TLDR
Creative, chef-driven pies from a culinary mastermind, celebrated for bold, experimental flavor combinations that remain top-tier even after delivery.
Details
Founded by renowned chef Wylie Dufresne, this creative pizza spot has gained a reputation for being a severely underrated gem in the city [1]. While many diners praise the consistently excellent flavors and unique menu items [1], others have pointed to inconsistencies like overly charred crusts or frustrations with delivery services [1]. Following a three-year run, the original Flatiron location has closed to allow the brand to focus on its Williamsburg operations at Domino Park [2].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on unique, chef-driven American-style pizzas that frequently earn praise for their interesting flavor profiles and ability to reheat well [1]. Standout mentions include the 'ploughman' pizza [1] and the 'al pastor' pizza [1], while others have expressed disappointment with the 'Toga' pizza's heavy onion ratio [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'ploughman' pizza and 'al pastor' pizza are frequently cited as top choices among diners [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •al pastor pizza(2)
Caveats
Some customers have noted issues with delivery reliability [1] and potential inconsistency in the char levels of the pizza [1]. Additionally, there is feedback that the pricing may feel high relative to the overall dining experience [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About STRETCH PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Ceres Question Best Choice And Ordering Process
"The commenter agrees that the pizza at Stretch is great."
PositiveFrom post: Ceres Question Best Choice And Ordering Process
"The commenter recommends Stretch for its solid pizzas and other dishes."
PositiveFrom post: Ceres Question Best Choice And Ordering Process
"The commenter suggests visiting Stretch as an alternative to Ceres because it offers more value."
PositiveFrom post: Food Ideas For My 6 Yr Old Me Mostly In Manhattan
"Suggested as an experimental pizza option."
NeutralFrom post: Sofia Pizza Shoppe Midtown Eastues Closed
"The user mentions that there is an outpost of Stretch located in The Hugh."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user found Stretch Pizza to be fine but definitely overpriced, possibly due to high expectations associated with a Wylie Dufresne restaurant."
NegativeFrom post: Kids Dinner
"Stretch Pizza was mentioned as a possible dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user simply commented 'burnt pizza' in relation to a picture."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"Acknowledging a previous correct mention, this user confirmed the third slice location for Stretch Pizza in Domino Park."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user agreed that the pizza might have been cooked slightly longer than usual, but flavor-wise, it did not taste burnt."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user added that Stretch Pizza has a third slice location in Domino Park."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user acknowledged the flavor was good but noted that the char on the pepperoni in the picture might indicate slight burning, suggesting a possible cooking mistake."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user humorously mentions liking Wylie Dufresne because a friend dislikes him, and urges people to support Stretch Pizza to ensure its success."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"In response to concerns about charring, this commenter stated that the pizza they had on-site was not that charred and tasted good, even if it was a bit more cooked than usual."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This commenter notes that Stretch Pizza began by using the ovens at Breads in Union Square at night and expresses happiness at their growth and success."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user enjoyed their pizza at Stretch Pizza but did not find it particularly memorable."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user states that Stretch Pizza is super slept on, with the 'Nellie' pizza being their go-to, noting that it requires a love for onions."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user, upon seeing a picture of Stretch Pizza, commented that it looked overly charred, possibly due to a cooking error, though they trust Wylie Dufresne's expertise."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user plans to try Uber Eats for Stretch Pizza delivery, specifically to avoid issues they've experienced with Grubhub."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user commented that Stretch Pizza does not receive enough recognition."
Positive