TLDR
Classic NYC-style cheese slices that surprise and delight after a Broadway show. A highly-rated, convenient go-to for top-tier pizza.
Details
Located in the heart of Manhattan, this pizza destination has gained a reputation as a must-visit spot for both casual diners and theater-goers after a show [1]. Many visitors count its classic cheese slices among their absolute favorites from their New York City trips [1]. While most feedback is glowing, with some even calling it the best slice they have tried among many city staples, opinions on the quality vary among locals [2, 5].
Caveats
Some local diners express mixed feelings, suggesting that it may not meet the high standards of every pizza enthusiast in the city [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ANDIAMO PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Pizza Place Near Bryant Park It Doesnt
"Highly recommended, with the user claiming it is the best they have tried out of ten places."
PositiveFrom post: Walk Up Pizza Spot That Starts With A
"This user suggested Andiamo as a possible restaurant, mentioning it in the context of potentially mind-blowing pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up Pizza Spot That Starts With A
"This user inquired if the restaurant was Andiamo pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up Pizza Spot That Starts With A
"This user asked if the restaurant in question was Andiamo, specifying its location at 28th & 6th."
NeutralFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This commenter praised the pizza choices from the original post, specifically mentioning Andiamo Pizza, and expressed relief that L'Industrie and Mama's Too were not included."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This comment suggests that the 'Andiamo spice' looks like the best option from the list of foods mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This commenter believes Andiamo Pizza is 'mid' and implies the original poster is not from NYC for including it."
NegativeFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"In response to a positive comment about Andiamo Pizza, the author stated they were happy to have stumbled upon it and found it delicious."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"This commenter randomly found Andiamo Pizza after a Broadway show and found a special slice to be one of the best they've had."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Nights In Your Marvellous City
"The author listed 'Andiamo Pizza' with a classic cheese slice as one of their favorites from their NYC trip."
Positive