TLDR
Iconic, Mad Men-esque upscale American chophouse in a landmark room. Famous for tableside service, prime rib, and a sophisticated, celebratory vibe.
Reddit Sentiment for THE GRILL / THE POOL(based on 168 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This post captures the highly anticipated moment of a diner finally trying The Grill's acclaimed Black Label Burger, often cited as NYC's top-rated burger, after waiting three years for a reservation. The video details his excitement and profound enjoyment, as he describes the burger as tasting like "heaven" and asserts it's the best he's ever experienced, making the lengthy wait entirely worthwhile. The focus is exclusively on the quality and the memorable experience of this specific dish at a high-end establishment.
Details
Located in a landmark dining room designed by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe and Philip Johnson, this elegant Midtown East chophouse offers a refined, upscale experience reminiscent of a 'Mad Men' fantasy [3], [4]. Renowned for its impeccable service and glamorous ambiance, it is a premier destination for special occasions and high-end client dinners [1], [2], [6]. Beyond its iconic setting, the establishment is lauded for premium American classics and sophisticated tableside presentations [3], [5].
Food Overview
This establishment offers a refined take on American steakhouse fare, with many diners favoring the prime rib over the traditional steak [2], [4]. Must-try dishes include the succulent steak tartare, duck breast pasta, and the tableside-carved prime rib [5], [6]. While highly regarded, some diners recommend exploring the wider menu beyond just the steak, noting that items like the chilled pea soup or crab cakes are excellent alternatives [2], [3], [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended dishes include the prime rib carved tableside, the duck breast pasta, and the steak tartare [5], [6]. For a lighter start, the chilled pea soup and avocado crab louis salad are excellent choices [2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •steak tartare(6)
- •steaks (off-menu)(5)
- •duck breast pasta(5)
- •omelette(5)
- •prime rib(3)
- •honey mustard duckling(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons overwhelmingly praise the restaurant's stunning interior, professional service, and overall experience, frequently citing it as a top-tier choice for birthdays and anniversaries [1], [4], [6]. While most feedback is glowing, some diners note the high price point and occasional difficulty in securing reservations [5], [6].
Caveats
The restaurant is very expensive and can be difficult to book on short notice due to high demand [5], [6]. Some diners feel that, while the experience is high-end, it lacks the 'true' traditional steakhouse feel compared to other local institutions [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE GRILL / THE POOL
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The restaurant is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Best Dinner For Two Including Cocktailswine For
"The restaurant is recommended as part of a list of high-quality dining spots."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Notes The Grill offers trolley service prime rib for $110."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Brief mention of The Grill."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"User notes they offer tableside prime rib carving."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Mentions The Grill as a major splurge option."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Mentioned as a recommended spot."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Listed as a recommended spot."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Recommended as a fancier dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Recommended for higher budget dining."
NeutralFrom post: Has Anyone Had Jacks Pie At The Grill Nyc Looking
"The commenter explains the composition of Jack's Pie at The Grill, noting it consists of asparagus and sunchoke pieces in a creamy sauce, possibly a Béchamel."
NeutralFrom post: Fancy Lunch Spots In Midtown For Summer Associate
"Briefly mentioned."
NeutralFrom post: Birthday Restaurant Steak Suggestions In Midtown
"Recommended as the best choice for a steakhouse experience in Midtown East."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Restaurant Steak Suggestions In Midtown
"Suggested as a great option if the diner is willing to travel a short distance."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"This commenter recommended The Grill, specifically mentioning their 'devils bone' prime rib."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"The Grill was listed as a place that serves prime rib."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"The Grill was listed as a restaurant that serves prime rib."
NeutralFrom post: Top Trendyhigh Vibe Restaurant Around
"The Grill was mentioned positively in conjunction with 'chimera'."
PositiveFrom post: Top Trendyhigh Vibe Restaurant Around
"The commenter noted that The Grill did not have openings for the following week, making it unavailable for their client dinner."
NegativeFrom post: Top Trendyhigh Vibe Restaurant Around
"The Grill was recommended as a solid option for a client dinner."
Positive