Classic NYC slice spot w/ thin crust & great sauce. Some debate if it's overrated, but original location remains a fave.
Joe's Pizza is a quintessential New York slice shop that has garnered a dedicated following for its classic, no-frills approach to pizza. While many rave about the thin crust and flavorful tomato sauce, some critics argue that certain locations are overrated or have seen a dip in quality. Nonetheless, the original Carmine Street location remains a beloved spot, praised for its consistency and authentic New York pizza experience, making it a popular stop for both locals and tourists.
Joe's Pizza is celebrated for its classic New York-style pizza, particularly its thin crust and flavorful sauce. While many find the pepperoni cheese and regular slices to be highlights, a portion of customers feel it's overrated or has declined in quality, with some criticizing specific locations for being burnt or having mediocre toppings. Despite some negative feedback, the Carmine Street location is frequently cited as the best and most authentic.
"The regular slice and plain cheese slice are frequently recommended as highlights. The pepperoni cheese slice is also noted as a solid, craveable option."
Customers generally have a positive view of Joe's Pizza, often hailing it as a classic New York slice. However, opinions can be divided, with some finding it overrated or noting a decline in quality over the years, while others consistently praise its taste and thin-crust style.
Important Note
Some customers report that certain locations, like 14th Street or Times Square, can be overrated, too thin, or have long lines. There are also differing opinions on whether the quality has declined over the years, and one user reported a very high price of $8 for a slice, though this was disputed by others.
"Joe's on Carmine is mentioned as the original Joe's location and is a good option for pizza, often with shorter lines than the Times Square branch."
Positive"Joe's Pizza in the West Village is recommended for a classic New York slice."
Positive"The commenter has a personal preference for a slice of Joe's in West Village straight out of the oven, citing nostalgic reasons and emphasizing that it should never be reheated."
Positive"The user advises getting a slice at Joe's on Carmine Street to experience something unique, suggesting it's a worthwhile alternative to more hyped places."
Positive"The commenter strongly advises against visiting Joe's Pizza."
Negative"This user dismisses Joe's, along with John's, as just another pizza place, criticizing the hype and long waits associated with such establishments."
Negative"The commenter expresses fondness for Joe's, viewing it as a classic slice that evokes childhood memories when out and about in NYC."
Positive"The commenter includes Joe's as part of a recommended pizza tour in the West Village, noting its close proximity to other pizzerias."
Neutral"This user points out that Joe's Pizza's prices are clearly displayed at the register and expresses sympathy for the original poster being overcharged."
Neutral"The original poster sarcastically concedes to the multiple comments about Joe's Pizza price, implying their previous statement was a 'ploy' to harm the institution, without clarifying the actual price they paid."
Neutral"The original poster defends their payment at Joe's Pizza, citing a busy rush and lack of a detailed receipt, then sarcastically dismisses the ongoing price debate."
Neutral"The original poster states they were asked for $8 for a single slice at Joe's Pizza and believes it was the cashier's mistake rather than their own."
Neutral"This user confirms that a slice at Joe's Pizza was $4 just last week."
Neutral"This user states that a slice at Joe's Pizza was $4 on the day of the comment, further contradicting the original poster's claim of an $8 slice."
Neutral"Joe's Pizza is recognized as an 'old school titan' among New York's best pizzerias."
Positive"This user presses the original poster to clarify if they were charged for two slices at Joe's Pizza, as an $8 price for a single regular slice is unusually high, even for specialty pizzerias."
Neutral"This user confirms that a slice at Joe's Pizza is definitely not $8."
Neutral"The original poster speculates that they might have been erroneously charged for two slices at Joe's Pizza, which would explain the $8 price tag."
Neutral"The original poster affirms they did pay $8 for a slice at Joe's Pizza and questions why they would lie about it, despite other users disputing the price."
Neutral"This user directly refutes the claim that a slice at Joe's Pizza costs $8."
Neutral
