Italian eatery known for standout burgers w/ shoestring onions & amazing bread & olive oil. Signature lasagna & babka bread pudding are must-tries!
This Italian spot offers a sophisticated yet approachable dining experience, with a focus on classic dishes elevated by quality ingredients. Reviewers frequently praise the excellent bread and olive oil, and the highly-rated burgers with shoestring onions. For a comforting and rich option, the signature Lasagne Della Nonna is a must-try, featuring homemade pasta and a slow-cooked bolognese. The atmosphere is often described as quirky and fun, making it suitable for various occasions.
The Italian cuisine here receives a generally positive reception, with specific mentions of excellent bread and olive oil, and highly-rated burgers featuring shoestring onions. The Lasagne Della Nonna is a signature dish, lauded for its homemade pasta and rich bolognese. While most feedback is positive, one user advises against dining here.
"Standout dishes include the highly-rated burgers with shoestring onions, the signature Lasagne Della Nonna, and the babka bread pudding."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, highlighting good food and pleasant outdoor seating. However, there is one notable dissenting opinion advising to avoid it.
Important Note
One user explicitly recommended avoiding this restaurant.
"Marks Off Madison is listed as a dining option."
Neutral"Marks off Madison is listed as a restaurant in the general area that might suit the user's needs."
Neutral"This restaurant serves shoestring onions on their burger and likely offers them as a side as well, with the burger itself being highly rated."
Positive"Marks off Madison serves shoestring onions as a side dish, often accompanying their burger."
Positive"Responding to a comment about dog-friendliness, this user recommended Marks off Madison. They noted it has outdoor seating and possibly heat lamps, and has been dog-friendly in their experience."
Positive"This user credits A Voce for the first ricotta toast they had in the early 2000s, suggesting it was a significant early example of the dish."
Positive"Marks Off Madison is described as a quirky and fun spot with a modern take on Jewish deli vibes. The babka bread pudding is particularly recommended as a must-try item."
Positive"This user mentioned Marks off Madison for good bread and olive oil."
Positive"Mark's on Madison is mentioned as not being too far from the area and offering nice outdoor seating."
Positive"Mark Off Madison was included in a comprehensive list of restaurants that did not make it onto the 2025 NY Times list."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended as a dining option located within a 10-minute walk from Gramercy Park."
Neutral"Appropriate-Knee9169 recommends avoiding Mark's Off Madison."
Negative"Expresses agreement with the recommendation of Marks off Madison."
Positive"Recommends Marks off Madison for lunch, highlighting its good food and pleasant outdoor seating."
Positive"Recommends Mark Off Madison and suggests going to Madison Square Park."
Positive"Marks off Madison"
Neutral
