Next.js logo

MASTRO'S STEAKHOUSE

Updated

Phone: (212) 459-1222

Address: 1285 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10019

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Upscale steakhouse known for excellent cuts, a standout bread service, and a lively bar area perfect for sports viewing.

Reddit Sentiment for MASTRO'S STEAKHOUSE(based on 6 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive50% Neutral

Tags

american 3steak 4View All

Neighborhoods

Theater District

Details

This high-end steakhouse is widely regarded as a premier destination for those seeking a top-tier dining experience [4], [6]. Patrons frequently highlight the quality of the steaks and the exceptional bread service as standout features of their visit [3], [4]. Additionally, the bar area is well-equipped with televisions, making it a great spot for catching a game while enjoying a meal [3].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on premium American steakhouse fare, with the filet mignon earning specific praise from guests [3]. The complimentary bread service is also frequently noted as a highlight of the dining experience [3].

Highlights / Recommended

The filet is highly recommended by patrons, and the butter cake is frequently cited as a must-try dessert option.

Customer Sentiment

Overall feedback is consistently positive, with diners frequently recommending the establishment for its high-quality steak and welcoming environment [4], [6]. Visitors have expressed particular enthusiasm for the menu offerings, including a celebrated butter cake.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MASTRO'S STEAKHOUSE

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1wlfgnd/nyc_steakhouse_showdown_for_a_40th_birthday_keens/
This post features a discussion where this location is highlighted as a hipper, excellent steakhouse choice for a 40th birthday celebration.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1ol3w28/where_can_i_watch_the_world_series_and_still_have/
This thread recommends the restaurant for its quality steak and bread service, while noting the presence of TVs in the bar area.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1pvnnq6/all_the_food_for_an_excellent_40th_birthday/
A brief recommendation confirming the restaurant as a suitable venue for a high-quality steak experience.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Nyc Steakhouse Showdown For A 40th Birthday Keens

"Suggested for a hipper, excellent steakhouse experience."

Positive
Sep 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Needing Some Birthday Steakhouse Suggestions

"The restaurant was suggested in response to a request for high-end steakhouse recommendations."

Neutral
Jul 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: All The Food For An Excellent 40th Birthday

"Mastro's is recommended for steak, suggesting it's a suitable venue for a high-quality steak experience."

Positive
Dec 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Can I Watch The World Series And Still Have

"Mastros has several TVs in the bar area. Their filet is good and they offer a great bread service."

Positive
Oct 31, 2025View Comment →

From post: Gallaghers Or Wolfgangs Or Others

"In response to 'Maestro', the commenter asks for clarification if it's 'Mastro's'."

Neutral
Oct 15, 2025View Comment →

More in Theater District

See all

More American in NYC

See all