Last Updated: ~2 months ago
Phone: (646) 360-2346
Address: 167 WEST 48 STREET 10036
Thick, stretchy cheese on their Sicilian slice is a must-try. A classic NYC slice joint with a solid reputation.
For a taste of classic New York pizza, this spot offers a variety of slices that cater to different preferences. The Sicilian slice is a must-try, praised for its generous and satisfyingly stretchy cheese. While it might present as a typical busy pizzeria with a wide selection, including chicken pizzas, and even offers ranch dressing, these characteristics don't detract from the generally positive feedback on the pizza itself. It's a solid choice for a quick, reliable slice in the heart of Manhattan.
This establishment is primarily known for its pizza, with the Sicilian slice being a highly recommended item due to its thick and stretchy cheese. While not explicitly bad, some patrons categorize it as a typical "yellow flag" pizzeria, possibly due to a wide variety of pies including chicken options and the availability of ranch dressing. The pizza quality is generally described as average or typical for its category, but the Sicilian slice receives specific praise.
"The Sicilian slice is highly recommended, specifically for its thick and stretchy cheese."
Customers generally have a positive view of the pizza, with specific mentions of the Sicilian slice being a standout. While some comments note that the establishment might fit a typical "yellow flag" profile for pizzerias, this is not necessarily indicative of bad pizza, but rather catering to a broader audience with offerings like chicken pizzas and ranch dressing. Overall sentiment leans towards satisfaction with the pizza quality, considering it typical for its kind.
Important Note
Some users consider it a typical 'yellow flag' establishment due to a wide variety of pies including chicken and the offering of ranch dressing, though this is not necessarily a reflection of poor pizza quality.
"Little Italy Pizza is generally considered good, despite being a type of place that might typically raise yellow flags like having many pies displayed."
Positive"Little Italy Pizza, with multiple locations in Manhattan, provides ranch dressing alongside other condiments, and its pizza quality is described as typical for such a place, implying average."
Neutral"The user describes pizzerias in midtown like Little Italy Pizza as a yellow flag due to displaying many pies with chicken toppings in the front window, suggesting they cater to a different crowd, though not necessarily implying bad pizza."
Neutral"The user believes the post is an advertisement."
Neutral"Notes that Italy Pizza in Midtown doesn't participate in the Seamless deal every day."
Neutral"Recommends the Sicilian slice from Little Italy Pizza, noting its thick and stretchy cheese."
Positive
