Reddit Sentiment for CHARLES PAN-FRIED CHICKEN(based on 53 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The video highlights the process of frying chicken in a large pan, showing a chef tending to multiple batches, and then showcasing a platter of golden-brown fried chicken along with sides like ribs, cornbread, sweet potatoes, collard greens, and macaroni and cheese. It emphasizes the classic preparation and satisfying meal portions.
Details
A beloved Upper West Side spot, Charles Pan-Fried Chicken is celebrated for its tender, flavorful pan-fried chicken and excellent Southern-style sides [1]. While some find the cornbread dense and dry, others rave about the amazing mac and cheese and even the banana pudding. It's a must-try for authentic soul food in NYC, offering great value [2], [3].
Food Overview
The star of the show is the pan-fried chicken, lauded for its tenderness and flavor [1]. While some users find the cornbread dense and dry [4], others rave about the amazing mac and cheese and even the banana pudding [3]. It's consistently recommended as a top spot for Southern-style fried chicken and soul food in NYC, offering great value, though it's not a Cajun restaurant [5], [6].
Caveats
The restaurant is primarily a take-out spot with limited counter space and no seating or bathroom facilities [5], [6]. Some users have noted that the cornbread can be dense and dry, and that while the chicken is excellent, the sides may not always match that quality.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CHARLES PAN-FRIED CHICKEN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Sylvias Has Fallen To A New Low And Is Now Going
"The user asserts that Charles Pan-Fried Chicken's fried chicken surpasses even the best places in Charlotte, NC, and compares it favorably to New Orleans chicken, while noting NYC's general limitations with authentic southern food."
PositiveFrom post: Sylvias Has Fallen To A New Low And Is Now Going
"The commenter praises Charles' fried chicken as unmatched in its class in NYC and generally finds their mac and cheese to be good, though acknowledges it might have been an off day for the sides."
PositiveFrom post: Sylvias Has Fallen To A New Low And Is Now Going
"This user agrees that Charles Pan-Fried Chicken is superior to Sylvia's."
PositiveFrom post: Sylvias Has Fallen To A New Low And Is Now Going
"Following a disappointing meal at Sylvia's, the user visited Charles Pan-Fried Chicken and found their fried chicken to be satisfying. However, they noted that the sides (mac & cheese, yams, okra) were not as good as Sylvia's, though acknowledged Charles is known for its chicken."
PositiveFrom post: Still Havent Found A Great Waffle Place In New
"This user acknowledged that Charles' waffles can be inconsistent, sometimes great and sometimes mediocre. They still rate it over Clinton Street Baking Co. due to being cheaper and not requiring a long wait."
NeutralFrom post: Still Havent Found A Great Waffle Place In New
"In response to a comment about Charles' waffles, this user agreed they were good but stated that if the waffles were on par with the chicken, they would agree with higher praise."
NeutralFrom post: Still Havent Found A Great Waffle Place In New
"Charles Pan Fried Chicken was mentioned for their waffles, with the author considering them good but not great."
NeutralFrom post: Which Places Have Become Part Of Your Regular
"Charles Pan Fried has been a staple for the commenter for several years and remains so."
PositiveFrom post: Delish Lunch Upper West Side Dining Solo
"Charles Fried Chicken is listed as an inexpensive, eat-standing-up option within the user's specified area."
PositiveFrom post: Which Nonfast Food Chicken Sandwiches And Tender
"This user stated that Charles Pan Fried Chicken serves some of the best chicken in the city, although not in sandwich form."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user describes Charles Pan Fried Chicken as solid, but notes that Southern fried chicken is generally superior. They also mention Bobwhite has declined and RedHead is gone."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user argues that it's helpful to manage expectations by stating NYC fried chicken isn't as good as Southern options, comparing it to Katz's as an overrated spot."
NegativeFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user defends the previous negative comment about Charles Pan Fried Chicken, stating it's unhelpful to compare NYC options to Southern ones if the OP isn't traveling."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user agrees with the previous comment stating Charles Pan Fried Chicken is not top-tier."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user rates Charles Pan Fried Chicken as solid but not top-tier compared to Southern standards."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user states Charles Pan Fried Chicken is 'absolutely top tier' for fried chicken, though wishes they had a spicy version."
PositiveFrom post: Quick Bite Between Met Opera And Levain Bakery On
"This commenter also recommended Charles Fried Chicken, specifically mentioning their 2-piece special and limited counter space."
PositiveFrom post: Quick Bite Between Met Opera And Levain Bakery On
"Charles Pan Fried Chicken was mentioned as a popular option near Levain Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Soul Food In The City
"Charles' Pan Fried is mentioned as a solid soul food option alongside other popular choices."
PositiveFrom post: Soul Food In The City
"Charles Pan Fried is suggested as a good option for soul food."
Positive