Charming vintage tavern w/ Shaker-inspired American fare. Acclaimed chefs behind Via Carota. Cozy ambiance & warm service.
Step into a charming vintage tavern inspired by 1700s Shaker culture, where culinary quality meets cozy ambiance. This spot, from the acclaimed team behind Via Carota, offers hearty, satisfying American fare with a focus on roasted and grilled dishes. Enjoy a delightful experience with interesting cocktails and warm, welcoming service, perfect for anything from weekday breakfast to bustling weekend brunch.
The food here is described as old-school British-American with a Shaker influence. Standout dishes frequently mentioned include their pancakes (often rated as top-tier) and a seared, dry-aged ribeye. Other praised items include the farmer's plate and patty melt, though the potatoes on the farmer's plate have been noted as soggy. The branzino with ramps is a seasonal favorite from the past.
"Highly recommended dishes include their pancakes, often cited as among the best in NYC, and the patty melt. The seared, dry-aged ribeye and seasonal dishes like branzino with ramps have also received praise."
Customers overwhelmingly recommend this restaurant, praising its brilliant food, gorgeous classic bar, and cozy atmosphere. It's frequently highlighted as a great spot for brunch and general dining.
Important Note
One comment mentioned that the restaurant no longer serves rotisserie chicken, and another noted it may be more expensive than some comparable establishments.
"The user notes they will look into Commerce Inn as a potential option for their birthday breakfast."
Neutral"Commerce Inn is suggested as a good option if the user decides to stay in Manhattan for their birthday breakfast."
Neutral"This commenter listed Commerce Inn as a potential alternative restaurant option."
Neutral"This commenter suggested Commerce Inn as a dinner option for a date night, noting that reservations were still available. The commenter also shared personal experience about feeling too exhausted after exams to go out."
Neutral"The Commerce Inn is mentioned as being run by the same people who own Via Carota and is described as having very good food and being a great space."
Positive"The Commerce Inn was suggested as a quaint option for dinner, with a link provided for more information."
Neutral"Commerce Inn is listed among the top 5 favorite classic burgers."
Positive"Commerce Inn is suggested as an upscale brunch option."
Positive"Commerce Inn is mentioned, but it does not offer bottomless drink deals."
Neutral"The Commerce Inn is recommended for history and food lovers, inspired by 1700s Shaker culture with early American cuisine. It has a fitting old-timey decor and is known for reliable food from its restaurateur team. The commenter and their history-buff partner enjoyed their meals there."
Positive"A user states they have not tried Commerce Inn for breakfast, thus cannot compare it, but speculates Little Owl might be better than Salt's Cure."
Neutral"A user expresses disbelief at the suggestion that Little Owl might be superior to Commerce Inn."
Positive"A user highly recommends Commerce Inn's pancakes, sausage, and carrots."
Positive"A user notes that Commerce Inn appears to be 1.5-2 times more expensive than Salt's Cure, though they have not personally tried it."
Neutral"A user asks about the quality of pancakes at Commerce Inn."
Neutral"A user suggests that Commerce Inn offers a better breakfast experience than Salt's Cure."
Positive"Commerce Inn is recommended as a dinner option for the 70th birthday celebration."
Positive"This user notes The Commerce Inn is very walk-in friendly, with little to no wait, especially if arriving near opening. They recommend adding seasonal fruit to the pancakes and also praise the patty melt."
Positive"After looking up The Commerce Inn, this user finds the pancakes look delightful and expresses gratitude for the recommendation."
Positive"This user strongly recommends considering The Commerce Inn for pancakes."
Positive
