West Village gem with amazing, moist cupcakes like Creme Brulee & salted caramel; a top spot for sweet treats.
This West Village bakery is a top-tier destination for cupcakes, earning rave reviews for their exceptional taste and variety. Customers frequently highlight unique flavors such as Creme Brulee, salted butterscotch caramel, and birthday cake, often comparing them favorably to other popular bakeries. While the cupcakes are generally loved for their moist texture, a common tip is to manage the sweetness by adjusting the frosting. Beyond cupcakes, their Rice Krispie treats are also a hit.
This bakery is highly recommended for its cupcakes, with many customers citing them as amazing and a favorite. Specific flavors like Creme Brulee, salted butterscotch caramel, and birthday cake are frequently mentioned as standouts. While generally praised for moistness, one reviewer noted the frosting can be quite sweet. They also offer Rice Krispie treats.
"Customers highly recommend the Creme Brulee cupcake, salted butterscotch caramel cupcake, and the birthday cupcake. The Rice Krispie treat and flourless chocolate cake are also praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the cupcakes, often calling them amazing and a favorite. Some note that the frosting can be very sweet and suggest removing some if preferred.
Important Note
The frosting on the cupcakes can be very sweet, and some customers recommend removing some of it to better enjoy the cake.
"Molly's is suggested as a cupcake replacement if Two Little Red Hens is unavailable."
Positive"The flourless chocolate cake at Molly's is the commenter's favorite."
Positive"The commenter forgot about Molly's Cupcakes but acknowledges they are good."
Positive"Molly's Cupcakes are a favorite, especially the creme brûlée ones."
Positive"This commenter enjoys the Rice Krispie treat available at Molly's Cupcakes."
Positive"The user mentioned that Mollys cupcakes are moist but suggested removing half the frosting if it's too sweet."
Neutral"The user suggested checking out Molly's Cupcakes if the original poster was in the area."
Neutral"Molly's Cupcakes is suggested as a good option for cupcakes, noted as originating from Chicago but considered a New Yorker spot due to its long presence in the West Village."
Positive"The commenter recalls Molly's pistachio rose water cupcake fondly and expresses a desire to try the birthday cupcake next."
Positive"The commenter agrees that Molly's offers much better cupcakes, with the birthday flavor being a particular favorite."
Positive"The commenter recommends Molly's for its amazing filled cupcakes, suggesting it as a superior alternative to Magnolia."
Positive"The commenter recommends Molly's Cupcakes for good cupcakes, noting its close proximity to Mamoun's."
Positive"A user seconds the recommendation to visit Molly's if one is looking for cupcakes."
Positive"A user highly praises the cupcakes from Molly's, describing them as amazing."
Positive"OP and his wife enjoyed cupcakes from Molly's Cupcakes, calling them 'really great'. OP's favorite was the salted butterscotch caramel cupcake."
Positive"Alrundz listed Mollys Cupcakes as an option, mentioning they offer cupcakes and might need advanced notice for orders."
Neutral"Recommends 'Molly's Tea' (likely Molly's Cupcakes which serves some drinks) as a bubble tea adjacent spot emphasizing higher quality tea."
Positive"Recommends Molly's Cupcakes in the West Village for the Creme Brulee cupcake."
Positive"User prefers cupcakes from Molly's Bakery, finding them better than those from Little Cupcake Bakeshop's Bay Ridge location."
Positive
