FAMOUS JOE'S PIZZA

Last Updated: 8 days ago

Address: 7 CARMINE STREET 10014

TLDR

Classic NYC slice joint, OG West Village spot. Solid, reliable, debates rage if it's still the king, but always a go-to.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 340 Reddit comments)

42% Positive44% Neutral14% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Neighborhoods

West Village

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

Famously known for its classic New York-style pizza, this West Village institution has been a go-to spot for decades. While many agree it's a solid, reliable choice, opinions on its current standing vary, with some lamenting a perceived decline in quality while others staunchly defend its iconic status. Despite the debates, it remains a popular destination for those seeking a quintessential slice of the city.

Food Overview

This pizzeria is celebrated for its New York-style pizza, particularly the plain cheese slice and pepperoni. While many find it to be a consistently good and classic option, some commenters have noted issues with crust, sauce sweetness, or perceived decline in quality over the years. The Carmine Street location is often cited as the definitive and best-tasting branch.

Highlights / Recommended

"The plain cheese slice and pepperoni slice are frequently recommended. The original Carmine Street location is often highlighted as the best place to get a slice."

Mentioned Dishes:

plain slice(3)
pizza (carmine street)(2)
pizza (times square)(2)
crust(2)
sauce(2)
plain cheese slice(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is divided, with many praising it as a classic, reliable New York slice, while others feel it's overrated or has declined in quality.

Important Note

Some users report inconsistency in quality, with certain locations or slices being better than others. There are also debates about whether the quality has declined over the years.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Clarifying things on Joe's

This extensive thread discusses the merits and demerits of Joe's Pizza, with many users defending it as the quintessential New York slice and others arguing it has declined in quality or is simply overrated. It highlights the difference in opinion between long-time locals and newer residents.

Bleecker Street Pizza or Joe's Pizza on Carmine St?

This post directly compares Joe's Pizza on Carmine Street with Bleecker Street Pizza. The consensus leans towards Joe's as the superior choice, with some users noting the plain slice is reliable while the fresh mozzarella is also favored by others.

Manhattan pizza tour - my list and other

This user discusses Joe's Pizza on Carmine Street as a baseline for good pizza and a 'gatekeeper' of the style, particularly noting its movie fame. They consider it a reasonable choice, similar in taste to other well-regarded slice shops.

My food spree in my 7 days in NYC

This post is a tourist's food diary that includes Joe's Pizza. While the original poster found it to be a 'wet soup' needing two hands, other commenters debated its quality, with some noting a decline and others advising to eat it fresh on-site.

What's a place that everyone recommends, but you...

In a discussion about widely recommended but divisive restaurants, Joe's Pizza is mentioned. Some users find it inconsistent, with the Carmine Street location usually being better but still subject to quality fluctuations.