Revived UWS diner w/ a 70yr history. Offers classic comfort food like burgers & meatloaf alongside a modern cocktail list. A unique high-low experience.
This classic American diner, a fixture for over 70 years on the Upper West Side, has been revived with a modern twist. It offers a blend of nostalgic comfort food like burgers and meatloaf alongside a surprisingly upscale cocktail menu, providing a unique high-low dining experience.
This diner is known for its classic American comfort food, with specific mentions of its BLT, burgers, and meatloaf. Customers have also praised their Eggs Benedict served on a crispy potato pancake. While generally well-regarded, one review noted a decline in food quality and diner atmosphere after a remodel.
"The diner is recommended for its BLT, classic burgers, and meatloaf. The Eggs Benedict served on a crispy potato pancake is also a notable dish."
Overall, customers have a positive sentiment towards the diner, praising its classic American fare and family-friendly atmosphere. However, some recent feedback suggests a change in the menu and a less authentic diner feel post-renovation.
Important Note
Some recent reviews suggest that the diner's remodel may have altered its traditional diner feel, with changes to the menu and service.
"Old John's Luncheonette is recommended as a place to get a burger."
Positive"Old John's Diner is an old reliable spot where one can sit at the counter, meet people, and enjoy cheesecake or pie for dessert."
Positive"This user acknowledges Old John Diner is very good but describes it as pricey and bougie."
Neutral"This user agrees Old John Diner is good but notes it's a bit niche and still a little pricey."
Neutral"This user states they have only been a few times but found Old John Diner to be solid."
Positive"Old John's Diner is described as the best diner on the Upper West Side."
Positive"A former fan notes that Old John's Luncheonette has been remodeled with a changed menu and lackluster service, suggesting it no longer feels like a diner."
Negative"A user expresses their affection for Old John's Luncheonette near Lincoln Center."
Positive"Old John's Luncheonette is a restaurant that the commenter enjoys."
Positive"Recommends Old John's Luncheonette as a place serving basic food."
Positive"User recommends Old John's Luncheonette, highlighting that their potato pancake base for Eggs Benedict is very crispy."
Positive"User suggests Old John's Luncheonette by providing a Google Maps link, implying it serves the requested Eggs Benedict."
Positive"The commenter recommends Old John's Diner as a kid-friendly option where inappropriate language from drunk patrons is unlikely."
Positive"good NYC diner feel but the food is a little more upscale"
Positive"Old John’s luncheonette has a very good one!"
Positive
