Upscale Italian with a deli vibe. Standouts incl. amazing Lasagne Della Nonna & must-try babka bread pudding.
This Italian eatery offers a refined yet comfortable dining experience, reminiscent of a classic New York deli with a modern twist. Reviewers frequently highlight the exceptional quality of their pasta dishes, particularly the signature Lasagne Della Nonna, and praise the addictive babka bread pudding. While generally well-regarded, some have noted that certain dishes or the overall experience might not meet everyone's expectations.
The Italian cuisine here is a highlight, with specific praise for the homemade Lasagne Della Nonna, described as a rich and comforting dish with layers of slow-cooked bolognese and béchamel. The babka bread pudding is also a frequently recommended dessert. While the fries are noted as a particularly good side, one opinion suggests avoiding some American/Italian offerings.
"The Lasagne Della Nonna is highlighted as a signature dish, praised for its rich layers and homemade pasta. The babka bread pudding is also a strongly recommended dessert."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, appreciating its unique atmosphere and standout dishes like the lasagna and babka bread pudding. However, there are some mixed opinions, with a few diners suggesting it might not live up to the highest expectations.
Important Note
One user suggests avoiding the restaurant, indicating that not all experiences may be positive.
"Responding to a comment about dog-friendliness, this user recommended Marks off Madison. They noted it has outdoor seating and possibly heat lamps, and has been dog-friendly in their experience."
Positive"This user credits A Voce for the first ricotta toast they had in the early 2000s, suggesting it was a significant early example of the dish."
Positive"Marks Off Madison is described as a quirky and fun spot with a modern take on Jewish deli vibes. The babka bread pudding is particularly recommended as a must-try item."
Positive"This user mentioned Marks off Madison for good bread and olive oil."
Positive"Mark's on Madison is mentioned as not being too far from the area and offering nice outdoor seating."
Positive"Mark Off Madison was included in a comprehensive list of restaurants that did not make it onto the 2025 NY Times list."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended as a dining option located within a 10-minute walk from Gramercy Park."
Neutral"Appropriate-Knee9169 recommends avoiding Mark's Off Madison."
Negative"Expresses agreement with the recommendation of Marks off Madison."
Positive"Recommends Marks off Madison for lunch, highlighting its good food and pleasant outdoor seating."
Positive"Recommends Mark Off Madison and suggests going to Madison Square Park."
Positive"Marks off Madison"
Neutral
