Decades-old family-style Italian eatery w/ HUGE portions. A go-to for classic red sauce dishes & group celebrations.
For decades, this classic family-style Italian restaurant has been a go-to for those seeking generous portions and a lively atmosphere. Diners rave about the traditional red sauce dishes, and many consider it a reliable choice for group gatherings and celebrations. The restaurant is known for its large platters of pasta and other Italian-American favorites, ensuring no one leaves hungry.
This restaurant specializes in family-style Italian-American cuisine, known for its exceptionally large portions. Popular choices include classic red sauce dishes, pasta, and hearty entrees. While many appreciate the generous servings and traditional flavors, a few find it to be overhyped and suggest other Italian options.
"Highly recommended dishes include the linguini white clam sauce and any of their classic family-style Italian-American entrees. Their 'francese' items are also specifically praised."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often recommending it for its large portions and family-style Italian-American classics. While some consider it a bit of a tourist trap, many find it to be a reliable and enjoyable dining experience, especially for groups.
Important Note
Some diners perceive the restaurant as a tourist trap with mediocre food and service, particularly in the Times Square location. It may be more suitable for large groups or families than for intimate dining.
"The user visited Tony's Di Napoli at 5 PM and was seated for a party of 6 with no wait. The restaurant became more crowded later."
Positive"This user has a slight preference for Tony di Napoli, specifically mentioning that their francese dishes are great."
Positive"This user listed Tony di Napoli as a potential option for family-style Italian dining."
Positive"The commenter recommended Carmine's or Tony's for Italian food, or a vegetarian Indian buffet like Bukhara."
Neutral"The commenter suggested Tony's Di Napoli."
Neutral"The commenter recommended Tony's di Napoli."
Negative"Tony's Di Napoli was recommended as a graduation celebration spot, described as having a great atmosphere and family-style Italian food that contributes to a positive dining experience."
Positive"This commenter expressed a dislike for Tony's Di Napoli, describing it as feeling like takeout quality. They suggested La Pecora Bianca as a more suitable option for a mother-daughter outing."
Negative"This commenter suggested replacing Tony's Di Napoli with Carmine's but also noted that either would be a waste of money and food for a small group of two."
Negative"While acknowledging a preference for Tony's Di Napoli, this commenter suggested Arthur and Sons or Carmine's as better alternatives."
Neutral"This commenter recommended Tony's Di Napoli, located in Times Square, as a great recent find. They highlighted the good food (mentioning lobster linguini and Tomahawk steak), amazing energy, singing waiter, solid drinks, old New York vibe, and ease of reservation."
Positive"The commenter notes they haven't been to Tony's Di Napoli but suggests it as a place they've considered."
Neutral"Tony di Napoli is mentioned as a reliable and established institution for dining, similar to Carmine's, and is considered a fine option."
Positive"Tony di Napoli is seconded for its reasonable prices in the Times Square area, good food, pleasant service, and ample seating."
Positive"Tony di Napoli is recommended as a fantastic Italian restaurant with great portion sizes, making it suitable for families."
Positive"Tony di Napoli is highlighted as the only choice for dining in the Times Square area, despite the general avoidance of the area."
Positive"Tony's di Napoli was mentioned as a restaurant option."
Neutral"Tony d'Apoli was suggested as a restaurant option."
Neutral"Tony's Di Napoli is suggested for Italian family-style dining, offering large portions that can fit within the budget if a few dishes are ordered and shared."
Positive"This commenter listed Tony DiNapoli as an overhyped, pricey restaurant with mediocre food and generally poor service."
Negative
