Classic NYC steakhouse w/ dry-aged steaks, inspired by Peter Luger. Known for porterhouse & refined ambiance, esp. the Park Ave location.
Wolfgang's Steakhouse, established by a former Peter Luger's headwaiter, offers a high-end, dry-aged steak experience in a refined setting. The Park Avenue location is particularly praised for its ambiance and quality, with many considering it the best among its branches. Patrons often recommend the porterhouse for two, though some suggest exploring other cuts like ribeye or sirloin. While generally lauded for its steak, some reviews mention a less than stellar experience with their seafood, and one noted a potentially shady billing practice with gratuity calculation.
The core offering at Wolfgang's Steakhouse is its dry-aged steaks, with the porterhouse being a frequent recommendation. Other popular choices include ribeye and sirloin. While the steaks receive high marks, some customers have found the seafood to be average. One specific point of contention was a perceived deceptive billing practice involving gratuity.
"The porterhouse for two is frequently recommended, as are the ribeye and sirloin steaks. Some users also highlight the bacon and onion rings. For those seeking a specific experience, the bone-in ribeye with sautéed mushrooms is suggested."
Customers generally praise Wolfgang's for its excellent dry-aged steaks and refined atmosphere, with the Park Avenue location frequently cited as a favorite. However, some have noted issues with seafood quality and a peculiar billing practice regarding gratuity.
Important Note
One reviewer noted a potentially deceptive billing practice regarding gratuity. There is also some debate about the specific historical claim regarding the 33rd Street location being a former subway station.
"Wolfgang's is recommended for a filet mignon with Au Poivre sauce as a good entry into steak."
Positive"Wolfgang's is recommended for its filet mignon with Au Poivre sauce as a good entry into steak."
Positive"Wolfgang's is suggested as an excellent alternative to Delmonico's and Gallagher's."
Positive"Only the original Wolfgang's location is considered good; other branches are described as 'meh'."
Neutral"Wolfgang's is considered the #1 steakhouse in NYC by this commenter."
Positive"A simple recommendation for Wolfgang's."
Positive"A warning that Wolfgang's and Strip House have gone downhill and faced numerous health department closures."
Negative"The commenter's favorite steakhouse is Wolfgang's, though they haven't been in years and were disappointed by Old Homestead and Delmonico's previously. A warning about past health department closures for Wolfgang's and Strip House was also noted."
Positive"Wolfgang's is mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"This user mentioned liking Wolfgang's onion rings."
Positive"Wolfgang's is suggested as a good steakhouse option for expense account meals."
Positive"The user noted the existence of another Wolfgang's Steakhouse location on Broadway around 37th Street."
Neutral"The user simply recommended Wolfgang's Steakhouse."
Positive"The user mentioned that Wolfgang's Steakhouse on Park Avenue and E 33rd Street is walkable from the user's hotel and suitable for a nice evening out."
Positive"The user recommended Wolfgang's Steakhouse, stating it's suitable for families with children and is available at both the Park Avenue and Times Square locations."
Positive"The user recommended Wolfgang's Steakhouse as a good option for a celebration dinner, noting it's not overly fancy and is conveniently located near the user's accommodation."
Positive"The user suggests Wolfgang's makes a phenomenal tuna steak, although it's not sesame-crusted."
Positive"Responding to a comment about a bad steak experience at Wolfgang's, this user advised that if a steak is not cooked to satisfaction, it should be sent back, recalling a time they successfully did so at Wolfgang's."
Neutral"In a discussion about expensive steaks, Wolfgang's was mentioned as a place that served decent ribeye steaks for $75, although the commenter did not consider it exceptional."
Neutral"This user recommended Wolfgang's on 41st street for a modern, bright dining room ambiance."
Positive
