Next.js logo

NIGHTLY'S

Updated

Phone: (917) 526-2090

Address: 1496 2 AVENUE 10075

TLDR

Stylish UES American bistro w/ elevated comfort food & fun vibe. Nailing both food & atmosphere.

Reddit Sentiment for NIGHTLY'S(based on 9 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive11% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo
Achievement logo

Tags

american 7chicken 3burger 3dip 2View All

Neighborhoods

Upper East Side

Instagram Posts References

This post offers an in-depth review of several dishes and drinks at Nightly's, located in New York City's Upper East Side. The reviewer found the overall ambiance of the restaurant to be 'cute,' but expressed mixed sentiments regarding the food quality, noting that it 'didn't blow me away' despite hearing good things about their dessert. Specific items were either highly praised or strongly advised against. The burger was deemed delicious, particularly for its onions, and the fries were highlighted as exceptionally crispy, both warranting a reorder. The Aperol Spritz was a favorite drink and also recommended for a repeat order. Conversely, the Spinach Artichoke Dip was rated as merely 'okay' and not worth reordering, while the Tuna Tartare was criticized for being 'flavorless,' despite its 'fire' chips, and would not be reordered. The Mac & Cheese, while appreciated for its baked preparation, was ultimately not a favorite and would also be skipped on a subsequent visit.

The post captures a very favorable dining experience at Nightly's in NYC, emphasizing the restaurant's superb ambiance. The visual array of dishes suggests a versatile menu with well-prepared, high-quality offerings, appealing to a diverse culinary palate.

Nightly's is presented as a stylish new culinary destination on the Upper East Side, bringing fresh energy to the neighborhood with its elevated American bistro concept. The establishment is lauded for successfully nailing both a fun and stylish vibe, with its food being consistently described as absolute hits across the board.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Nightly's
positive

Bryan Kim reviews Nightly's, an American restaurant on the Upper East Side, praising its crowd-pleasing formula and dishes like pan-seared gnocchi and roast chicken.

Bryan KimMay 3, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
The Upper East Side Is More Than Just Old New York
positive

Nightly’s is an all-purpose American restaurant offering a crowd-pleasing menu with dishes like burgers and fish tacos, reminiscent of TGI Fridays but with a modern touch.

Sonal ShahDate unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

This stylish American bistro on the Upper East Side offers a crowd-pleasing menu with a modern twist. Known for its elevated comfort food, Nightly's has quickly become a neighborhood favorite, perfect for date nights or casual dinners. The ambiance is consistently praised as fun and stylish, making it a great spot for people-watching.

Food Overview

Nightly's serves an elevated American bistro menu. Standout dishes include the 'Ultimate Black Tie Burger' and 'Steak au Poivre,' both highly recommended. The 'Spinach & Artichoke Dip' and 'Tuna Tartare' have received mixed reviews, with some finding them just 'okay' or flavorless.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the 'Ultimate Black Tie Burger' and the 'Steak au Poivre.' The 'Marry Me Chicken' is also noted as a dish that surpasses homemade versions."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • marry me chicken(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a very positive view of the restaurant, highlighting its stylish ambiance and crowd-pleasing American bistro fare. Specific dishes like the burger and steak au poivre receive high praise, though some minor critiques exist for appetizers.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About NIGHTLY'S

A user specifically recommended the steak au poivre at Nightly's, calling it impressive and a welcome local option.
This restaurant is noted for being particularly good at managing customer allergies, including gluten-free and dairy sensitivities.
Nightly's was suggested as a lovely place for solo diners to enjoy people-watching while having a meal.
A recommendation was made for Nightly's on the Upper East Side.
Nightly's was mentioned as a suitable American bistro option when seeking recommendations.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Is A Great Steak In Nyc Not At A Steakhouse

"The steak au poivre at Nightly's on the Upper East Side was impressive and a welcome local option."

Positive
Mar 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Fun Place To Peoplewatch While Dining Solo

"Nightly's was mentioned as a place that would be lovely for good New York people watching."

Positive
Jan 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: Recommendations

"Nightlys was suggested as an American bistro option."

Positive
Oct 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Iso Restaurants Sensitive To Gf And Dairy

"Nightlys, located on the Upper East Side, is praised for being great at managing allergies."

Positive
May 29, 2025View Comment →