Bustling American eatery, known for its lively (and loud!) atmosphere. Craveable salmon tartare & crispy rice, but beware of smaller portions and potential noise levels.
This American restaurant offers a bustling atmosphere, though it can get quite loud, making conversation difficult. While some find the food decent and the salmon tartare a must-try, others have noted shrinkflation on dishes like steak. It's a popular spot for walk-ins and groups, conveniently located near Lincoln Center.
This American restaurant's food receives a range of feedback. The salmon tartare is specifically recommended, and crispy rice is also highlighted positively. However, some patrons have noted a decrease in portion sizes, particularly for steak, leading to concerns about value. The overall food quality is sometimes described as decent but not exceptional.
"The salmon tartare is a standout dish recommended by patrons. Crispy rice is also mentioned positively."
Customer feedback is mixed, with some enjoying the lively ambiance and specific dishes like salmon tartare, while others criticize the extreme noise levels, perceived shrinkflation, and mediocre overall food quality.
Important Note
The restaurant is frequently cited as being extremely loud, which can make conversation difficult. There are also mentions of shrinkflation, particularly regarding steak portions. Additionally, one comment links the ownership to the Sackler family.
"Notes that The Smith is owned by the Sackler family."
Neutral"States that The Smith is very loud with poor acoustics and mediocre food, recommending other nearby options instead."
Negative"States that The Smith has some of the worst acoustics in NYC, preventing conversation."
Negative"Echoes the sentiment that The Smith is excessively loud, to the point of being unable to converse, and hasn't been back since its acoustics issue."
Negative"Acknowledges the warning about The Smith's noise level."
Neutral"Confirms that The Smith is very loud, making conversation impossible."
Negative"Strongly advises against The Smith due to its extremely loud atmosphere, making conversation difficult."
Negative"The Smith is located across the street and is considered good and somewhat quick, though the speed of service is uncertain."
Positive"The Smith is suggested as a go-to spot for walk-in groups, with consistently decent food and a good atmosphere."
Positive"The Smith is implied to be louder than The Consulate and The Ribbon."
Neutral"The Smith has best crispy rice"
Positive"don’t sleep on the smith’s salmon tartare."
Neutral"The Smith is NYC Denny’s"
Negative"I like The Smith"
Positive"The Smith is right nearby"
Neutral"The Smith is decent despite shrinkflation but there are better options."
Neutral"The Smith is a terrible restaurant, owners responsible for opioid epidemic."
Negative"Negative reaction to The Smith."
Negative"The Smith served a smaller portion of steak."
Negative"The Smith is owned by the Sackler family."
Negative
