A hidden subway pizzeria with mind-blowing thin-crust pizza and a killer punk-rock vibe.
Tucked away within the bustling 50th Street subway station, See No Evil Pizza offers a truly unique dining experience. This hidden gem boasts a casual yet vibrant atmosphere, underscored by a punk rock edge, 80s music, and classic black-and-white checkered floors. It's the perfect spot for pre-show dining, especially with its adjacent cocktail bar, Nothing Really Matters. The thin-crust pizzas are the star of the show, with rave reviews for inventive toppings and exceptional quality. Standout options include the rich 'Vinnie Stigmata,' the surprisingly delightful 'Guy Picciotto,' and the spicy 'Hell Pie.' Don't overlook the intriguing small plates or the unique olive oil and sea salt soft serve for a memorable meal.
The pizza here is highly praised, with some customers claiming it's so good it might 'ruin all other pizza for you.' The thin-crust pizzas feature unique and delicious toppings. Specifically, the 'Vinnie Stigmata' with slow-cooked beef sauce and aged cheese, the 'Guy Picciotto' with a surprising sweet crunch from peas and asparagus, and the spicy 'Hell Pie' loaded with pepperoni are frequently recommended. The menu also includes intriguing small plates like toast with sardines or seasonal bean dishes. For dessert, a vanilla soft serve drizzled with olive oil and sea salt is a unique offering.
"The 'Vinnie Stigmata' pizza with slow-cooked beef sauce and aged cheese, and the spicy 'Hell Pie' loaded with pepperoni are highly recommended for their unique and delicious toppings."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards this restaurant, frequently recommending it for its pizza and its unique location within the 50th Street subway station. The adjacent cocktail bar, Nothing Really Matters, is also noted as a plus for pre-show dining. Many appreciate the pizza's quality, with some even suggesting it could redefine their standards for pizza. The atmosphere is described as having a casual yet punk rock edge, complete with 80s music and classic decor.
Important Note
Reservations are recommended, or arriving at opening is advised, especially for pre-show dining.
"The commenter suggests considering See No Evil Pizza, implying it is one of the improved food options available in Midtown."
Positive"Recommends checking out See No Evil Pizza and its adjacent cocktail bar near the 50th St subway station for pre-show dining. Suggests making reservations or arriving at opening."
Positive"User recommends See No Evil for pizza with a bar in Midtown West."
Positive
