Classic NY pizza slices, esp. Sicilian & Grandma. Faves: Brooklyn, Pesano, cup n char grandma pie.
A go-to spot for classic New York-style pizza, this establishment offers a variety of delicious slices and whole pies. Reviewers rave about their Sicilian and Grandma slices, with particular praise for the cup and char grandma pie. While generally well-regarded, some suggest it might not always have the freshest pies due to high demand.
This spot is celebrated for its New York-style pizza, with standout mentions for their Sicilian and Grandma slices. The 'tomato Sicilian with extra garlic' and the 'cup n char grandma whole pie' are highlighted as must-tries. While slices are popular, some feedback suggests that entire pies may not always be fresh due to the high volume of orders.
"Highly recommended are the Brooklyn slice, Pesano slice, and Grandma slice. The tomato Sicilian with extra garlic and the cup and char grandma whole pie are also specifically praised."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, frequently recommending the various pizza slices and pies. Some note that freshness can occasionally be an issue due to high demand.
Important Note
Due to high volume, entire pies may not always be as fresh as desired.
"This user mentions Williamsburg Pizza as a place to get good pizza, especially if buying slices."
Positive"The user mentioned Williamsburg Pizza as a place that offers a vegan pepperoni option, describing it as fine and unfussy at best."
Neutral"This user finds Williamsburg Pizza solid and likes their grandma slices, though they note it's not the best and doesn't do enough volume to always have fresh pies."
Neutral"This user recommends Williamsburg Pizza, suggesting to try their fresh cup and char grandma whole pie, describing it as a "work of art.""
Positive"The user highly recommends Williamsburg Pizza, stating it's their favorite and praising all their slices, specifically mentioning the Brooklyn, Pesano, and Grandma slices as favorites."
Positive"Expresses enjoyment of Williamsburg Pizza's tomato Sicilian pizza, particularly when ordered with extra garlic."
Positive
