TLDR
Authentic old-school NYC vibe in the West Village with a standout bar, ideal for solo dining or romantic evenings. Renowned for its lively atmosphere and consistently solid American-Italian fare.
Details
A West Village staple defined by its old-school New York charm, this spot is frequently praised for its moody ambiance and versatile dining experience [30]. The menu features a mix of reliable American and Italian-inspired dishes that often draw positive reviews for consistency [16], [17]. While some diners find the atmosphere reminiscent of other local haunts [14], [38], it remains a popular choice for those seeking a romantic dinner or a reliable solo meal at the bar [4], [25], [41].
Food Overview
The kitchen offers a mix of American and Italian dishes, with high praise for items like the roast beef au jus [34], pasta, and the 'god-tier' Spaghetti Anchoiade [43]. Diners also recommend the proteins [27] and seasonal offerings like morels [44], though some have noted the menu feels similar to other casual eateries [11]. The lunch pasta special is frequently cited as a great value [6], [7].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Spaghetti Anchoiade is a standout favorite, alongside the roast beef au jus [34], [43]. The pasta options and protein dishes are also frequently recommended for their quality [27], [43]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •mashed potatoes(4)
- •pasta(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is generally positive, with many diners appreciating the vibrant atmosphere and the quality of the bar-seated dining experience [41], [42]. While some visitors feel the hype is occasionally overstated or the vibe too similar to other neighborhood spots, many find it a reliable and enjoyable destination [14], [15], [38].
Caveats
Some visitors report inconsistent quality or find the hype to be unwarranted, noting that it may not offer a unique enough experience compared to other local options [15], [38]. Service has been described as spotty by some diners [18].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ANTON'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Casual Italian In West Village Area For Group
"Suggested in the West Village."
NeutralFrom post: Casual Italian In West Village Area For Group
"Suggested as a location in the West Village."
NeutralFrom post: Dinner Spots For Taking Out Visiting Parents In
"Anton is recommended as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Small Localneighborhood Italian
"Antons is mentioned as a restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Any Restaurants That Serve Morels Now That Theyre
"The commenter stated that this restaurant had morels available during their visit in late April."
PositiveFrom post: Best Affordable Italian Restaurant Nyc
"This user recommended Anton's Spaghetti Anchoiade as god-tier."
PositiveFrom post: Spots Where Bar Seated Meal Is Great
"The commenter listed Anton's as a restaurant where dining at the bar is enjoyable."
PositiveFrom post: Spots Where Bar Seated Meal Is Great
"Anton's is recommended for its ambiance and great food when dining at the bar."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is The Best Nyc French Dip
"Anton's is described as having solid food, strong vibes, and a great location, although the commenter has not tried their French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is The Best Nyc French Dip
"Anton's is suggested as a potential place for French Dip."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Dirty Martini Recs
"Anton's was recommended for dirty martinis if budget is not a concern."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Dinner In West Villagesoho
"Anton's was mentioned as a place offering good happy hour specials for both food and drinks, making it a potential birthday dinner spot."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Dinner Recommendations
"This commenter listed Anton's as a recommended Italian restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Take Your Mentor To Lunch
"This user listed Anton as a potential restaurant for lunch."
PositiveFrom post: Sexy Restaurants In West Villagethe Village Or
"Anton's is listed as a 'moody adult restaurant' that aligns with the user's request."
PositiveFrom post: Whats A Fancy Spot With Cheese Ravioli On The Menu
"This user listed Anton's as a potential place for cheese ravioli."
NeutralFrom post: French Dip Or Roast Beef Recommendations In
"Anton's roast beef au jus is excellent, with a view of 'attractive affluent West Villagers'."
PositiveFrom post: Where Should I Take My Uncle Offbrand Anthony
"Anton's was deemed too similar to the West Village date spot vibe and not worldly enough for the occasion."
NegativeFrom post: Where Should I Take My Uncle Offbrand Anthony
"Thanks for the feedback on Anton's, which helps in narrowing down the choices. The user found it similar to USC but without the history."
NeutralFrom post: Where Should I Take My Uncle Offbrand Anthony
"Anton's was considered good but not worth it for an out-of-towner compared to other options."
Neutral