Next.js logo

ELEPHANT & CASTLE

Updated

Phone: (212) 243-1400

Address: 68 GREENWICH AVENUE 10011

TLDR

A West Village gem serving up hearty American classics w/ generous portions & fair prices for over 50 yrs. Known for its underrated Elephant Burger & unique Eggs Benedict.

Reddit Sentiment for ELEPHANT & CASTLE(based on 33 Reddit opinions)

48% Positive18% Neutral33% Negative

Tags

american 7european 2brunch 6eggs benedict 4burger 4View All

Neighborhoods

West Village

Details

A beloved West Village institution for over 50 years, Elephant & Castle was a go-to for hearty American fare with generous portions at economical prices. Known for its consistently good food and friendly atmosphere, it was a reliable spot for breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. Despite its long history and dedicated clientele, the restaurant recently closed its doors.

Food Overview

Elephant & Castle was celebrated for its American cuisine, offering a wide variety of dishes including sandwiches, salads, omelets, and burgers. The 'Elephant Burger,' often described as the most underrated in NYC, was a standout, noted for its exceptional taste with curried sour cream, bacon, and cheddar. Brunch items, particularly the Eggs Benedict (sometimes served on a potato pancake) and perfectly poached eggs, were also highly recommended. While most feedback is positive, there are no dishes explicitly mentioned as being avoided.

Highlights / Recommended

"The 'Elephant Burger' is frequently cited as the most underrated burger in NYC, lauded for its unique curried sour cream and other toppings. Brunch dishes, especially the Eggs Benedict (sometimes on a potato pancake) and perfectly poached eggs, are also highly recommended."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • elephantburger(4)
  • elephant burger(3)
  • eggs & apples benedict(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly held a positive sentiment towards Elephant & Castle, consistently praising its excellent food, generous portions, and economical prices, often referring to it as a neighborhood gem. The recent closure has elicited significant sadness and nostalgia from its loyal patrons.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About ELEPHANT & CASTLE

This post announces the closure of Elephant & Castle, citing insufficient patronage and a lack of interest from younger generations. It notes the food was described as excellent and mentions the Elephantburger and a poached egg breakfast dish as highly recommended.
A commenter extensively praises Elephant & Castle for its location, great food, generous portions, variety, economical prices, and long presence in the West Village. They specifically highlight the 'Elephant Burger' as the most underrated in NY.
This post details a positive brunch experience at Elephant & Castle, highlighting a poached eggs dish with balsamic, tarragon, tomatoes, avocado, and mushrooms as very good. The user also mentions loving the Elephantburger from a previous visit.
A user raves about the Elephantburger, describing the curried sour cream, bacon, scallion, and cheddar as exceptional, and also commends the perfectly cut fries.
A commenter recommends Elephant & Castle on Greenwich Avenue, a long-standing restaurant, specifically for its Elephant Burger, calling it the most underrated in the city.
A user suggests Elephant & Castle, mentioning their unique offering of Eggs Benedict served on a potato pancake.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter noted that Elephant and Castle closed recently."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter noted that Elephant and Castle closed recently."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter also stated that Elephant and Castle is closed."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter also stated that Elephant and Castle is closed."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Final Visit To Elephant Castle Eggs And Apples

"A commenter expressed sadness regarding the closure of Elephant & Castle."

Negative
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

More in West Village

See all

More American in NYC

See all