Classic NY pizza w/ standout Sicilian & Grandma slices. Try the 'cup n char' grandma pie!
This neighborhood pizza joint is a go-to for many, offering classic New York slices with a reliable taste. Reviewers praise their Sicilian and Grandma slices, with some highlighting the unique 'cup and char' grandma pie as a must-try. It's a solid choice for a no-fuss, delicious pizza experience.
Known for its classic New York-style pizza, Williamsburg Pizza receives high praise for its Sicilian and Grandma slices. The 'cup and char' Grandma pie is frequently mentioned as a standout. While most feedback is positive, one user noted that the volume of business can sometimes impact the freshness of pies available.
"The Sicilian and Grandma slices are highly recommended, with a particular shout-out to the 'cup and char' Grandma whole pie."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, frequently recommending the pizza, especially specific slices like Sicilian and Grandma. Some note consistency can vary, but overall it's seen as a reliable spot.
Important Note
While generally well-regarded, one user noted that the restaurant's high volume might sometimes mean pies aren't as fresh as they could be.
"Williamsburg Pizza is mentioned as a place that served classic, reliable NY pizza tasting the same as it always has, in contrast to trendier modern options."
Positive"This user mentions Williamsburg Pizza as a place to get good pizza, especially if buying slices."
Positive"The user mentioned Williamsburg Pizza as a place that offers a vegan pepperoni option, describing it as fine and unfussy at best."
Neutral"This user finds Williamsburg Pizza solid and likes their grandma slices, though they note it's not the best and doesn't do enough volume to always have fresh pies."
Neutral"This user recommends Williamsburg Pizza, suggesting to try their fresh cup and char grandma whole pie, describing it as a "work of art.""
Positive"The user highly recommends Williamsburg Pizza, stating it's their favorite and praising all their slices, specifically mentioning the Brooklyn, Pesano, and Grandma slices as favorites."
Positive"Expresses enjoyment of Williamsburg Pizza's tomato Sicilian pizza, particularly when ordered with extra garlic."
Positive
