Quintessential UWS diner w/ revamped menu – think burgers & meatloaf w/ modern cocktails. Perfect for pre-show bite!
This classic Upper West Side diner has been revived with an updated menu that includes beloved favorites like burgers and meatloaf, all while maintaining its traditional charm. It offers a unique 'high-low' dining experience with a decidedly un-diner-like cocktail list. The diner is known for its quintessential atmosphere and efficient service, making it a reliable spot for a satisfying meal.
The food focuses on classic American diner fare, with highlights like burgers, meatloaf, and a well-regarded BLT. Customers have also enjoyed the potato pancake base for Eggs Benedict and praised the cheesecake and pie. While most feedback is positive, one user noted a change in the menu post-renovation that they found less appealing.
"Standout dishes include the BLT, burgers, and Eggs Benedict with a crispy potato pancake base. Cheesecake and pie are also recommended desserts."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the diner, often praising its classic American and diner food, with specific mentions of good burgers and a positive BLT. Some recent feedback suggests a potential decline in service and atmosphere post-renovation, though many still find it a reliable and enjoyable spot.
Important Note
One commenter noted that after a remodel, the restaurant's menu and service changed and it no longer feels like a traditional diner. Another user describes it as pricey and 'bougie'.
"This commenter recommends the cheesecake at Old John's on the Upper West Side, stating they order it every time they visit."
Positive"This user mentioned Old John's Luncheonette for carrot cake."
Neutral"The commenter had a great tuna melt at Old John's Diner."
Positive"User recommends Old John's Diner on the Upper West Side, calling it very good."
Positive"User notes Old John's is a step above a regular diner but still cute and quintessential."
Positive"User recommends Old John's Luncheonette on the Upper West Side, describing it as quintessential inside."
Positive"User recommends Old John's Luncheonette, upper west side."
Positive"This commenter advises against Old John's Luncheonette, describing it as a hipster imitation of a diner. They suggest authentic NYC diners like Westside Restaurant or Utopia Diner as alternatives."
Negative"A brief mention of 'John's' which is likely referring to Old John's Luncheonette."
Positive"Old John's is mentioned as a potential breakfast spot near Lincoln Center."
Positive"Agreed with the recommendation for Old John's Luncheonette."
Positive"This is a recommended spot for breakfast near Lincoln Center."
Positive"Old John's Luncheonette is recommended as a place to get a burger."
Positive"Old John's Diner is an old reliable spot where one can sit at the counter, meet people, and enjoy cheesecake or pie for dessert."
Positive"This user acknowledges Old John Diner is very good but describes it as pricey and bougie."
Neutral"This user agrees Old John Diner is good but notes it's a bit niche and still a little pricey."
Neutral"This user states they have only been a few times but found Old John Diner to be solid."
Positive"Old John's Diner is described as the best diner on the Upper West Side."
Positive"A former fan notes that Old John's Luncheonette has been remodeled with a changed menu and lackluster service, suggesting it no longer feels like a diner."
Negative"A user expresses their affection for Old John's Luncheonette near Lincoln Center."
Positive
