Seafood haven w/ a killer lobster roll & crab dip. Don't miss the Caesar salad & chicken sandwich. Great cocktails too!
This West Village spot is a go-to for seafood lovers, particularly celebrated for its excellent lobster roll and crab dip. Beyond the seafood, it also shines with a standout Caesar salad featuring bagel chips and a highly recommended chicken sandwich. While some might find it on the pricier side, the lively atmosphere, especially at the bar, and its great Bloody Mary and espresso martinis make it a destination worth visiting.
This establishment is primarily known for its excellent seafood, with strong recommendations for the lobster roll and crab dip. Other highly praised items include a Caesar salad served with bagel chips and a chicken sandwich. While the focus is on American and New England cuisine with an oyster bar, the quality of the food, especially the seafood, is a consistent highlight for patrons.
"Highly recommended are the lobster roll, crab dip, Caesar salad (notable for its bagel chips), and chicken sandwich. The regular espresso martini and Bloody Mary are also singled out as excellent drink choices."
Customers largely express positive sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its seafood, particularly the lobster roll and crab dip. The Caesar salad and chicken sandwich also receive notable praise. The Bloody Mary and espresso martinis are highlighted as exceptional drinks.
Important Note
One comment suggests that the restaurant may be 1.5-2 times more expensive than some other comparable establishments.
"This commenter recommended Jeffrey's Grocery, suggesting sitting at the front bar or side window for excellent people-watching."
Positive"This commenter mentioned Jeffrey's Grocery as a place to visit in the West Village."
Positive"The user highly recommends Jeffrey's Grocery for their regular espresso martini, considering it the best they've ever had, but advises against variations with extra ingredients."
Positive"This place is recommended for its people-watching opportunities and atmosphere, suggesting the front bar for the meal. It's noted that patrons might meet stylish gay men there."
Positive"Jeffrey's Grocery makes a fantastic Bloody Mary."
Positive"Jeffrey's Grocery is recommended for its Bloody Mary."
Positive"A user notes that Jeffrey's Grocery appears to be 1.5-2 times more expensive than Salt's Cure, though they have not personally tried it."
Neutral"A user suggests that Jeffrey's Grocery offers a better breakfast experience than Salt's Cure."
Positive"A user states Jeffrey's Grocery has a great Caesar salad, noting it comes with bagel chips."
Positive"The commenter suggests Jeffrey's Grocery as a good option for breakfast alongside Joseph Leonard."
Positive"The commenter expresses a preference for Jeffrey's Grocery as the best option for lunch among those discussed."
Positive"Names Jeffrey's Grocery as their favorite spot for chicken sandwiches."
Positive"Likes the crab dip from Jeffrey's Grocery and is seeking other recommendations for crab dips."
Positive"User nicwolff includes Jeffrey's Grocery in their list of go-to restaurants."
Positive"Recommends Jeffrey's Grocery as having the best lobster roll they've had, suggests taking it to Washington Sq Park, and notes it is a sit-down restaurant."
Positive"Lists Jeffrey's Grocery as a suggestion for lobster dishes."
Positive
