Solid bagels & diverse cream cheese options. A reliable Manhattan breakfast & lunch spot.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, this bagel shop offers a classic New York experience. It's a go-to spot for a solid breakfast or lunch, with a variety of bagels and spreads. While many praise the traditional offerings, some suggest exploring their unique cream cheese flavors for a standout meal.
The restaurant is primarily known for its bagels, with customers frequently recommending the classic everything bagel and varieties like pumpernickel. The tofu cream cheese options, especially with lox, are highlighted as a must-try. While most feedback on bagels is positive, one opinion labeled the establishment as 'very mid'. Their pizza bagel has also received praise for its sauce and mozzarella, though the garlic bagel base was noted as potentially too strong.
"Highly recommended are the Waldorf chicken salad and curried chicken salad, especially when paired with their bagels. The pizza bagel is also a standout, praised for its toppings and sauce."
Customers generally view this establishment positively, with many recommending it for its classic bagel offerings and unique cream cheese selections. However, there are some opinions suggesting it's 'mid' and not worth the effort.
Important Note
One commenter expressed a strong negative opinion, calling the establishment 'very mid' and not worth the effort. It has also been noted that their gluten-free bagels are not made in-house but are sourced from Canyon Bakehouse.
"The Waldorf chicken salad from Bagel Pub, especially on a roasted egg everything bagel, is highly recommended and evokes a sense of home. They also have a decent curried chicken salad."
Positive"A bagel and lox from Bagel Pub was rated 8/10 and described as really nice, with a specific mention of liking the saltiness of the bagel."
Positive"The commenter states that Bagel Pub offers banana lattes, but they are unsure if it includes the 'bread' aspect."
Neutral"The commenter found the iced banana latte at Bagel Pub to be pretty good."
Positive"Bagel Pub was listed as a recommendation."
Positive"This commenter recommended Bagel Pub, enjoying their selection of cream cheeses."
Positive"This commenter recommended Bagel Pub, enjoying their selection of cream cheeses."
Positive"This commenter advised getting rid of Bagel Pub from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
Negative"This commenter advised getting rid of Bagel Pub from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
Negative"This pizza bagel was considered a significant improvement, with better sauce that was slightly salty and quality fresh mozzarella. The author used a garlic bagel, which they felt might have been too strong and would opt for onion next time, appreciating the extra sauce."
Positive
