Upscale Mexican dining w/ creative guac & cocktails like watermelon margarita. Great for pre-show meals, known for lobster tacos.
Toloache offers a sophisticated take on Mexican cuisine, making it a popular choice for those seeking a more refined dining experience. It's frequently recommended for pre- or post-theater dining, conveniently located near Times Square and various theaters. The menu boasts a variety of creative guacamole options and a selection of well-crafted cocktails, with the watermelon margarita being a standout favorite. Diners also rave about the delicious lobster tacos. While most reviews are glowing, a few patrons note that it can be on the pricier side, though the overall quality and ambiance justify the cost for many.
Toloache is praised for its Mexican cuisine, offering a more upscale dining experience than typical casual Mexican spots. The watermelon margarita and lobster tacos are highlighted as must-try items. The restaurant is noted for having multiple guacamole options and delicious cocktails. While generally well-received, one comment mentioned it might be pricey.
"The watermelon margarita and lobster tacos are particularly recommended by customers."
Customers generally have a positive view of Toloache, frequently recommending it for its Mexican cuisine, upscale yet not overly formal atmosphere, and well-crafted cocktails. Specific dishes like the watermelon margarita and lobster tacos receive high praise. Some mention it can be a bit pricey, but overall, the dining experience is considered very good.
Important Note
Some customers find the restaurant to be on the pricier side.
"The commenter expressed liking Toloache for its more upscale and less casual ambiance."
Positive"The commenter agreed with the positive sentiment for Toloache, stating they love the place and specifically highlighting the awesome lobster tacos."
Positive"Toloache was recommended as "really good," noting its multiple locations in Midtown and the East 80s."
Positive"Toloache was described as "decently nice," with the Upper East Side location being the commenter's favorite."
Positive"Toloache received a concurring recommendation."
Positive"Toloache on 50th Street received a second recommendation."
Positive"Toloache, located near Times Square, was highly recommended for its great food and delicious fancy cocktails."
Positive"Toloache is suggested for Mexican food."
Positive"Recommended Toloache for Mexican food."
Positive"Tolache is pretty good."
Positive"Toloache is delicious, especially the watermelon margarita."
Positive"Would have recommended Toloache, but it's pricey."
Neutral"Recommends Toloache."
Positive"Toloache - Mexican with very solid options and multiple guac types. It's slightly more upscale than a casual Mexican restaurant but it's not overly fancy. Would be great before or after the show(s)."
Positive
