TLDR
A reliable NYC staple for creative bagel sandwiches and iced lattes. Known for varied cream cheese options and hearty chicken salads, though pricing can be a point of debate.
Details
Known for a diverse menu ranging from creative pizza bagels to hearty chicken salads, this spot provides a reliable stop for a classic NYC bite [1], [9]. Customers particularly appreciate the house-made cream cheese selection and comforting staples like the Waldorf chicken salad served on an egg everything bagel [2], [9]. While some diners consider it a standout lunch destination, others have expressed concerns regarding the higher price points of the bagels [11], [13].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide array of options including a highly-regarded Waldorf chicken salad, quality pizza bagels with fresh mozzarella, and a notable iced banana latte [5], [7], [9]. Guests specifically recommend the tuna and tomato on an everything bagel for a classic experience, and the shop is known for its wide variety of cream cheeses [2], [13].
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that the pricing for individual bagels can be significantly higher than at other local shops [11].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BAGEL PUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Absolute Best Weekday Lunch Options In Nyc
"Recommends the tuna and tomato on an everything bagel for a classic experience."
PositiveFrom post: Weird Request Does Any Place Sell The Liz Lemon
"This user noted that Bagel Pub locations sell pastrami lox on their sandwiches, and suggested that many other bagel shops likely do too."
NeutralFrom post: Will A Ban On Bromated Flour Change New York
"The commenter expresses surprise at the price of bagels, noting that Bagel Pub charges significantly more ($6-7) than the $2.50 mentioned by another user."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chicken Salad In Manhattan
"The Waldorf chicken salad from Bagel Pub, especially on a roasted egg everything bagel, is highly recommended and evokes a sense of home. They also have a decent curried chicken salad."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A bagel and lox from Bagel Pub was rated 8/10 and described as really nice, with a specific mention of liking the saltiness of the bagel."
PositiveFrom post: Banana Bread Lattes In Nyc
"The commenter states that Bagel Pub offers banana lattes, but they are unsure if it includes the 'bread' aspect."
NeutralFrom post: Banana Bread Lattes In Nyc
"The commenter found the iced banana latte at Bagel Pub to be pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations
"Bagel Pub was listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip
"This commenter recommended Bagel Pub, enjoying their selection of cream cheeses."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip
"This commenter recommended Bagel Pub, enjoying their selection of cream cheeses."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip
"This commenter advised getting rid of Bagel Pub from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
NegativeFrom post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip
"This commenter advised getting rid of Bagel Pub from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
NegativeFrom post: Pizza Bagels Black Seed Essabagel Bagel Pub Bagel
"This pizza bagel was considered a significant improvement, with better sauce that was slightly salty and quality fresh mozzarella. The author used a garlic bagel, which they felt might have been too strong and would opt for onion next time, appreciating the extra sauce."
Positive