TLDR
Revamped UWS diner, peak efficiency. Classic American w/ modern cocktails. Great for breakfast, burgers, cheesecake & pie. Quintessential NYC experience [1], [2], [3].
Reddit Sentiment for OLD JOHN'S DINER(based on 26 Reddit opinions)
Details
Old John's Diner, a 70-year-old Upper West Side institution, has been revamped and is now operating at peak efficiency [1]. This classic American diner offers a nostalgic experience with updated menu items like burgers and meatloaf [1], alongside a modern cocktail list [1]. It's a recommended spot for breakfast near Lincoln Center and is known for its quintessential diner feel and delicious desserts like cheesecake [2], [3].
Food Overview
Old John's Diner is renowned for its classic American comfort food, with standout recommendations for burgers, meatloaf, and tuna melts [1], [5], [6]. It's also a popular spot for breakfast, with mentions of challah French toast [2]. Desserts like cheesecake and pie are frequently praised, and the diner is noted for making good egg creams [3], [7]. While generally well-regarded, one opinion suggests it's a "hipster imitation" [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The diner is highly recommended for its burgers and tuna melts. Classic desserts like cheesecake and pie are also highlighted as must-tries, alongside challah French toast and homemade ice cream [1], [2], [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise Old John's Diner as the best on the Upper West Side, highlighting its solid food, quintessential atmosphere, and classic desserts like cheesecake [2], [3]. However, some find it a bit niche and pricey, with one commenter describing it as a "hipster imitation" of a diner [4].
Caveats
One Reddit user described Old John's Luncheonette as a 'hipster imitation' of a diner and suggested seeking out more authentic establishments like Westside Restaurant or Utopia Diner.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLD JOHN'S DINER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Listed John's Luncheonette as a casual burger spot."
PositiveFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"This commenter recommends Old John's Diner, along with other classic diners, noting that diners generally do pancakes well."
PositiveFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"The commenter suggests trying Old John's Diner or other classic diners for pancakes."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user mentioned Old John's as making pretty good egg creams, similar to S&P."
PositiveFrom post: Soon To Be First Time In Nyc As An Irish Person
"Old John's Luncheonette is recommended as a less touristy diner option with better food than those in Midtown and Hell's Kitchen, noting its long history since 1951."
PositiveFrom post: Cheesecake
"This commenter recommends the cheesecake at Old John's on the Upper West Side, stating they order it every time they visit."
PositiveFrom post: Best Carrot Cake In The City
"This user mentioned Old John's Luncheonette for carrot cake."
NeutralFrom post: Tuna Salad
"The commenter had a great tuna melt at Old John's Diner."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User recommends Old John's Diner on the Upper West Side, calling it very good."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User notes Old John's is a step above a regular diner but still cute and quintessential."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User recommends Old John's Luncheonette on the Upper West Side, describing it as quintessential inside."
PositiveFrom post: Help Us Find The Best Diner In Nyc We Want To
"User recommends Old John's Luncheonette, upper west side."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center
"This commenter advises against Old John's Luncheonette, describing it as a hipster imitation of a diner. They suggest authentic NYC diners like Westside Restaurant or Utopia Diner as alternatives."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center
"A brief mention of 'John's' which is likely referring to Old John's Luncheonette."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center
"Old John's is mentioned as a potential breakfast spot near Lincoln Center."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center
"Agreed with the recommendation for Old John's Luncheonette."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Near Lincoln Center
"This is a recommended spot for breakfast near Lincoln Center."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"Old John's Luncheonette is recommended as a place to get a burger."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Birthday Dinner Rec
"Old John's Diner is an old reliable spot where one can sit at the counter, meet people, and enjoy cheesecake or pie for dessert."
PositiveFrom post: Recommend Me Your Go To Diner Mines Jumped The
"This user acknowledges Old John Diner is very good but describes it as pricey and bougie."
Neutral