TLDR
Brooklyn's unhyped pizza gem w/ identical pie to a famous neighbor, minus the wait. Killer calzones too!
Reddit Sentiment for GIUSEPPINA'S BRICK OVEN(based on 14 Reddit opinions)
Details
For those craving authentic Italian-American pizza, this Brooklyn spot is a must-visit. Often drawing comparisons to the famed Lucali, it's noted for being owned by Lucali's brother and serving equally delicious pizza. Diners can expect a no-frills experience focused on the quality of the pie, with some also praising the calzones.
Caveats
One diner noted that the pizza crust was excessive.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GIUSEPPINA'S BRICK OVEN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: How Does Takeout Work At Lucali
"The user likes Giuseppina's but feels it doesn't quite match the unique appeal of Lucali."
NeutralFrom post: How Does Takeout Work At Lucali
"The user recommended Giuseppina's, located on 6th Avenue in Brooklyn, as an alternative to Lucali, noting it's owned by the same family and avoids Lucali's complicated ordering system."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user suggests Giuseppina's in Brooklyn as a worthy addition for a pizza tour, though not strictly New Haven style."
PositiveFrom post: Holiday Dining Notnot Reviews
"Giuseppina's is highly recommended for its excellent pizza, described as a great alternative to Lucali due to its accessibility and lack of wait times. The menu is simple, focusing solely on the quality of the pie."
PositiveFrom post: Many New York Pizzerias Using All Beef Pepperoni
"This user lists Giuseppina's as one of the many 'S tier' pizza places in NYC, arguing that the city's pizza game has never been better."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Pizzas Ive Tried In Manhattan
"Giuseppina's in Brooklyn is listed as a place that might appeal to those who like coal fire oven pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Takeout At Lucalis
"This user recommends Giuseppinas in the South Slope, stating it is owned by Lucali's brother and is very good."
PositiveFrom post: Besides Corner Store Whats The Hottest Vibe
"Giuseppina's in Sunset Park is mentioned as holding its own when it comes to pizza quality, alongside Luigi's and Astarita."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For
"The user simply recommends Giuseppina's."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For
"The user simply recommends Giuseppina's."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For
"The user confirms Giuseppina's is just as good as Lucali's, highlighting their killer calzones."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For
"The user suggests Giuseppina's as an alternative to Lucali, noting it is owned by Lucali's owner's brother and implies it's a good option."
PositiveFrom post: Lucali
"The commenter suggested going to Giuseppina's as an alternative, implying it's a preferable option to Lucali."
PositiveFrom post: Lucali
"The commenter noted that the Lucali pizza in the photo resembles pizza from Giuseppina's, criticizing both for having too much crust."
Negative