Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 247-3491
Address: 236 WEST 56 STREET 10019
Old-school NYC Italian w/ celeb history & classic red sauce fare. Famously Frank Sinatra's fave.
Experience a taste of classic New York Italian at this historic eatery, a favorite among celebrities like Frank Sinatra. It's known for its old-school ambiance and traditional red sauce dishes, offering a quintessential slice of the city's culinary heritage. While many praise its classic charm and accommodating service, some newer reviews suggest the food quality may not match its storied past.
The restaurant is celebrated for its traditional Italian-American red sauce cuisine, reminiscent of a classic New York dining experience. It's frequently mentioned as a great spot for pizza and those seeking an old-school vibe. However, some recent feedback indicates that the food quality might not be as exceptional as it once was, with a few recommending skipping it if food quality is the primary concern.
"The restaurant is frequently mentioned for its pizza and classic red sauce Italian dishes, embodying a traditional New York dining experience."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often highlighting the classic Italian-American atmosphere and service, though a few recent opinions suggest a decline in food quality compared to its heyday.
Important Note
Some recent reviews suggest that while the ambiance and classic feel are preserved, the food quality may have declined over the years.
"Patsy's is suggested for an old-school Italian dining experience, noting they can prepare dishes not on the menu, and it's a bit further west from the user's location."
Neutral"Lists Patsy's as a recommended pizza place in Midtown."
Positive"Recommends Patsy's in Harlem."
Positive"Mentions Patsy's as a recommended pizza spot."
Positive"The user, from Europe, is not overly concerned about the food being exceptional, prioritizing the classic New York experience and atmosphere over high-quality Italian food."
Neutral"Responding to a query about why Patsy's isn't recommended, this user states the food is simply not very good, especially with so many better Italian options in NYC. They suggest skipping it if food quality is important, or visiting if the draw is the tourist attraction and classic experience."
Negative"The user asked for more details on why Patsy's might not be liked, acknowledging mixed reviews and the possibility of it being more of a classic New York Italian experience than a high-quality food destination."
Neutral"Patsy's on West 56th is described as an old-school Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin-esque restaurant with great classic food, ambiance, and service."
Positive"This user, who lives across the street from Patsy's, strongly advises against it, stating the food was good 30 years ago but is not good now. They emphasize that despite living so close and frequently eating Italian food, they would not eat there."
Negative"The user initially thanked JayMoots for the recommendation of Patsy's, noting it sounds like the type of classic New York Italian experience they are looking for."
Positive"Patsy's in midtown Manhattan is described as an old-school, classic red sauce restaurant, still family-owned and famously Frank Sinatra's favorite."
Positive"Carmine's or Patsy's are suggested as good options."
Neutral"Patsy's on West 56th is recommended as a dining option."
Positive"Patsy's on W 56th is recommended as an old-school spot."
Positive"Patsy's Italian Restaurant on W 56th St is recommended as the place to go."
Positive"Patsy's is recommended as an old-school red sauce Italian place that is accommodating with requests."
Positive"Patsy's is mentioned as an Italian restaurant that was a favorite of Frank Sinatra."
Neutral"A commenter mentions Patsy's Italian Restaurant in Midtown, noting its history of serving celebrities like Frank Sinatra and its legal feuds with the East Harlem pizzeria over the name 'Patsy's'."
Neutral"The commenter stated they would personally pick Patsy's for a wedding dinner, characterizing it as a quaint and classic Italian restaurant."
Positive"There's a Patsy's a couple blocks south."
Neutral
