Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (347) 749-8730
Address: 110 WEST 38 STREET 10018
Enormous, meat-packed Italian paninis; an absolute must-try for sandwich lovers. Great value for the size!
This Italian sandwich shop is renowned for its generously portioned paninis, often described as enormous and capable of serving two to three people. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients, particularly the meat, and the delicious bread options, with ciabatta and semolina rolls frequently highlighted. While the sandwiches are a bit pricey, many find them to be excellent value for the size and quality, making them a popular choice for a hearty and satisfying meal.
The restaurant is celebrated for its exceptionally large and delicious Italian sandwiches and paninis. The meat portions are substantial, and customers frequently recommend upgrading to specialty bread like ciabatta or semolina. While most feedback is positive, one commenter found the mortadella sandwich to have too much mortadella, and another noted the caprese sandwich was huge and expensive, though still very good.
"Customers frequently praise the Italian sandwiches and paninis, with specific mentions of the prosciutto and porchetta sandwich and the #26 on ciabatta. Upgrading to specialty breads like semolina or ciabatta is also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the massive, high-quality Italian sandwiches, often noting they are large enough to share and a great value despite the price. Some minor feedback mentioned specific sandwich combinations being less ideal.
Important Note
The sandwiches are generally considered large and hearty, which might not be ideal for those seeking lighter fare. Some individual sandwich combinations received mixed feedback, and the price point is on the higher side, though often justified by the portion size.
"Arguably the best Italian sandwich in NYC, with portions large enough to feed two people."
Positive"A brief mention recommending Pisillo."
Positive"This user recommends trying Pisillo's for sandwiches."
Positive"Pisillo is mentioned as having multiple locations, including Midtown, Chelsea, and FiDi."
Positive"This commenter noted that Pisillo has a location on 38th Street in addition to others."
Neutral"Pisillios is listed as a recommended spot for breakfast sandwiches."
Positive"Pisillo was recommended, with a general endorsement for any of their paninis."
Positive"The commenter recommended Pisillo, specifically mentioning the semolina sandwich."
Positive"Pissilo is listed among several recommended food options in the area."
Neutral"This user suggests getting chocolate chip cookies from Culture Espresso and then a sandwich from Pisillo."
Neutral"Pisillo is recommended for great Italian sandwiches at their location on 38th street between 6th and 7th."
Positive"The commenter recommends Faicco's for Italian sandwiches when in the West Village, implying it's a good alternative or complement to other Italian sandwich spots."
Positive"The commenter confirms a positive experience at the 38th Street Pisillo's location, describing the sandwich as great and large enough for 2-3 people."
Positive"This commenter lists Pisillo's as a top choice for Italian subs alongside other recommendations."
Positive"This commenter agrees with the recommendation for Pisillo's, expressing a strong liking for their sandwiches and mentioning a new Chelsea location."
Positive"The commenter recommends Pisillo's for an Italian sandwich, noting that one sandwich is large enough to share and still have leftovers."
Positive"The user buys a sub from Pisillo Italian Panini and eats it over three days, finding it a cost-effective strategy."
Positive"A user noted that Pisillo Italian Panini sandwiches are large enough to be considered two meals, making them a cost-effective option."
Positive"The user acknowledged Pisillo Italian Panini is good but not a cheap eat."
Negative"The user suggests Pisillios as a lunch spot."
Neutral
