangout for food before partying."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Opinion On My 2day Solo Eating Plan In Nyc 3

"While acknowledging Two Boots is solid, this commenter suggests trying other pizza places like 'industry's' for a potentially better experience."

Neutral
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Two Boots is recommended as a go-to spot."

Positive
Apr 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Opinion On My 2day Solo Eating Plan In Nyc 3

"This user recommends trying Two Boots pizza."

Neutral
Apr 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Boucherie Reviews

"The commenter would rather eat at Two Boots than Boucherie."

Positive
Feb 2, 2026View Comment →

From post: New Yorkers Whats Your Favorite Place For Thin

"This commenter mentioned Two Boots as not bad and criminally underrated, in addition to Lucia."

Neutral
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In

"The commenter mentioned 'The Meg' from Two Boots."

Neutral
Aug 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Knots At Two Boots Is Some Of The Best Food

"This user enthusiastically agrees, stating that Cleopatra Jones pizza from Two Boots was a favorite."

Positive
Jun 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Knots At Two Boots Is Some Of The Best Food

"The commenter criticizes Two Boots' pizza, specifically disliking its cornmeal crust."

Negative
Jun 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Knots At Two Boots Is Some Of The Best Food

"The commenter acknowledges the general negative perception of Two Boots but expresses strong personal affection for the restaurant."

Positive
Jun 21, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Knots At Two Boots Is Some Of The Best Food

"The user expresses strong enjoyment for Two Boots' meatball sliders."

Positive
Jun 21, 2025View Comment →