Details
This pizza spot is considered by many to be a hidden gem, significantly underrated and consistently delivering excellent, interesting flavors that reheat well [1]. While some find the pizza to be overly charred in photos, those who have tasted it on-site often report it's delicious, even if slightly more cooked than usual [1]. The restaurant is associated with Chef Wylie Dufresne, known for his molecular gastronomy background at wd~50 [1].
Food Overview
This establishment is highly regarded for its pizza, with many considering it one of the best in the city and a place that holds up well, even via delivery [1]. Specific mentions include an amazing al pastor pizza and a very good cauliflower side [1]. However, there are mixed opinions on charring, with some photos showing overly charred crusts, though taste reviews vary [1]. The 'Toga' pizza was noted as disappointing due to too many onions and not enough guanciale [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'al pastor pizza' and 'ploughman pizza' have been highly recommended, with the latter praised for its unusual yet successful flavor combination. The 'Nellie' pizza is a go-to for those who enjoy onions. Sliders are also mentioned as a recommended item [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •al pastor pizza(2)
Caveats
Some users have experienced consistent issues with delivery service [1]. There are also differing opinions on the pizza's charring and specific dishes like the 'Toga' pizza [1]. One user found the restaurant to be overpriced [1]. There's a sentiment that the Williamsburg location is 'awful' [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About STRETCH PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Sofia Pizza Shoppe Midtown Eastues Closed
"The user mentions that there is an outpost of Stretch located in The Hugh."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user found Stretch Pizza to be fine but definitely overpriced, possibly due to high expectations associated with a Wylie Dufresne restaurant."
NegativeFrom post: Kids Dinner
"Stretch Pizza was mentioned as a possible dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user simply commented 'burnt pizza' in relation to a picture."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"Acknowledging a previous correct mention, this user confirmed the third slice location for Stretch Pizza in Domino Park."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user agreed that the pizza might have been cooked slightly longer than usual, but flavor-wise, it did not taste burnt."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user added that Stretch Pizza has a third slice location in Domino Park."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user acknowledged the flavor was good but noted that the char on the pepperoni in the picture might indicate slight burning, suggesting a possible cooking mistake."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user humorously mentions liking Wylie Dufresne because a friend dislikes him, and urges people to support Stretch Pizza to ensure its success."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"In response to concerns about charring, this commenter stated that the pizza they had on-site was not that charred and tasted good, even if it was a bit more cooked than usual."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This commenter notes that Stretch Pizza began by using the ovens at Breads in Union Square at night and expresses happiness at their growth and success."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user enjoyed their pizza at Stretch Pizza but did not find it particularly memorable."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user states that Stretch Pizza is super slept on, with the 'Nellie' pizza being their go-to, noting that it requires a love for onions."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user, upon seeing a picture of Stretch Pizza, commented that it looked overly charred, possibly due to a cooking error, though they trust Wylie Dufresne's expertise."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user plans to try Uber Eats for Stretch Pizza delivery, specifically to avoid issues they've experienced with Grubhub."
NeutralFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user commented that Stretch Pizza does not receive enough recognition."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This commenter highly recommends the 'ploughman' pizza from Stretch Pizza, calling it one of their favorites in the city due to its unusual yet successful flavor combination."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user considers Stretch Pizza their go-to spot for a lunch slice, appreciating its straightforward quality without any pretense."
PositiveFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user stated that the Stretch Pizza location in Williamsburg is awful."
NegativeFrom post: Stretch Pizza
"This user recalls an experience with Chef Wylie Dufresne making a breakfast sandwich at Du's Donuts, highlighting his presence and personal touch."
Neutral