Next.js logo

THE MILLING ROOM

Updated

Phone: (212) 595-2624

Address: 446 COLUMBUS AVENUE 10024

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A spacious, sky-lit dining room with a lively bar. Known for its comfortable seating and great bread. Recently closed.

Reddit Sentiment for THE MILLING ROOM(based on 9 Reddit opinions)

33% Positive44% Neutral11% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

american 2View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
Eater’s Guide to All the New York City Restaurants, Bars, and Cafes That Closed in February 2026

Eater • Date unknown
Read More →
Eater

Details

The Milling Room was a long-standing American restaurant on Columbus Avenue, known for its sky-lit dining room and lively bar. It offered a comfortable and spacious environment with ample seating. While it was a popular choice for various occasions, including family gatherings and special events, recent information suggests the restaurant has closed.

Food Overview

The Milling Room was an American restaurant that received a specific mention for its 'crazy good' bread. While not much else is detailed about the food, one comment mentioned bibimbap and a Cherry Lime Rickey from a different establishment that shared a similar name.

Highlights / Recommended

"The bread at The Milling Room was specifically highlighted as being exceptionally good."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is mixed, with some highlighting the 'crazy good' bread and the restaurant's beautiful and spacious ambiance. However, recent comments indicate the restaurant may be closed.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE MILLING ROOM

Who has your favorite bread and olive oil? Here's mine
This user specifically called out the bread at The Milling Room as 'crazy good,' despite an otherwise average rating for the restaurant.
Spacious restaurants with large tables?
The Milling Room is described as a beautiful and large space, offering comfortable seating with ample distance between tables, making it a good option for those seeking space.
Where to take parents 2nd time in NYC?
The Milling Room was mentioned as a frequent choice for meals with parents, suggesting it was a reliable option for family dining.
Poor quality yet expensive restaurant?
This commenter suggested The Milling Room, but noted it seemed to be closed at the time of their comment.
A cult-beloved Vietnamese bakery and more NYC openings
This post mentions that The Milling Room's location will be taken over by a new restaurant called Ashi, indicating the former's closure.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For A Sesame Crusted Tuna Steak In Nyc

"The user thinks they may have had a dish similar to the one requested at The Milling Room on the Upper West Side."

Neutral
Mar 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: A Cultbeloved Vietnamese Bakery And More Nyc

"The user expresses excitement for the upcoming opening of Ashi in the location formerly occupied by The Milling Room and Calle Ocho."

Positive
Feb 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant

"This commenter suggested The Milling Room, noting it seems to be closed but would have been a recommendation if open."

Neutral
Nov 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Uws Engagement Gift Advice Needed

"This was a suggestion for an engagement gift for a couple in their early thirties living on the UWS. The suggestion included this restaurant."

Neutral
Sep 3, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Place Still Make A Cherry Lime Rickey

"The Mill, a Korean restaurant in Morningside that was formerly a diner, used to offer a Cherry Lime Rickey, which was enjoyed with bibimbap. The restaurant closed in 2021."

Negative
Jul 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Who Has Your Favorite Bread And Olive Oil Heres

"This user found the bread at Milling Room to be 'crazy good', despite rating the overall restaurant as average."

Positive
Jun 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Spacious Restaurants With Large Tables

"The Milling Room is described as a beautiful and large space, offering comfortable seating with ample distance between tables."

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Uws Brunch With Parents

"Mentions Milling Room as a usual choice but is unsure of its suitability for the user's needs."

Neutral
May 3, 2025View Comment →