Generous family-style Italian w/ massive portions & decades of history. A go-to for groups & celebrations.
A long-standing Manhattan institution, this Italian eatery is celebrated for its family-style dining and exceptionally large portions. Many patrons have fond memories spanning decades, highlighting its consistent appeal for groups and celebratory meals. The restaurant is often recommended as a solid, classic choice for authentic Italian-American cuisine.
This restaurant is known for its generous family-style portions of Italian-American classics. Dishes like linguini with white clam sauce and chicken parmigiana are frequently mentioned, alongside decadent family-sized desserts. While many recommend it for its comforting and abundant offerings, one reviewer called it a 'huge tourist trap' with mediocre food and poor service.
"The linguini white clam sauce is highly recommended, and the restaurant is known for its family-style portions of classics like chicken parmigiana and large, decadent desserts."
Customers frequently praise the restaurant for its large, family-style portions and classic Italian-American fare, often citing it as a long-standing favorite for group gatherings and celebratory meals.
Important Note
One reviewer described the restaurant as a 'huge tourist trap' with mediocre food and generally poor service, suggesting alternative locations or restaurants might be better choices.
"This commenter listed Tony DiNapoli as an overhyped, pricey restaurant with mediocre food and generally poor service."
Negative"This user suggests Tony's DiNapoli as an alternative to overpriced pasta."
Neutral"This commenter simply suggested Tony's Di Napoli as a potential option."
Positive"Tony's Di Napoli, located right off of Times Square, is described as looking like a tourist trap but is actually really good."
Positive"Tony Di Napoli is mentioned as a potential kid-friendly dining option, suitable for when the focus is on ensuring a child has a good time rather than fine dining."
Positive"The commenter highly recommends the linguini white clam sauce at Tony Di Napoli."
Positive"Carmine's is considered a tourist trap but has good food and fun family-style service suitable for large groups."
Positive"Carmine's is recommended as a suitable option for large groups."
Positive"This commenter believes Carmine's is the best choice for the request, despite being a bit of a tourist trap, due to its good food and fun family-style service for larger groups."
Positive"This commenter had a wonderful experience bringing their partner's family from the Midwest to Tony's Di Napoli, and highly recommends it."
Positive"Carmine's or Patsy's are suggested as good options."
Neutral"The commenter's older male colleagues in midtown banking love Tony Di Napoli."
Positive"This commenter had their rehearsal dinner at Tony's Di Napoli and found the food good and family-style, with everyone enjoying themselves."
Positive"Tony's Di Napoli is recommended as a place that older male colleagues in midtown love."
Positive"The user questioned the validity of national restaurant rankings, citing an example where Una Pizza Napoletana was ranked #1 and Tony's Pizza Napoletana #2 or 3 in a pizza ranking by an Italian society. They prefer rankings focused on specific categories or local markets."
Neutral"If Tony Di Napoli must be visited, the user recommends the 3rd Avenue location over the Times Square one and suggests Bar Primi for casual Italian."
Negative"This user strongly advises against visiting Tony Di Napoli, calling it a 'huge tourist trap' and suggesting seeking other Italian food recommendations."
Negative"Toni's is listed as a place that serves roast pork rice rolls, which might be similar to the dish the original poster is looking for."
Neutral"Tony's was suggested as a place to get a slice of pizza, located conveniently near Anthony and Sons."
Positive
