Last Updated: 17 days ago
Phone: (212) 680-4265
Address: 118 GREENWICH AVENUE 10011
A cozy West Village spot with a classic NYC feel, celebrated for its ambiance and wood-fired steaks.
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, this contemporary American restaurant offers a dining experience that is frequently lauded for its ambiance and classic New York feel. It's a popular choice for those seeking a cozy and celebratory dinner spot, with multiple recommendations across various online forums. The cuisine focuses on American classics, with specific highlights including oysters and steak, particularly the wood-fired variety. While the atmosphere and overall dining experience garner significant praise, some diners have noted that it may not offer a unique culinary experience compared to other cities, suggesting it might be more about the ambiance than groundbreaking cuisine.
The restaurant is recommended for its American cuisine, with specific mentions of oysters and steak. One user specifically recommended the wood-fired steak. While generally well-received, one reviewer felt it was comparable to options found in other mid-size American cities, suggesting it might not be exceptional value for money.
"The wood-fired steak is a highly recommended dish, with mentions of oysters also being a good choice."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the restaurant, with multiple recommendations for various occasions like celebratory dinners and cozy evenings. Several users specifically highlight its great ambiance and classic New York feel as significant draws. While most feedback is positive, one user noted that it might be comparable to options in other cities, potentially at a lower cost.
Important Note
One user noted that the restaurant might be comparable to options in other mid-size American cities and could potentially be more expensive.
"Jack and Charlie's 118 is suggested as a place to eat. No specific dish or detailed sentiment is provided."
Neutral"Jack & Charlie's was also recommended by Garconavecunreve as a good option for wood-fired steak."
Positive"Jack & Charlie's was recommended by ChefSuffolk as a good place for wood-fired steak."
Positive"The user 'mgianfal' positively recommends Jack and Charlies as a good option for dinner."
Positive"Jack and Charlie's 118 is suggested as a potential option for the dinner."
Neutral"Jack & Charlies is recommended as a dinner spot."
Positive"The commenter loves Jack & Charlies, recommending it for a celebratory dinner due to its great ambiance and classic NYC feel, aligning with the original poster's request for such a venue."
Positive"Jack and Charlies was recommended by mgianfal as a dinner option for a solo diner in the West Village/Soho area. The original poster was looking for an American restaurant with a nice ambiance under $100pp."
Positive"Jack & Charlies 118 was suggested as a cozy dinner spot."
Positive"Recommends Jack & Charlies 118."
Positive"User lists Jack & Charlie's No. 118 (as Jack & Charlie) as a medium-end option for burgers."
Positive"The commenter believes Jack & Charlie’s No. 118 (referred to with a typo as No. 1998) is not bad but comparable to, or even surpassed by, options in other mid-size American cities, potentially at a lower cost. They also categorize several other restaurants from the OP's list as average or overpriced."
Neutral"The commenter listed 'Jack & Charlies' as a dining suggestion for the West Village/Soho area, understood to be the contemporary American restaurant Jack & Charlie's."
Neutral"The commenter later added Jack & Charlie's, a contemporary American restaurant, to their list of suggestions for the West Village/Soho area after initially forgetting it."
Neutral"Suggested as a place for food."
Positive"Lists Jack and Charlies as a potential option."
Neutral
