Famed West Village cupcake haven, known for inventive flavors & moist cakes. A must-try for dessert lovers!
This charming West Village bakery is a delightful stop for those seeking expertly crafted cupcakes and other sweet treats. From classic flavors to unique creations like the Creme Brulee cupcake, there's a dessert to satisfy every craving. It's a beloved spot that even inspires bakery crawls and comparisons to other popular shops, with many highlighting its moist cakes and creative fillings.
This bakery is celebrated for its wide array of cupcakes, with many customers highlighting specific flavors like the Creme Brulee, Salted Butterscotch Caramel, and Birthday cupcake. While generally highly praised for moistness and creative fillings, one reviewer found some flavors (Crème brûlée, s'mores, cake batter) to be unremarkable or overly synthetic-tasting.
"Customers highly recommend the cupcakes, with specific favorites including the Creme Brulee, Salted Butterscotch Caramel, Birthday, and Pistachio Rose Water flavors. The flourless chocolate cake and Rice Krispie treats are also mentioned positively."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the cupcakes, frequently recommending them and comparing them favorably to other bakeries. Some find the frosting a bit sweet, but the cake itself is consistently described as moist and delicious.
Important Note
One reviewer found some cupcake flavors to be unremarkable or have a synthetic taste, and another noted that the frosting can be very sweet.
"Molly's Cupcakes were rated as pretty unremarkable: crème brûlée (6/10), s'mores (4/10), and cake batter (4/10), with the cake batter flavor being particularly synthetic-tasting."
Negative"This user is interested in whether filled cupcakes can be ordered as cakes from Molly's Cupcakes."
Neutral"This user notes that any cupcake from Molly's Cupcakes can be ordered as a cake."
Positive"Molly's Cupcakes have become a new favorite for this user."
Positive"Molly's is suggested as a cupcake replacement if Two Little Red Hens is unavailable."
Positive"The flourless chocolate cake at Molly's is the commenter's favorite."
Positive"The commenter forgot about Molly's Cupcakes but acknowledges they are good."
Positive"Molly's Cupcakes are a favorite, especially the creme brûlée ones."
Positive"This commenter enjoys the Rice Krispie treat available at Molly's Cupcakes."
Positive"The user mentioned that Mollys cupcakes are moist but suggested removing half the frosting if it's too sweet."
Neutral"The user suggested checking out Molly's Cupcakes if the original poster was in the area."
Neutral"Molly's Cupcakes is suggested as a good option for cupcakes, noted as originating from Chicago but considered a New Yorker spot due to its long presence in the West Village."
Positive"The commenter recalls Molly's pistachio rose water cupcake fondly and expresses a desire to try the birthday cupcake next."
Positive"The commenter agrees that Molly's offers much better cupcakes, with the birthday flavor being a particular favorite."
Positive"The commenter recommends Molly's for its amazing filled cupcakes, suggesting it as a superior alternative to Magnolia."
Positive"The commenter recommends Molly's Cupcakes for good cupcakes, noting its close proximity to Mamoun's."
Positive"A user seconds the recommendation to visit Molly's if one is looking for cupcakes."
Positive"A user highly praises the cupcakes from Molly's, describing them as amazing."
Positive
