Next.js logo

THE SMITH

Updated

Phone: (212) 496-5700

Address: 1900 BROADWAY 10023

TLDR

Known for brunch & lively vibe near Lincoln Center; some rave about salmon tartare & crispy rice, others find it akin to a chain diner.

Reddit Sentiment for THE SMITH(based on 13 Reddit opinions)

38% Positive23% Neutral38% Negative

Tags

american 3View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

This American restaurant is a popular spot, especially for its brunch and convenient location near Lincoln Center. While some praise its salmon tartare and crispy rice, others note that portions can be small and the overall experience can be comparable to a chain diner.

Food Overview

The food at this American restaurant receives mixed reviews. While the salmon tartare and crispy rice are highlighted positively, there are also comments about shrinkflation affecting steak portions and a general sentiment that it can be akin to a 'NYC Denny's'.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers have specifically recommended the salmon tartare and crispy rice."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is mixed, with some enjoying specific dishes like salmon tartare and crispy rice, while others criticize portion sizes and compare it unfavorably to chain restaurants.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE SMITH

A user recommends The Smith's salmon tartare, and another user agrees, stating they have the best crispy rice.
A discussion about shrinkflation where a user notes that The Smith served a smaller portion of steak. Another user states the restaurant is owned by the Sackler family.
The Smith is mentioned as a potential lunch spot near Lincoln Center, noted for decent food and atmosphere.
The Smith is suggested as a suitable walk-in spot for larger groups, with the commenter stating it has consistently decent food and a good atmosphere.
Multiple users strongly advise against The Smith due to its extremely loud atmosphere and poor acoustics, making conversation difficult. One user also mentions the owners are responsible for the opioid epidemic.
The Smith is recommended as a good and relatively quick option near Lincoln Center, though the speed of service is uncertain.
The Smith Lincoln Square is mentioned as a place that serves breakfast.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Solo Dining Near Central Park Southevents In Nyc

"The Smith is suggested as a place with a good bar."

Positive
Mar 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center

"The Smith Lincoln Square is mentioned with a link to their website, indicating it serves breakfast."

Positive
Feb 25, 2026View Comment →

From post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center

"The Smith is mentioned as a place that serves breakfast."

Positive
Feb 25, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"Notes that The Smith is owned by the Sackler family."

Neutral
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"States that The Smith is very loud with poor acoustics and mediocre food, recommending other nearby options instead."

Negative
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"States that The Smith has some of the worst acoustics in NYC, preventing conversation."

Negative
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"Echoes the sentiment that The Smith is excessively loud, to the point of being unable to converse, and hasn't been back since its acoustics issue."

Negative
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"Acknowledges the warning about The Smith's noise level."

Neutral
Feb 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"Confirms that The Smith is very loud, making conversation impossible."

Negative
Feb 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Searching For A Good Spot To Take A 90something

"Strongly advises against The Smith due to its extremely loud atmosphere, making conversation difficult."

Negative
Feb 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Quick Meal Near Lincoln Center

"The Smith is located across the street and is considered good and somewhat quick, though the speed of service is uncertain."

Positive
Dec 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Looking For Good Lunchdinner Spots For A Party Of

"The Smith is suggested as a go-to spot for walk-in groups, with consistently decent food and a good atmosphere."

Positive
Jul 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Uws Weekday Lunch

"The Smith is implied to be louder than The Consulate and The Ribbon."

Neutral
Apr 8, 2025View Comment →