TLDR
Old-school New York vibe with a moody, adult atmosphere in the West Village; perfect for solo bar dining and high-quality comfort classics.
Details
Known for its authentic old-school New York vibe, this West Village establishment captures a moody, adult atmosphere [9]. It has earned praise for its solid food offerings, ranging from excellent roast beef au jus to standout Italian-inspired dishes [12], [22], [25]. While many diners laud its consistent quality and lively bar scene, others suggest it may feel similar to other local spots [14], [16], [23].
Food Overview
While classified as American, the kitchen excels with Italian influences, serving notable dishes like Spaghetti Anchoiade, baked clams, and ricotta ravioli [7], [25], [30], [31]. Diners also highly recommend the roast beef au jus and are appreciative of seasonal ingredients like morels [12], [26].
Caveats
Some diners have noted that the restaurant can feel quite crowded [33], and others have suggested it may not feel distinct enough from other West Village options to justify a special trip for out-of-towners [14], [16].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ANTON'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"The user found the experience crowded and just okay, not noteworthy."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"A West Village spot recommended by the user."
PositiveFrom post: Dimlylit Intimate Cheap Recs For Birthday Dinner
"Suggested as a recommendation located in the West Village."
NeutralFrom post: I Need To Find The Truffle Moneybags From Now
"The user suggests trying the ricotta ravioli at Anton's, noting it is good but not identical to the original truffle moneybags requested."
Positive