TLDR
Damn good burgers under $20. A balance of not too greasy with good veggies. Known for its smash burger and fried pickles.
Reddit Sentiment for GOTHAM BURGER SOCIAL CLUB(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Details
This American burger joint, with locations in Lower East Side and Greenpoint, is known for its highly-praised smash burger [1]. The signature Gotham Smash includes grilled onions, American cheese, pickles, jalapeño, club sauce, ketchup, and mustard. They also offer vegetarian and gluten-free options [1].
Food Overview
The restaurant is primarily known for its American-style smash burgers, which are often highlighted for their flavor and reasonable price point [1], [2]. Some diners appreciate the balance of ingredients, noting it's not too greasy and includes good vegetables [2]. Fried pickles are also recommended by some [3], [4]. However, a few customers felt the burgers were overhyped, with one suggesting the patty needed more salt [5], [6]. One user also noted that the burgers might have a mustard-forward flavor [7].
Caveats
Some diners find the restaurant to be overhyped, and one user noted that the patty could benefit from more salt [1], [2]. Another reviewer mentioned that the burgers might be too mustard-forward for some palates [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GOTHAM BURGER SOCIAL CLUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Warned that Gotham Burger Social Club's burgers might not be for those who dislike mustard."
NeutralFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Recommended Gotham Burger Social Club for a great smash burger."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Fried Pickles In Nyc I Checked
"The user, not claiming to be an expert, states that Gotham Burger's fried pickles are good."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Fried Pickles In Nyc I Checked
"The user recommends Gotham Burger Social Club for fried pickles."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of
"Gotham burger is mentioned as a late-night food option."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"This user broadly criticized the original post for including 'Instagram spots' like Gotham Burger, suggesting they are overpriced and not very good."
NegativeFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user is considering trying Blue Road Burger partly due to a negative rating for Gotham Burger."
NegativeFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user found Gotham Burger to be a bit overhyped and felt the patty needed more salt."
NegativeFrom post: Please Critic My Itinerary
"This user advises against visiting Gotham Burger Social Club, stating that it is overhyped."
NegativeFrom post: Best Counter Service Classic Burger Not Smashed
"The original poster preferred Gotham Burger, finding its balance of not being too greasy and having good vegetables appealing."
PositiveFrom post: Go To Minetta Tavern But Dont Order The Black
"This user considers Gotham Social Club to serve damn good burgers for under $20, though not as exceptional as some pricier options."
Positive