Upscale Mexican w/ creative cocktails & solid guac. Great pre/post-theater option.
This Mexican restaurant offers a slightly upscale dining experience, perfect for pre- or post-theater outings. With a strong emphasis on creative cocktails and a diverse menu, it's a popular choice for those seeking authentic Mexican flavors in a sophisticated setting. Diners frequently praise the quality of the food and drinks, making it a reliable option for a flavorful meal.
The Mexican cuisine here is praised for its solid options and variety, particularly the guacamole. Specific dishes like lobster tacos and queso fundido receive positive mentions, as does the watermelon margarita. While generally well-regarded, one comment noted it can be pricey.
"Customers particularly recommend the lobster tacos, queso fundido, and the watermelon margarita. The variety of guacamole options is also frequently highlighted."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards this restaurant, highlighting its delicious food, creative cocktails, and upscale yet approachable ambiance.
Important Note
One user mentioned that the restaurant can be pricey.
"The commenter expressed a willingness to try Toloache, noting the general improvement of the city's taco scene and their desire to try huitlacoche tacos."
Positive"Toloache was mentioned as a place that offers huitlacoche tacos, with the commenter unsure of how its offerings would compare to others."
Neutral"Mentions Toloache as a place with good food and drinks that isn't too expensive."
Positive"A user suggests Toloache as one of four good options for dinner near the Gershwin Theatre but advises against having too many cocktails if concerned about walking afterwards."
Neutral"User is asking for dinner recommendations near the Gershwin Theatre, with a preference for restaurants within a few blocks of a subway station."
Neutral"Toloache is recommended as a nice Mexican spot with table service, contrasting with more casual taco stands."
Positive"Toloache was mentioned as a possible restaurant."
Neutral"Toloache was suggested for those willing to venture a bit north of Union Square."
Positive"The user suggests Toloache for Mexican food, describing it as a bit fancy but with great food, and recommends making a reservation."
Positive"This user lists Mexican Radio as a missed restaurant."
Neutral"Toloache was listed as a dining option."
Neutral"Toloache is listed among many good restaurants in the area."
Positive"Toloache is recommended for its queso fundido and ease of finding vegetarian options."
Positive"The commenter expressed liking Toloache for its more upscale and less casual ambiance."
Positive"The commenter agreed with the positive sentiment for Toloache, stating they love the place and specifically highlighting the awesome lobster tacos."
Positive"Toloache was recommended as "really good," noting its multiple locations in Midtown and the East 80s."
Positive"Toloache was described as "decently nice," with the Upper East Side location being the commenter's favorite."
Positive"Toloache received a concurring recommendation."
Positive"Toloache on 50th Street received a second recommendation."
Positive"Toloache, located near Times Square, was highly recommended for its great food and delicious fancy cocktails."
Positive
