TLDR
Creative twists on comfort bakes—from inventive pastries to unique cakes & flatbreads. A must-try East Village gem!
Reddit Sentiment for HANI'S BAKERY + CAFE(based on 131 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Hani's Bakery is recognized for its chocolate chunk cookie, ranking as a top bite. The cookie appears large and features visible chocolate chunks with a hint of sea salt, suggesting a decadent and satisfying dessert from this bakery.
Hani's Carrot Cake was featured among the bakeries at the event, showcasing its delicious carrot cakes. Large, beautifully decorated cakes were on display, contributing to the diverse array of culinary delights available to guests.
Hani's Bakery is acknowledged for its Triple Chocolate Chip cookie, positioning it as a noteworthy and enjoyable option for chocolate chip cookie lovers in New York City. The post includes it as a recommended choice.
Hani's, located in the East Village, was opened by the Gramercy Tavern Pastry Chef and his wife, a senior food editor at Bon Appetit. It offers a variety of delicious and unique sweet and savory pastries, cakes, and flatbreads, making it suitable for breakfast, lunch, or dessert.
A slice of cake from Hanis Bakery NYC made such a profound impression that the author and their family are "still talking about this slice of CAKE," calling it "actually life changing." This highlights an exceptionally positive and memorable dessert experience.
Hani's Bakery is highlighted for its creative and classic dessert offerings, making it a standout for those seeking exceptional baked goods in NYC.
Hani's in Cooper Square is recognized for its impressive chocolate layer cake. The cake is described as both soft and rich, indicating a well-executed dessert.
Willa Moore reviews Hani's Bakery & Café, an East Village spot praised for its fun twists on comfort baked goods like pistachio halva rice crispy treats and broccoli-cheddar scones, calling it an instant hit.
Details
This East Village bakery, founded by a former Gramercy Tavern pastry chef and a Bon Appetit editor, offers a delightful array of inventive sweet and savory pastries, cakes, and flatbreads. It’s praised for its fun atmosphere and creative twists on comfort classics like pistachio halva rice crispy treats and PB&J cakes, making it a go-to spot for breakfast, lunch, or dessert.
Food Overview
Hani's Bakery is celebrated for its creative American and Middle Eastern-inspired pastries, cakes, and flatbreads. Standout items frequently mentioned include their chocolate chip cookies, honey cake, carrot cake, cinnamon rolls, and unique creations like pistachio halva rice crispy treats and paneer tikka pinwheels. While many praise the quality and inventiveness, a few opinions suggest that some items can be overly sweet or that the hype doesn't always match the taste.
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the chocolate chip cookie, honey cake, carrot cake, cinnamon roll, pistachio halva rice crispy treat, and paneer tikka pinwheel. The smoked salmon flatbread is also noted as a standout savory option."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chocolate chip cookie(26)
- •cinnamon roll(17)
- •honey cake(10)
- •carrot cake(8)
- •cosmic brownie(5)
- •brownie(4)
- •chocolate cake(4)
- •pistachio halva rice krispie treat(3)
- •smoked salmon flatbread(3)
- •cinnamon bun(2)
- •cookie(2)
- •pb cake(2)
- •blackout cake(2)
- •brownies(2)
- •seasonal tart(2)
- •pistachio, tahini, halva, and brown butter rice crispy treat(2)
- •triple chocolate chip cookie(2)
- •paneer tikka pinwheel(2)
- •chocolate chunk cookie(2)
Caveats
Some reviewers find the prices high for NYC, and there are mixed opinions on whether the hype matches the taste, with some items being considered overly sweet or having slightly 'off' flavor profiles.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About HANI'S BAKERY + CAFE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie
"Hani's is mentioned as a place that sometimes has cookies on the menu."
NeutralFrom post: Savory Croissants
"Commenter listed Hanis as a place with good savory options."
NeutralFrom post: Best Midtown Bakeriescafes
"Hani's is listed as a recommended bakery/cafe."
PositiveFrom post: Nycs Best New Dishes Of 2025 New York The
"This user seconded Hani's Bakery & Caf uevo as a recommended spot."
PositiveFrom post: Crunchyhard Cookies Recs
"Hani's is mentioned as having thinner cookies that many people like, although the commenter found them just okay."
NeutralFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Enjoys the rice krispie treat and chocolate cake but was underwhelmed by the honey cake and other items. Agrees that prices are high for NYC."
NeutralFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Found the pistachio halva rice krispie treat disappointing, too sweet, lacking in pistachios and spices, and overpriced after a long wait."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Considers the cinnamon rolls at Hani's to be among the best they've ever had."
PositiveFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Found the cinnamon roll overrated but enjoyed other items, particularly the rice crispy treat."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Recommends trying the Paneer Tikka pinwheel for its sweet and savory balance, and also praises the chocolate zucchini muffin."
PositiveFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"This user commented that the flavors at Hani's are 'slightly off' and finds it odd, unsure if it's due to ingredients or recipes."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Finds Hani's overpriced and overhyped, with their chocolate chip cookie paling in comparison to others like Pastry Box and From Lucie."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"Echoing another user, this commenter found that while Hani's items look beautiful, the taste was consistently underwhelming across multiple visits."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"This commenter has tried Hani's multiple times but finds the taste falls flat despite the appealing appearance, questioning the hype."
NegativeFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"On a repeat visit, the reviewer found the baked goods to be delicious and unique, highlighting the shakshuka Danish and pistachio halva rice krispie treat. They noted that items are pricier than average."
NegativeFrom post: Any Spots Near The East Village For Sweet Or Fun
"Hani's in Astor Place is recommended by a commenter."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Trip Itinerary
"Hani's is mentioned as another recommended bakery in addition to Radio Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: The 25 Essential Pastries To Eat In New York City
"The author enjoyed Hani's honey cake but was surprised by the attention it received, noting that many Eastern European bakeries offer honey cake in various styles."
PositiveFrom post: The 25 Essential Pastries To Eat In New York City
"The author found Hani's honey cake to be too sweet and difficult to eat, preferring other items from the bakery."
NegativeFrom post: The 25 Essential Pastries To Eat In New York City
"The author found Hani's honey cake not amazing, lacking sufficient burnt honey flavor, and suggested other items there are better."
Negative