TLDR
Indulge in exceptionally good brownies & Reese's cheesecake. Known for amazing gluten-free cakes that taste just like the real thing.
Details
Posh Pop Bakeshop is a beloved dessert spot known for its exceptionally good brownies and Reese's cheesecake [1]. While a West Village location has closed, the Midtown branch remains open, offering a variety of cakes and desserts [2]. The bakeshop is also noted for its gluten-free options, with cakes tasting as good as conventional ones [8].
Food Overview
Posh Pop Bakeshop is highly recommended for its desserts, with brownies and Reese's cheesecake being standout items [1]. They also offer cakes and cupcakes, with a popular funfetti option [3]. Notably, their gluten-free cakes are praised for tasting just as delicious as traditional cakes [8]. Some customers have noted the high pricing of their cakes, with a 6-inch funfetti cake costing $125 [4].
Caveats
One of the main concerns raised by customers is the high price of cakes from Posh Pop Bakeshop [4], [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About POSH POP BAKE SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"This commenter confirmed that Posh Pop Bakeshop's items are gluten-free and taste as good as regular cake."
PositiveFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"A question was raised about whether Posh Pop Bakeshop's offerings are gluten-free."
NeutralFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"The commenter mentioned that the high prices at Posh Pop Bakeshop prevent them from trying it."
NeutralFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"The commenter expressed fondness for Posh Pop's lemon squares and funfetti cheesecake bar, despite the high cost of their cakes."
PositiveFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"This commenter stated that everything from Posh Pop is great but acknowledged its prohibitively high prices for cakes."
NeutralFrom post: Anywhere In The City That I Can Order A Funfetti
"Posh Pop Bakeshop was recommended for cakes, and Buttercup Bake Shop was mentioned for funfetti cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Any Gluten Free Cakes And Desert
"Posh Pop is a girlfriend's favorite, and while the West Village location has closed, the Midtown one is reportedly still open."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Good Sit Down Dessert Places That Are
"Posh Pop Bakeshop in the West Village is open until 11 PM and offers exceptionally good brownies and Reese's cheesecake."
Positive