Next.js logo

MORGENSTERN'S FINEST ICE CREAM

Updated

Phone: (917) 657-3942

Address: 490 LAGUARDIA PLACE 10012

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Innovative ice cream flavors, from classic to wild. Vegan options & unique combos. Some say pricey, but a must-try for dessert lovers.

Reddit Sentiment for MORGENSTERN'S FINEST ICE CREAM(based on 42 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive26% Neutral24% Negative

Tags

american 16desserts 4dessert 2ice cream 36dessert 6soft serve 2View All

Neighborhoods

Greenwich Village

Instagram Posts References

Morgenstern's is featured for its inventive and indulgent dessert, indicating a creative approach to ice cream offerings that go beyond traditional sundaes.

Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream is featured for its array of delicious soft serve flavors, with particular commendation for their vegan peanut butter and banana options, described as divine.

Details

Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream offers a creative and diverse range of ice cream flavors, from classic to unconventional, making it a must-visit for dessert enthusiasts. While many praise their inventive options and non-dairy choices, some find the prices steep and service inconsistent. Despite occasional drawbacks, its unique flavor profiles and high-quality ingredients continue to draw crowds seeking a memorable frozen treat.

Food Overview

Morgenstern's is celebrated for its extensive and creative ice cream menu, featuring both familiar and adventurous flavors. Popular recommendations include their non-dairy options and unique combinations like raspberry black sesame and even a Brown Sugar Chicken and Waffle Sundae. While the variety is a major draw, a few customers found certain flavors, like salted caramel pretzel, too salty, and some noted that even basic flavors like vanilla were not always impressive. There's also a noted policy against giving samples, which has drawn some criticism.

Highlights / Recommended

Customers frequently recommend trying unique flavors like raspberry black sesame and the vegan peanut butter and banana soft serves. The Brown Sugar Chicken and Waffle Sundae is highlighted as an adventurous and surprisingly delightful option.

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally praise the inventive and high-quality ice cream flavors, with particular acclaim for non-dairy and unique options. However, some feedback indicates that the pricing is on the higher side and service can be inconsistent.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MORGENSTERN'S FINEST ICE CREAM

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1kgcv7d/fried_onion_burger_from_hamburger_america_by/
This comment recommends Morgenstern's for an indulgent treat after a meal, specifically highlighting the raspberry black sesame ice cream as a favorite. It also notes a negative experience where staff refused to mix flavors for a milkshake.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1kihhur/are_there_any_good_ice_cream_spots_that_have_a/
Several users recommend Morgenstern's for its unique and inventive ice cream flavors, noting that the menu rotates frequently. Examples of interesting flavors like Cheddar Cheese Ritz Bits and Hennessy Honeycomb are mentioned.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1mnh39b/three_days_in_nyc_trip_report/
In a trip report, a user found the peaches and cream ice cream at Morgensterns to be great, but noted that the salted caramel pretzel flavor was too salty. Another commenter praised the service at Morgensterns as the best they've experienced.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1odand8/which_ice_cream_places_have_the_best_top_tier/
This thread discusses the closing of Morgenstern's, with users lamenting its closure and recalling specific flavors like burnt honey vanilla. It's also mentioned that in their final weeks, they stopped making fresh ice cream and had limited flavors.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1k66hbg/dairy_free_eats_in_nyc/
Morgenstern's is recommended for its non-dairy ice cream options, with one user specifically suggesting it for those seeking alternatives beyond sorbets. However, another user stated that the non-dairy ice cream at Morgenstern's is bad.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1lsixlk/best_ice_cream_in_the_city_not_gelato/
Morgenstern's is mentioned as having a large variety of ice cream flavors (75), but it is also noted as being a bit pricey. Other users also recommend it as a good ice cream spot.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1luxvwn/spots_that_are_comically_overpriced_but_you_still/
Some users find Morgenstern's to be overpriced with small scoops, and one even blacklisted it due to a negative service experience. Others note that buying by the pint makes the cost more acceptable.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Ice Cream Shops With Multiple Vanilla Flavors

"This user expressed sadness about Morgenstern's closing and specifically missed their burnt honey vanilla ice cream."

Negative
Feb 13, 2026View Comment →

From post: Ice Cream Shops With Multiple Vanilla Flavors

"This user mentioned Morgenstern's in response to a question about vanilla ice cream flavors."

Neutral
Feb 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Which Ice Cream Places Have The Best Top Tier

"Responding to the news of Morgenstern's closing, this user noted they stopped making fresh ice cream in their final weeks and only had a few flavors left. They inquired about the specific flavors available on the last day."

Neutral
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Which Ice Cream Places Have The Best Top Tier

"This user discovered Morgenstern's was closing through this post and expressed sadness about it."

Negative
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Which Ice Cream Places Have The Best Top Tier

"This user confirmed that Morgenstern's stopped making fresh ice cream in its final two weeks, drastically reducing their flavor options to only four on their last day."

Negative
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

More in Greenwich Village

See all

More American in NYC

See all