TLDR
Gigantic, shareable Italian paninis that pack insane value. A cult-favorite for high-quality, long-lasting lunches across NYC.
Reddit Sentiment for PISILLO ITALIAN PANINI(based on 68 Reddit opinions)
Details
Famous for their massive Italian-style sandwiches, this eatery offers portions so generous that many diners find a single order sufficient for multiple meals [1], [2]. While the menu is praised for its high quality and authentic flavor, customers should be aware that the shop operates as a quick-service spot rather than a traditional sit-down establishment [3]. The restaurant maintains several convenient locations across Manhattan, including Midtown and the Financial District [4].
Food Overview
Specializing in authentic Italian-style paninis and heroes, the menu is widely celebrated for its fresh ingredients and generous servings [1], [5]. The focaccia bread and hot spread are frequently highlighted by regulars as 'fire' additions [6], though one critic suggested the default bread can be chewy, recommending an upgrade to semolina for a better experience [6].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Italian sandwiches are consistently praised, with frequent recommendations to order them on semolina bread for superior texture [6]. Adding the house 'hot spread' is also a highly recommended customization [6]."
Customer Sentiment
Overall customer sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with patrons frequently citing the exceptional value and colossal portion sizes as standout features [1], [5]. While most consider it a top-tier destination for sandwiches, some diners note that personal preferences for bread texture can vary compared to other local delis [6].
Caveats
The restaurant is primarily a counter-service establishment rather than a sit-down restaurant [3]. Additionally, the shop is cash-only for in-person orders, though customers can bypass this by ordering online [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PISILLO ITALIAN PANINI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user lists Pisillo Italian Panini as a place that exceeded expectations."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter listed Pisillo Italian Panini as a solid sandwich spot, noting it's not a sit-down restaurant with waiters."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Following Unicorn Foods To Have
"This user seconded the recommendation for Pisillo, specifically mentioning the homemade bread or semolina for their sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Following Unicorn Foods To Have
"Pisillo was recommended as a place to get Italian sausage or cold cut sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user highlighted Pisillo Italian Panini as one of the cheapest meals in NYC, with a $20 sandwich feeding three people."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user agreed that sandwiches from Pisillo Italian Panini last for 2-3 meals and mentioned taking their mother there who also loves it."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user praised the focaccia bread at Pisillo Italian Panini."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user responded positively to the tip about paying extra for better bread at Pisillo Italian Panini."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user advised paying extra for better bread at Pisillo Italian Panini, stating the default bread is 'meh'."
NeutralFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user mentioned Pisillo Italian Panini as a favorite from their time at Pace University, noting sandwiches last for 2-3 meals."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user confirmed Pisillo Italian Panini offers large sandwiches, stating their office splits them and that the ciabatta looks like a 'roomba'."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user mentioned Pisillo Italian Panini has a location by the Seaport and that their sandwiches provide about four meals."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user expressed dissatisfaction with the chewiness of the bread at Pisillo Italian Panini."
NegativeFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user commented that sandwiches from Pisillo Italian Panini are like having two meals."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended Pisillo Italian Panini in Midtown for its gigantic sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Day Nyc Need Food Recommendations Updated With
"Pisillo Italian Panini is one of the few places near Times Square that fits the user's budget and location preferences."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bang For Your Buck In This Economy Aka Big
"This user agreed that Pisillo's sandwiches are very large, stating they are bigger than their head and have caused many food comas."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bang For Your Buck In This Economy Aka Big
"The sandwiches at Pisillo are expensive at around $20 but are large enough to last for 2-4 meals."
PositiveFrom post: Quick Lunch In Penn Station Area
"Pisillo is mentioned as a good sandwich shop located nearby."
PositiveFrom post: Affordable Dinner Options In Lower Midtown
"Pisillo Italian Panini is mentioned as a place to get sandwiches."
Neutral