Next.js logo

THE MILLING ROOM

Last Updated: ~1 month ago

Phone: (212) 595-2624

Address: 446 COLUMBUS AVENUE 10024

TLDR

Charming New American spot w/ spacious, comfy seating. Noted for its 'crazy good' bread, it's a solid choice for a relaxed meal.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 6 Reddit comments)

50% Positive33% Neutral17% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

This New American restaurant offers a dining experience that balances classic dishes with a charming ambiance. Known for its beautiful and spacious setting with comfortable seating, it's a great spot for various occasions. While some dishes receive mixed reviews, the bread has been noted as exceptionally good.

Food Overview

The Milling Room serves New American cuisine. While specific dishes may vary in customer reception, the bread has been highlighted as a standout item.

Highlights / Recommended

"The bread at The Milling Room has been specifically praised by customers as being exceptionally good."

Customer Sentiment

Customers appreciate the restaurant's beautiful and spacious environment with comfortable seating. While the overall dining experience is generally positive, specific dish feedback can be mixed.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This post mentions The Milling Room as a frequent choice for parents meeting for a meal.
A commenter specifically praised the bread at The Milling Room, describing it as 'crazy good,' even while rating the restaurant as average overall.
The Milling Room is described as a beautiful and large space with comfortable seating and ample distance between tables.
The Milling Room is mentioned as a usual choice, though the commenter is unsure if it fits the user's specific needs for a brunch with parents.
This restaurant was suggested as part of an engagement gift idea for a couple living on the Upper West Side.

Recent Mentions

From post: Uws Engagement Gift Advice Needed

"This was a suggestion for an engagement gift for a couple in their early thirties living on the UWS. The suggestion included this restaurant."

Neutral
Sep 3, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Place Still Make A Cherry Lime Rickey

"The Mill, a Korean restaurant in Morningside that was formerly a diner, used to offer a Cherry Lime Rickey, which was enjoyed with bibimbap. The restaurant closed in 2021."

Negative
Jul 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Who Has Your Favorite Bread And Olive Oil Heres

"This user found the bread at Milling Room to be 'crazy good', despite rating the overall restaurant as average."

Positive
Jun 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Spacious Restaurants With Large Tables

"The Milling Room is described as a beautiful and large space, offering comfortable seating with ample distance between tables."

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Uws Brunch With Parents

"Mentions Milling Room as a usual choice but is unsure of its suitability for the user's needs."

Neutral
May 3, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where To Take Parents 2nd Time In Nyc

"My parents come in frequently to meet for a meal and these are some of the hits... The Milling Room"

Positive
Mar 22, 2025View Comment →