Last Updated: 6 days ago
Phone: (914) 602-3590
Address: 131 ESSEX STREET 10002
NYC's best smash burger? Highly debated, but many say yes! Perfect patties, crispy tots, and amazing onion rings.
This acclaimed burger joint has garnered a strong reputation for its exceptional smash burgers, frequently cited as among the best in NYC and a standout in the competitive burger scene. While many patrons rave about the perfectly cooked patties and savory flavors, a few have experienced inconsistency with dryness or overly sweet sauces. The sides receive mixed reviews, with standout onion rings and tater tots, but some find the fries to be underwhelming.
The restaurant is highly acclaimed for its smash burgers, with many users declaring them the best in the city and superior to other popular burger joints like 7th Street Burger and Hamburger America. Some customers found the burgers to be perfectly cooked, flavorful, and less greasy than competitors. Conversely, a few reviews mentioned burgers being dry, overcooked, or having an unappealing sauce. Opinions on the side dishes are divided; while some praised the onion rings and tater tots, others found the fries to be disappointing or overly salty.
"The smash burgers are highly recommended, with many considering them the best in the city. The onion rings and loaded tots also receive strong positive mentions."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards the burgers, with many considering them among the best in NYC. However, opinions on the fries and tots are more mixed.
Important Note
Some customers find the fries to be underwhelming or overly salty, and a few have experienced inconsistency in burger preparation, citing dryness or excessive sauce.
"This user considers Gotham Social Club to serve damn good burgers for under $20, though not as exceptional as some pricier options."
Positive"While finding Nowon's burger fantastic, this user still believes GBSC is superior. They appreciated Nowon's chopped cheese rice cakes as well."
Positive"This user finds Gotham Burger Social Club (GBSC) to be mediocre."
Negative"This user finds 7th Street Burger to be a good backup option when GBSC is closed, especially for late-night or drunk cravings. However, they still consider GBSC to be better."
Positive"This comment mentions GBSC having significant hype and long lines, implying a generally popular and likely positive reception, though not a direct personal endorsement in this instance."
Neutral"This user strongly disagrees with the idea that Shake Shack is better than GBSC. They feel GBSC offers superior quality across the board compared to Shake Shack."
Positive"The user considers GBSC to be just "OK" but notes it's better than Hamburger America. They also suggest Shake Shack might be better."
Neutral"The original poster finds Gotham Burger Social Club (GBSC) exceptionally good, consistently craving it after having a burger there. They consider it a benchmark for smash burgers."
Positive"This user considers Gotham Burger their 'go-to' smash burger spot, praising its quality but wishing the fries were better."
Positive"A user questioned if Gotham Burger cooks its burgers to a specific temperature, implying a potential concern for burger quality related to smash burger cooking methods."
Neutral"The Original Poster considers Gotham Burger one of their preferred burger spots, enjoying the double burger and chicken tenders with hot honey."
Positive"A user highly recommends Gotham's special 'California Dreamin'' burger, available on Sundays or Mondays, stating it's much better than an In-N-Out burger."
Positive"The original poster agrees with a previous assessment that the burgers from Gotham Social Club are very decent."
Neutral"A user found the burgers at Gotham Burger Social Club to be very decent and noted its ambience slightly edges out others."
Neutral"A user recommends Gotham for the burger crawl."
Neutral"The original poster includes Gotham Burgers on their current list of potential burger crawl stops."
Neutral"A user recommends Gotham Burger Social Club for the burger crawl."
Neutral"A user simply recommends Gotham for the burger crawl."
Neutral"Gotham Burger in LES is recommended, specifically highlighting their pickle chips with tartar sauce."
Positive"Gotham burger is this user's favorite smashburger spot due to how they cook the burger, their special sauce, fries/onion rings, and the music."
Positive
