TLDR
Experience 'New Wave' NY-style slices featuring a unique, four-day fermented fluffy crust and signature garlic confit sauce.
Details
Renowned for its 'New Wave' take on NY-style slices, this Park Slope destination features a four-day fermented dough that creates a distinctively fluffy crust [1], [2]. The shop specializes in thin, crispy grandma-style pizza enhanced by garlic confit and a buttery finish [3]. While many patrons consider it a top-tier city favorite for pizza and meatballs, the brand has faced scrutiny regarding consistency across locations and a notable 'C' health rating [2], [4], [5].
Food Overview
The menu centers on 'New Wave' pizza, with the grandma-style pie and its garlic confit sauce frequently highlighted as standout options [1], [3]. Customers are generally enthusiastic about the fluffy, well-charred crust, though some critics find the dough too thick or inconsistent at express locations [1], [2], [5].
Caveats
Potential visitors should be aware of a documented 'C' health rating, which has been a point of concern for some diners [2]. Additionally, the express locations have received criticism for offering smaller, sometimes dry slices that do not match the quality of the main Park Slope shop [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN DOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Recommended pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Simple Delicious Meatballs Of Any
"Highly recommended for their meatball dish and phenomenal pizza, suggesting it is worth a visit for a slice and a plate of meatballs."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This commenter suggested Brooklyn DOP in Park Slope for its fluffy crust, which they believe the original poster is looking for."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This commenter simply recommended DOP, located a block off the Union St stop."
NeutralFrom post: Best Slice Of Pizza In Prospect Heightsft
"This commenter finds the Brooklyn DOP express shop in the area to be not as good as the park slope location, noting it's expensive with small, sometimes dry slices, and limited topping options."
NegativeFrom post: Best Slice Of Pizza In Prospect Heightsft
"This commenter disagrees with a previous mention of Brooklyn DOP Fast Life, stating they thought it would be good but felt the money was spent on decor rather than quality."
NegativeFrom post: Best Slice Of Pizza In Prospect Heightsft
"This commenter notes that Brooklyn DOP Fast Life (on Fulton and St. James in Clinton Hill) is a fairly new and pretty solid option."
PositiveFrom post: How Does My Memorial Day Weekend Plan Sound For
"Brooklyn DOP is suggested as a good pizza option near Barclays Center."
PositiveFrom post: 4 Days Eating Through Nyc
"The user found Brooklyn DOP slices to be excellent."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill
"Expresses love for Brooklyn DOP but has reservations due to its 'C' health rating."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill
"Recommends Brooklyn DOP in Park Slope as worth the trip, describing it as one of their favorite slices in the city. Notes it's a 10-15 minute walk from Boerum Hill."
PositiveFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"The commenter agreed that the use of fake powdered parmesan at D.O.P. Pizza was unforgivable, especially given the restaurant's name."
NegativeFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"The commenter's husband could not forgive D.O.P. Pizza for putting fake powdered parmesan on his slice without asking."
NegativeFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"The commenter finds D.O.P. Pizza too thick and doughy, preferring other iconic NYC spots despite acknowledging good char and flavor in the dough."
NegativeFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"The commenter recommended D.O.P. Pizza in Park Slope."
PositiveFrom post: Authenticold Fashioned Ny Restaurants With Vegan
"This user listed Brooklyn DOP as a place with vegan pizza/slice options."
PositiveFrom post: Traveling In January Best Splurge And Pizza Recs
"Brooklyn DOP is categorized as a "New Wave" NY-style slice and is recommended."
Positive