Last Updated: ~2 months ago
Phone: (212) 338-0818
Address: 23 EAST 40 STREET 10016
Consistently top-rated steakhouse w/ impeccable service & standout porterhouse. A go-to for classic American fare & special occasions.
This esteemed steakhouse offers a classic American dining experience, with a strong emphasis on high-quality steaks that have garnered significant praise. Patrons frequently laud the excellent service and the sophisticated ambiance, making it a reliable choice for both special occasions and business dinners. The restaurant is also noted for its accommodating nature towards dietary needs and group bookings.
Primarily a steakhouse, this establishment is celebrated for its high-quality steaks, with the porterhouse being a notable favorite. Sides like Brussels sprouts and appetizers such as burrata have also received positive mentions. The restaurant is accommodating to gluten-free diets, showing care with cross-contamination.
"The porterhouse steak is a standout favorite, and the Brussels sprouts and burrata have also been specifically recommended."
Overall, customers express strong satisfaction with both the food, particularly the steaks, and the attentive service, frequently recommending it for various occasions.
"Recommends Benjamin Prime, stating it is fantastic."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is recommended as a steakhouse option in Midtown."
Positive"The commenter had a fantastic ribeye from Benjamin Prime Steakhouse last night."
Positive"The commenter suggests Benjamin Prime Steakhouse for its steak quality, which they rank alongside top steakhouses, also noting good sides and service. They observe it's often busy with satisfied customers."
Positive"Benjamin Prime is listed among the user's favorite steakhouses."
Positive"This restaurant is a recommended option."
Neutral"This is a recommended steakhouse near Grand Central."
Neutral"This is a recommended restaurant."
Neutral"Benjamin Prime is listed as a favorite steakhouse, noted for being easy to get a table and consistently good."
Positive"The commenter has upcoming reservations at Benjamin Steakhouse, a place they have had excellent Restaurant Week menus from before."
Positive"A user highly recommends Benjamin Prime for work events, praising its food quality."
Positive"A user recommends Benjamin Prime."
Neutral"This user highly praises Benjamin Prime, calling it "soo good" and expressing a clear preference for it over Sea Fire Grill, even though they have hosted events at both."
Positive"This user strongly recommends Benjamin Prime for corporate events, praising it for consistently providing a "10/10 experience" and its willingness to work within budget constraints."
Positive"Benjamin Prime was declared a user's favorite in the city for its porterhouse steak, stating they have yet to find a comparable one."
Positive"Benjamin Prime is highlighted as a viable option for large groups, as they are willing to accept such parties without mandating a prefix menu. This allows the group to order directly from their regular dinner menu."
Positive"The commenter generally likes the collabs involving Benjamin Prime and Hen House, despite finding the bone in the specific collab sandwich comical, and believes a good steak sandwich from this collaboration would taste fine later as leftovers."
Positive"The Original Poster usually loves Benjamin Prime and expresses curiosity about their "massive sandwich" collab with Hen House, while noting its large size but expecting it to be delicious."
Positive"Benjamin Prime is mentioned for offering a $45 lunch menu, relevant to the search for steak lunch specials."
Neutral"The commenter reported that Benjamin Prime accommodates gluten-free requirements, citing an instance where the steakhouse used separate broilers for their friend with celiac disease. This suggests the restaurant is careful with cross-contamination for gluten-free diners seeking steakhouse options."
Positive
