Last Updated: 15 days ago
Phone: (347) 749-8730
Address: 110 WEST 38 STREET 10018
Gigantic Italian sandwiches overflowing w/ meat. A legendary NYC deli experience worth every penny.
For an authentic taste of Italy, look no further than this beloved sandwich shop, renowned for its gargantuan and generously filled Italian heroes. Customers rave about the quality and portion sizes, often noting that one sandwich can easily serve multiple people. While it's not the cheapest option, the sheer volume and deliciousness make it a worthwhile indulgence.
This spot is celebrated for its colossal Italian sandwiches, packed with generous amounts of meat. While most customers find them incredibly satisfying and a great value due to their size, one diner found the mortadella sandwich to have too much meat. The option to upgrade to specialty bread, like semolina, is also frequently recommended.
"Customers frequently praise the Italian sandwiches, with specific mentions of the prosciutto and porchetta panini, and the Caprese sandwich. Upgrading to specialty bread, such as semolina, is also highly recommended."
Overwhelmingly positive, with customers frequently praising the massive portion sizes and high-quality ingredients of their Italian sandwiches.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash only unless ordering online. Some found the mortadella sandwich to have too much meat, and while generally considered a good value, they are not the cheapest option.
"This user mentions they used to place orders online for Pisillo to pay by card and do pick up."
Neutral"This user suggests Pisillo for Italian sandwiches, mentioning they are gigantic and that the establishment is cash only, but worth the wait."
Positive"This user recommends Pisillo Italian Panini for gigantic Italian sandwiches, noting that it is cash only unless ordered online."
Positive"The author agreed that Pisillo Italian Panini's heroes are massive and can easily last three days, requiring portions to be saved for later meals."
Positive"This user mentioned that focaccia sandwiches from Pisillo Italian Panini are large enough to last three days, requiring part of it to be saved for a later meal."
Positive"Arguably the best Italian sandwich in NYC, with portions large enough to feed two people."
Positive"A brief mention recommending Pisillo."
Positive"This user recommends trying Pisillo's for sandwiches."
Positive"Pisillo is mentioned as having multiple locations, including Midtown, Chelsea, and FiDi."
Positive"This commenter noted that Pisillo has a location on 38th Street in addition to others."
Neutral"Pisillios is listed as a recommended spot for breakfast sandwiches."
Positive"Pisillo was recommended, with a general endorsement for any of their paninis."
Positive"The commenter recommended Pisillo, specifically mentioning the semolina sandwich."
Positive"Pissilo is listed among several recommended food options in the area."
Neutral"This user suggests getting chocolate chip cookies from Culture Espresso and then a sandwich from Pisillo."
Neutral"Pisillo is recommended for great Italian sandwiches at their location on 38th street between 6th and 7th."
Positive"The commenter recommends Faicco's for Italian sandwiches when in the West Village, implying it's a good alternative or complement to other Italian sandwich spots."
Positive"The commenter confirms a positive experience at the 38th Street Pisillo's location, describing the sandwich as great and large enough for 2-3 people."
Positive"This commenter lists Pisillo's as a top choice for Italian subs alongside other recommendations."
Positive"This commenter agrees with the recommendation for Pisillo's, expressing a strong liking for their sandwiches and mentioning a new Chelsea location."
Positive
