Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (646) 795-6211
Address: 502 WEST 34 STREET 10001
Iconic Jewish appetizing store w/ legendary smoked fish & bagels. A must-visit N.Y.C. classic.
A classic New York institution, this establishment is renowned for its exceptional smoked fish and traditional Jewish appetizing fare. While lauded for its quality ingredients and timeless appeal, some diners find the bagels to be less impressive than the star of the show. Despite this, it remains a highly recommended spot for an authentic taste of New York's culinary heritage.
This establishment is celebrated for its outstanding selection of smoked fish, including lox, sable, and whitefish, often served on bagels. While the fish is consistently lauded as top-tier, there's a divided opinion on the bagels themselves, with many finding them to be only average. Other recommended items include matzoh ball soup, babka, and their unique shrub drinks.
"The smoked fish, particularly the lox, is highly recommended. Diners also enjoy the matzoh ball soup, babka, and their unique shrub drinks. The 'Super Heebster' and other specialized bagel sandwiches are frequently mentioned."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality of the smoked fish and traditional Jewish dishes, with many calling it an unforgettable experience. However, a recurring point of feedback is that the bagels, while decent, do not live up to the high standard set by the fish.
Important Note
Some customers find the bagels to be mediocre and suggest that the establishment is more of an 'appetizing store' focused on fish rather than a dedicated bagel shop.
"Russ & Daughters is listed as a recommended bagel place."
Positive"Russ and Daughters is noted for its excellent fish, but the bagels are considered mediocre by the commenter. They also mentioned another bagel spot, Bagel Joint in Greenpoint, as a must-try."
Neutral"Russ & Daughters is recommended for its bagels with smoked fish. It's an old-school establishment known for its quality fish."
Positive"The original poster found a large black coffee and two jelly Grahams to cost $10.80, stating it was the best coffee they had on their trip and the chocolate was superb."
Positive"This commenter points out that they wouldn't know Russ & Daughters offered desserts if they only associated it with lox, and would only discover this by going inside."
Neutral"This commenter appreciates the original poster sharing information about Russ & Daughters, even if it's a well-known spot, and states they had forgotten about it."
Positive"This user is asking about the price of items at Russ & Daughters."
Neutral"Explaining that Russ & Daughters is an 'appetizing store' and not a bagel shop, which is why their bagels are not the focus and often considered secondary to their fish preparations. It's common for New Yorkers to visit separate establishments for bagels and appetizing goods."
Neutral"This commenter, nearing childbirth, craved Russ & Daughters' lox and planned to pair it with bagels from another UWS establishment, agreeing that R&D's bagels are not top-tier."
Positive"This commenter agrees that Russ & Daughters bagels are subpar and questions why, given their esteemed reputation for other items."
Negative"A long-time NYC resident who loves Russ & Daughters for their fish and bagels, but admits they've never tried the sweets despite visiting for 20 years, inspired by the original post to try them."
Positive"This commenter suggests that visitors might not be aware of establishments like Russ & Daughters or Yonah Schimmel's Knish, implying they are significant culinary landmarks."
Neutral"This commenter notes that Russ & Daughters was a well-kept secret among New Yorkers until it gained wider popularity through the show Louie and social media."
Neutral"This commenter suggests that the jelly Grahams at Russ & Daughters can be found for better prices at Economy Candy, the source from which R&D likely gets them."
Neutral"This commenter fondly recalls the caviar cream cheese from Russ & Daughters, calling it the 'best shmear on the planet' and admits to buying $50 worth of it on a gift certificate instead of smoked fish."
Positive"This commenter considers Russ & Daughters a UNESCO World Heritage site and a favorite NYC spot, recommending the cafe for its classic bagel platter with lox, matzoh ball soup, and chocolate babka French toast."
Positive"This commenter humorously states they've been on Reddit too long, as the preview image of the post looked like a snake eating a rat."
Neutral"This commenter recommends the sit-down cafe at Russ & Daughters for caviar and other traditional nosh."
Positive"This commenter states that Russ & Daughters has some of the best caviar in the city."
Positive"The original poster found the sweets at Russ & Daughters to be high quality and delicious, expressing a desire to try more of their snacks on a future visit."
Positive
