Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (347) 749-8730
Address: 110 WEST 38 STREET 10018
Gigantic Italian sandwiches piled high w/ quality meats & cheeses. Worth every penny & shareable for multiple meals!
Step into Pisillo Italian Panini for a true taste of authentic Italian sandwiches, where generous portions and high-quality ingredients reign supreme. Each sandwich is a culinary masterpiece, packed with a flavorful array of meats and cheeses, often hailed as large enough to be shared or savored over multiple meals. While the sandwiches are undeniably a star, consider upgrading to their specialty bread for an even more delightful experience.
Pisillo Italian Panini is renowned for its massive and flavorful Italian sandwiches. Customers frequently praise the quality of the meats and cheeses, with many recommending upgrading to specialty bread. The portion sizes are consistently highlighted as being exceptionally large, often equating to two or more meals.
"The prosciutto and porchetta panini, the semolina sandwich, and the caprese sandwich have all been specifically recommended. Customers also frequently suggest upgrading to their specialty bread options."
Customers rave about the incredibly generous portion sizes and the high quality of ingredients used in their Italian sandwiches, often noting that one sandwich can easily serve multiple people.
Important Note
One commenter noted a negative experience with the mortadella sandwich, citing it was too thick and excessive. Another user found the establishment to be overrated compared to other sandwich shops. It is also noted that the establishment is cash only unless ordering online.
"Pisillo is mentioned as a good sandwich shop located nearby."
Positive"Pisillo Italian Panini is mentioned as a place to get sandwiches."
Neutral"This commenter recommends Pisillo for high-quality Italian sandwiches and mentions locations in Fidi and Chelsea."
Positive"This commenter recommends Pisillo for high-quality Italian sandwiches and mentions locations in Fidi and Chelsea."
Positive"This commenter provides a link to Pisillo Pannini."
Positive"This commenter provides a link to Pisillo Pannini."
Positive"This comment seconded the recommendation for Pisillo."
Positive"This commenter rates Pisillo Pannini as a 10/10."
Positive"This commenter rates Pisillo Pannini as a 10/10."
Positive"This commenter lists Pisillo Italian Panini as a recommended sandwich spot."
Positive"This commenter lists Pisillo Italian Panini as a recommended sandwich spot."
Positive"This user suggested adding Pisillo to the sandwich list."
Positive"Pisillo was recommended for Italian sandwiches."
Positive"This user mentioned Pisillo as an option for Italian sandwiches, suggesting it is likely close enough to The Hugh."
Positive"The commenter recommends getting sandwiches at Pisillo's on focaccia bread for maximum value, suggesting it yields 2-3 meals and to be sure to get their hot spread."
Positive"The commenter notes that finding Pisillo's focaccia bread option is 'fire' and that there are no bad options, advising to get their hot spread."
Positive"Nostalgia and a positive first sandwich experience are cited as reasons for recommending Pisillo's."
Positive"This user is asking for recommendations at Pisillo's."
Neutral"This user found Pisillo's to have insane value, stating one colossal sandwich can make four meals."
Positive"The commenter finds Pisillo's to be overrated compared to Royal Crown or Paneantico, stating Royal Crown has better bread and glaze for a classic Italian sandwich."
Negative
