TLDR
Hearty family-style Italian staples in Times Square, perfect for large groups and celebrations. Surprisingly solid food despite the tourist-heavy location.
Reddit Sentiment for TONY'S DI NAPOLI(based on 71 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Tony Di Napoli's offers a generous bread basket to its patrons, featuring a variety of breads including seeded and olive-studded loaves, served with butter pats.
Tony's Di Napoli is recognized for its classic ice cream sundae. The dessert is generously portioned with multiple scoops of ice cream, piled high with whipped cream, and drizzled with chocolate sauce. A cherry and a birthday candle add a festive touch, making it suitable for celebrations.
Details
Located in the heart of Times Square, this establishment defies the 'tourist trap' label to offer a consistently solid Italian-American experience [3]. It is widely celebrated as an ideal venue for large groups and family-style celebrations, thanks to its energetic atmosphere and spacious seating [10], [32]. While some critics argue it can be overhyped or pricey, many locals and visitors alike praise the generous portion sizes and classic red sauce dishes [6], [12], [47].
Food Overview
This restaurant specializes in Italian-American family-style dining, known for huge portions designed to be shared [9], [30], [47]. Standout dishes include the chicken parmigiana, rigatoni a la vodka, and the shrimp frachese [32], [44]. While the food is generally considered reliable and satisfying, some patrons suggest that smaller parties might find the large-format portions less cost-effective [24].
Highly recommended dishes include the family-style chicken parmigiana, rigatoni a la vodka, and the 'sleeper hit' shrimp frachese [32], [44]. For sharing, diners often point to the large Caesar salad, linguini with seafood, and the classic ice cream sundae for dessert [32], [41], [45].
Overall feedback is generally positive, with guests frequently praising the lively atmosphere and the restaurant's ability to accommodate large groups [10], [32], [42]. While some diners feel it is overpriced or mediocre, many consider it a reliable institution for a fun, classic Italian-American meal [6], [15], [32].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01chicken parmigiana2 mentions
Caveats
The restaurant is often packed, making reservations highly recommended to avoid wait times [32]. Some diners find the atmosphere loud, and smaller groups may find the family-style pricing structure to be a poor value [24], [32].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TONY'S DI NAPOLI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Thoughts On Carmines For A Dinner During A Short
"Considered a fine touristy, family-style Italian alternative near Times Square."
NeutralFrom post: Who Has The Best Spaghetti And Meatballs In The
"Recommended for spaghetti and meatballs."
NeutralFrom post: Good Midtown Reservation Choices For 40yo Mom And
"Recommendation to order the Caesar salad as it is easy to share."
PositiveFrom post: Good Midtown Reservation Choices For 40yo Mom And
"The commenter notes that the restaurant is very good."
PositiveFrom post: Good Midtown Reservation Choices For 40yo Mom And
"This is described as a solid, consistent Italian-American staple with large portions, perfect for when you are very hungry."
Positive