Next.js logo

UPSIDE PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (917) 587-8888

Address: 2878 BROADWAY 10025

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A Harlem pizza gem known for its standout mushroom slice, delivering a solid pie experience and a reliable option in the neighborhood.

Reddit Sentiment for UPSIDE PIZZA(based on 8 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive38% Neutral13% Negative

Tags

italian 7pizza 6garlic knots 4View All

Neighborhoods

Morningside Heights

Details

This pizza spot is a go-to for many, consistently delivering solid pies that stand out, especially in areas where good pizza might be scarce. While the mushroom slice has garnered significant praise, other offerings like garlic knots tend to be more of a mixed bag, with some finding them just okay. It's a place many return to for a satisfying pizza experience.

Food Overview

The star of the show is undoubtedly the pizza, with the mushroom slice being a particular favorite among patrons. While the pizza generally receives high marks, the garlic knots have been described as just okay by some. The cuisine is primarily Italian, with a focus on pizza.

Highlights / Recommended

"The mushroom slice is highly recommended and a favorite among customers. Some patrons also enjoy the signature slice, finding it very filling."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards this pizza place, with many praising their signature slices. However, some of their other offerings, like garlic knots, have received mixed reviews.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About UPSIDE PIZZA

Garlic knots at Upside Pizza
This thread discusses Upside Pizza, with a user specifically praising their mushroom slice but finding the garlic knots to be just okay. Other users chime in with their experiences, some expressing strong loyalty to the pizza while having varied opinions on the knots.
Where is the best pizza in Harlem?
Upside Pizza is mentioned as one of several restaurant recommendations in Harlem, indicating its presence and positive reception within the local dining scene.
Garlic knots at Upside Pizza
One user highlights their love for Upside Pizza, particularly their signature slice which is so filling they haven't yet tried the garlic knots.
Garlic knots at Upside Pizza
A user finds Upside Pizza to be a solid choice, especially considering the limited availability of other good pizza options in the area.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user finds Upside Pizza to be a solid option, especially given the perceived lack of other good pizza places in the vicinity."

Positive
Oct 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user is a big fan of Upside Pizza, particularly their mushroom slice, but tried the garlic knots on a subsequent visit and found them to be just okay. They also mentioned that Unregular Pizza has the best mushroom pizza."

Neutral
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user expresses a general positive sentiment towards Upside Pizza."

Positive
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user, who likes sauce and bread, has not had Upside Pizza in a while but recalls it being solid when they had only one location. They are not typically a fan of garlic knots due to them often being dry."

Neutral
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"This user questions if there can be too much garlic on a garlic knot, receiving a strong negative reaction from other users."

Negative
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user loves Upside Pizza but has not tried the garlic knots because they are usually too full from their signature slice."

Positive
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Garlic Knots At Upside Pizza

"The user is a regular at Upside Pizza's Nolita and Garment District/Times Square locations and enjoys their offerings."

Positive
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Is The Best Pizza In Harlem

"Upside was listed among several restaurant recommendations in Harlem."

Neutral
Jun 30, 2025View Comment →

More in Morningside Heights

See all

More italian in NYC

See all