TLDR
A 'Mad Men' fantasy in a gorgeous room with high-end, classic American fare. Perfect for special occasions and swanky celebrations.
Reddit Sentiment for THE GRILL / THE POOL(based on 164 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Grill is featured for a Saturday night drink experience. The image shows a cocktail bar setting with a bartender mixing drinks and two classic cocktails on the bar.
The post features 'The pasta à la press' from The Grill, indicating a special preparation method for their pasta dish.
This post captures the highly anticipated moment of a diner finally trying The Grill's acclaimed Black Label Burger, often cited as NYC's top-rated burger, after waiting three years for a reservation. The video details his excitement and profound enjoyment, as he describes the burger as tasting like "heaven" and asserts it's the best he's ever experienced, making the lengthy wait entirely worthwhile. The focus is exclusively on the quality and the memorable experience of this specific dish at a high-end establishment.
Details
Offering an otherworldly 'Mad Men'-esque experience, this restaurant is widely considered a premier Midtown East destination for special occasions [1], [2]. Known for its gorgeous, iconic room and sublime service, it delivers a high-end atmosphere that many describe as a classic New York experience [1], [3], [4]. While the price point is high, the culinary experience is frequently backed by accolades including Michelin and New York Times recognition [5], [6].
Food Overview
While not always categorized as a traditional steakhouse, the menu features stellar highlights like succulent steak tartare, exceptional steaks, and a highly praised prime rib prepared tableside [1], [2], [8]. For lighter options, the chilled pea soup and avocado crab louis salad are recommended favorites [5]. Less positive feedback was noted regarding the tableside omelette, which some found visually appealing but lacking in depth of flavor [8].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •steak tartare(6)
- •steaks (off-menu)(5)
- •duck breast pasta(5)
- •omelette(5)
- •prime rib(3)
- •honey mustard duckling(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently rave about the impeccable service, atmospheric dining room, and professional hospitality, often citing it as a top-tier choice for celebrations [1], [4]. While generally positive, some diners note the high price makes it an infrequent splurge, and a small minority feel it lacks the traditional feel of a classic steakhouse [6], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE GRILL / THE POOL
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Seeking Recommendation For Good Italian Pasta In
"Recommended for its pressed duck pasta."
PositiveFrom post: Private Dinner Recommendations Near Grand Central
"Suggested as a potential venue for a small private party."
NeutralFrom post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The restaurant is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Best Dinner For Two Including Cocktailswine For
"The restaurant is recommended as part of a list of high-quality dining spots."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Notes The Grill offers trolley service prime rib for $110."
Neutral