THE GRILL / THE POOL
Updated
Phone: (212) 375-9001
Address: 99 EAST 52 STREET 10022
$$$Mains mostly $45–$98
TLDR
Iconic, 'Mad Men'-style midtown power-dining with spectacular tableside service and an elite atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for THE GRILL / THE POOL(based on 90 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The author identifies The Grill as an underrated NYC establishment for martinis. They specifically enjoyed a gin martini served with olives, noting the restaurant's impressive freezer for chilling glasses. The post suggests the restaurant maintains an 'if you know, you know' status, which the author prefers.
The post features a dessert, the Peach Melba Flambé, served at The Grill. The preparation of this dessert is shown, with a chef flambéing it tableside. The author seems to have enjoyed the experience, indicated by the celebratory tone and the inclusion of the dessert in the post.
The post strongly recommends ordering the baked Alaska at The Grill, emphasizing its tableside flambé presentation as a highlight of the dining experience. The dessert is described as the best and is associated with Major Food Group, Mario Carbone, and Rich Torrisi, suggesting a high standard of quality and execution.
The Grill is featured for a Saturday night drink experience. The image shows a cocktail bar setting with a bartender mixing drinks and two classic cocktails on the bar.
The post features 'The pasta à la press' from The Grill, indicating a special preparation method for their pasta dish.
This post captures the highly anticipated moment of a diner finally trying The Grill's acclaimed Black Label Burger, often cited as NYC's top-rated burger, after waiting three years for a reservation. The video details his excitement and profound enjoyment, as he describes the burger as tasting like "heaven" and asserts it's the best he's ever experienced, making the lengthy wait entirely worthwhile. The focus is exclusively on the quality and the memorable experience of this specific dish at a high-end establishment.
Details
Renowned for its 'Mad Men'-esque ambiance, this upscale Midtown East destination offers a sophisticated stage-like setting ideal for special occasions and corporate dinners [1], [2]. While it serves classic American fare and prime aged steaks, it is particularly celebrated for its tableside services, including prime rib carving and indulgent pasta preparations [2], [3], [4]. The dining experience is consistently described as an elegant, iconic New York experience that justifies its high-end price point [5], [6].
Food Overview
The restaurant serves a high-end American menu featuring prime aged steaks, poultry, and classic seafood [2]. Customer favorites include the tableside prime rib [4], [10], the indulgent pasta à la presse [2], [3], and the celebrated Black Label Burger [11]. The dessert menu, specifically the tableside flambéed baked Alaska and Peach Melba, is frequently cited as a must-order highlight [12], [13].
Patrons overwhelmingly praise the sophisticated atmosphere, professional service, and overall celebratory vibes, with many noting it is a top-tier choice for special events [1], [7]. While the food and ambiance are highly regarded, some diners note the restaurant comes at a significant cost and can be difficult to book [8], [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE GRILL / THE POOL
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me
"Listed as a favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Best High End Nyc Restaurant To Go To Treat
"Briefly recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Best High End Nyc Restaurant To Go To Treat
"Recommended as a nice steakhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Cosme In 2026 Farewell Dinner Date Night And
"Mentioned as a high-end option if price is not a concern."
NeutralFrom post: 85th Birthday Splurge Dinner For Grumpy Foodie Dad
"Mentioned as a potential dining option."
Neutral