Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (212) 247-3491
Address: 236 WEST 56 STREET 10019
Classic red-sauce Italian, Sinatra's fave. Old-school vibe, family-owned charm.
Step into a piece of New York history at this classic Italian-American institution, famously a favorite of Frank Sinatra. This old-school red-sauce joint offers a quintessential New York dining experience, complete with a warm ambiance and traditional fare. While some debate its current culinary standing, many still cherish it for its nostalgic charm and consistent quality.
This establishment is primarily known for its Italian-American, red-sauce cuisine, with pizza being frequently mentioned. While many recall it fondly as a classic choice, a segment of reviewers suggest that the food quality may not be what it once was, recommending it more for the experience than for exceptional culinary innovation.
"While specific dishes are not consistently highlighted, pizza is frequently mentioned. Some diners also appreciate the classic red-sauce Italian fare."
Customer opinions are divided, with some praising its classic ambiance and welcoming nature for families, while others feel the food quality has declined over the years.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the food quality may have declined from its peak, and one commenter described it as a tourist trap with poor service.
"Delivery orders from Patsy's can sometimes result in a soggy pizza."
Negative"Regarding pizza crust preference, Patsy's can be chewy, and the knockoff versions in Midtown also offer a chewy fold."
Neutral"Despite enjoying ordering from Patsy's, dining in is not recommended due to slow service and an outdated, unkempt environment."
Negative"The "Patsy special pie" in Harlem is a top-rated dish, noted for its garlic flavor."
Positive"For Patsy's, ordering the pizza 'well done' is recommended if you are unsure about liking it, as it can sometimes be a bit soft."
Neutral"While takeout from the original Patsy's is good, dining in has resulted in soggy, undercooked pizza multiple times."
Negative"Patsy's is great for dining in; the thin crust pizza is enjoyable and can be finished in one sitting."
Positive"A slice of pizza from Patsy's in Harlem last summer, fresh out of the oven, was very good."
Positive"Patsy's is still excellent for dining in."
Positive"According to hearsay, the original Patsy's remains quite good."
Positive"The pistachio sauce on ravioli at the non-original Patsy's (East Side locations) is praised, despite the commenter preferring the slice at the original Patsy's."
Positive"Patsy's Italian on W. 56th Street (not the pizzeria chain) is recommended for its excellent food and is a favorite of Frank Sinatra."
Positive"Patsy's is listed as a recommended Italian restaurant if one is willing to consider options slightly outside the immediate Times Square area but still in Midtown."
Positive"Patsy's Italian Restaurant is recommended as very old school and having great food, reportedly being Frank Sinatra's favorite."
Positive"Patsy's is listed as a place to avoid, deemed a tourist trap with bad service and average food."
Negative"Patsy's on 57th street is recommended as accessible, beloved, and legitimately old-school with mobster connections, though this commenter did not personally enjoy it."
Neutral"A recent visit to Patsy's was disappointing, with the food being not good, and the commenter suggests many better alternatives."
Negative"This commenter lives across the street from Patsy's and prefers Joe G's, which is next door."
Neutral"The original poster is considering Patsy's, along with John's of 12th St. and Arthur & Sons."
Positive"Patsy's Italian Restaurant on West 56th St. is presented as an old-school option with great food, claiming to be Frank Sinatra's favorite."
Positive
