Bagels w/ incredible texture, unique toppings like white fish salad & tomato/cream cheese. Top-tier NYC bagel experience.
This Greenwich Village spot is a must-visit for bagel aficionados. Praised for their fluffy, airy, and flavorful bagels, they also offer unique combinations like white fish salad or tomato and cream cheese. The everything bagel with salmon is a standout, with a perfect ratio of ingredients served on a perfectly seasoned bagel.
The bagels here are a major highlight, described as fluffy, airy, and flavorful, with some noting a sourdough-like quality. Popular choices include the everything bagel with salmon, which features a good ratio of ingredients, and the white fish salad bagel. The tomato and cream cheese combination is also surprisingly well-received.
"The everything bagel with salmon is frequently recommended for its balanced toppings and seasoning. The white fish salad bagel is also a popular choice, praised for its flavor."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bagels, highlighting their exceptional texture and flavor. Some debate if they are traditional bagels or a sourdough style, but most agree they are delicious.
Important Note
Some users note that the bagels might be more akin to a toasted sourdough style rather than traditional bagels, and there are differing opinions on whether they are superior to other popular bagel spots in the city.
"This bagel spot is highly praised for its chewiness, whitefish salad, and the quality of the bagels themselves, earning a perfect score."
Positive"This commenter elaborates that even as a bread product, Apollo bagels are mediocre."
Negative"This commenter disagrees, stating that Apollo Bagels are not very good."
Negative"This commenter believes Apollo Bagels makes the best bagels in the city by a significant margin."
Positive"The author acknowledges Apollo Bagels' offerings are sourdough bread in a bagel shape, but finds them to be very good sourdough. They are considered tasty, though potentially overhyped, and better than a specific pop-up."
Positive"This user provided the location of Apollo Bagels West Village in response to a query about an onigiri pop-up."
Neutral"Apollo bagel is listed as a recommended restaurant."
Positive"The commenter expresses a preference for Pop Up Bagels over Apollo Bagels."
Neutral"Apollo bagels are characterized as a riff on an LA bagel style, with Utopia on 34th Street suggested as an alternative."
Neutral"The commenter suggests that there are better bagel options available than what was listed."
Negative"Apollo Bagels are described as good, but noted for being a toasted sourdough style, which might be a specific preference."
Neutral"The Apollo Bagel bagel is listed as something the commenter has tried and loved."
Positive
