TLDR
Authentic Piedmontese cuisine in SoHo. Known for exceptional fresh pasta, decadent white truffle dishes, and high-quality Milanese-style risotto.
Reddit Sentiment for SAN CARLO OSTERIA PIEMONTE(based on 27 Reddit opinions)
Details
This SoHo destination specializes in authentic Piedmontese cuisine, earning consistent acclaim for its high-quality pasta and regional specialties [1], [5], [17]. Diners frequently highlight the exceptional truffle dishes, including a standout tajarin with white truffle, as well as Milanese-style risotto [1], [9], [21]. The experience is further elevated by friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a reliable choice for traditional Italian dining [8], [23].
Food Overview
The kitchen focuses on Northern Italian and Piedmontese traditions, featuring highly-regarded dishes like Vitello tonnato, agnolotti, and tagliatelle [5], [22]. Truffle-centric items are a major draw, alongside excellent crudo and Milanese-style risotto preparations [9], [21], [23]. While most items are consistently praised, some diners note that certain specialty dishes may be seasonal or subject to daily menu availability [5], [23].
Caveats
Some specialty items, such as Bagna Càuda or specific truffle dishes, may be seasonal or not available on the daily menu [3], [5], [23].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAN CARLO OSTERIA PIEMONTE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Need A Good Italian Pasta Restaurant For This
"Mentioned as having easy reservations."
PositiveFrom post: Loooking For A Great Risotto Preferably Without
"The restaurant is noted for serving a delicious truffle risotto."
PositiveFrom post: Loooking For A Great Risotto Preferably Without
"A complex vegetarian risotto is recommended, featuring specific ingredients like Castelmagno cheese and roasted pepper glaze."
PositiveFrom post: I Realized Ive Never Tried Risotto What Are Good
"Praises the crudo and the friendly staff, though notes menu availability may vary."
PositiveFrom post: I Realized Ive Never Tried Risotto What Are Good
"The user suggests starting with the Vitello tonnato and highlights the quality of their agnolotti and tagliatelle."
PositiveFrom post: I Realized Ive Never Tried Risotto What Are Good
"Known for Milanese-style dishes, specifically their risotto."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Thing Youve Eaten In The Past Week
"The grilled Tuscan branzino with saffron sauce from Osteria San Carlo was highlighted."
PositiveFrom post: Every Country Whether Theyve A Restaurant In Nyc
"In response to the previous comment, this user stated that San Marino seems to be closed."
NegativeFrom post: Every Country Whether Theyve A Restaurant In Nyc
"The user reported that they could not find San Marino Soho on Google Maps."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"San Carlo Osteria is recommended for Piedmontese cuisine."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Small Localneighborhood Italian
"San Carlo in SoHo is recommended for its good food and decent outdoor seating. The cuisine is described as food from the Piedmont region."
PositiveFrom post: Need Help Remembering Restaurant With Truffle Menu
"This user suggested San Carlo Osteria Piemonte, linking to their website and truffle menu. This restaurant is located in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user recommended San Carlo Osteria in SoHo for its authentic Italian food, specifically mentioning rigatoni with lobster and spaghetti pomodoro, and also noted its Sunday jazz brunch."
PositiveFrom post: Milanesenorthern Italian Food In Nyc Other Than
"A link to the dinner menu for San Carlo NYC is provided."
NeutralFrom post: Milanesenorthern Italian Food In Nyc Other Than
"San Carlo Osteria Piemonte is suggested as a place to consider."
NeutralFrom post: Italian Dinner Recommendations
"This commenter listed San Carlo Osteria Piemonte as a recommended Italian restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Anywhere With White Truffle Pasta
"This user suggested San Carlo Osteria Piemonte in response to a query about white truffle pasta."
PositiveFrom post: Fluke Crudo
"The user mentioned San Carlo Osteria as a place they have already eaten fluke crudo."
NeutralFrom post: Regional Cuisine That Isnt The Stereotypical
"The commenter agrees that San Carlo is a solid spot and expresses love for the Vitello tonnato dish."
PositiveFrom post: Regional Cuisine That Isnt The Stereotypical
"San Carlo is praised as a great restaurant with terrific food, reasonably priced lunch specials, and good service."
Positive