TLDR
Thick, stretchy cheese on classic NY slices & Sicilian! A go-to for locals, offering a reliable pizza experience.
Details
This Manhattan pizza joint serves up classic New York slices with a focus on quality ingredients. Customers rave about the cheesy, stretchy goodness, particularly recommending the Sicilian slice. While generally well-regarded, it's noted that not all locations participate in daily deals, and some find the extensive display of chicken pies a bit of a yellow flag, though not necessarily indicative of poor quality.
Food Overview
The pizza here is a highlight, with a focus on classic New York style and Sicilian slices. The cheese is frequently praised for being thick and stretchy. While most feedback is positive, one observation notes that a wide variety of chicken pizzas displayed might be a 'yellow flag' for some, though not necessarily a reflection of poor pizza quality.
Caveats
Not all locations may participate in daily deals consistently. The display of numerous chicken pizzas in the window is noted as a potential 'yellow flag' by some, though not necessarily indicating poor quality.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE ITALY PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recommendations Please
"This is a recommendation for a pizza place located near the 9/11 Memorial. It's described as a typical New York pizza spot that many locals frequent."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias
"Little Italy Pizza is generally considered good, despite being a type of place that might typically raise yellow flags like having many pies displayed."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias
"Little Italy Pizza, with multiple locations in Manhattan, provides ranch dressing alongside other condiments, and its pizza quality is described as typical for such a place, implying average."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias
"The user describes pizzerias in midtown like Little Italy Pizza as a yellow flag due to displaying many pies with chicken toppings in the front window, suggesting they cater to a different crowd, though not necessarily implying bad pizza."
Neutral