TLDR
Iconic West Village bakery known for amazing layer cakes & famous banana pudding. A must-visit for dessert lovers!
Details
Step into a West Village haven for dessert lovers! This iconic bakery is a beloved spot for a slice of good cake, with a reputation for its American classics. While opinions on the cupcakes are divided, with some finding them overly frosted, the layer cakes are a definite crowd-pleaser. Don't miss out on their famous banana pudding – it's a must-try that consistently earns rave reviews.
The banana pudding is a universally loved item, and the layer cakes are also highly recommended for their quality.
Customers have mixed feelings about the cupcakes, with some finding them to have too much frosting and to be subpar, while others praise the layer cakes and consider the bakery a go-to for good cake. The banana pudding, however, receives consistent high praise and is a favorite.
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01cupcakes2 mentions
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Emergency Choc Cake In West Village
"Alrundz suggested Magnolia as one of several bakeshops in the West Village area for someone seeking chocolate cake."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Cake Slice Youve Had In Nyc Or
"In response to criticism of cupcakes, the author clarifies they are not a huge fan of Magnolia's cupcakes due to excessive frosting but loves their layer cakes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Cake Slice Youve Had In Nyc Or
"The author had a negative experience with Magnolia Bakery's cupcakes, finding them lacking, but loves their famous banana pudding."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Cake Slice Youve Had In Nyc Or
"The author states that Magnolia Bakery is still their go-to when they want a slice of good cake."
Positive